Legislature Class 11 Question Answer | NCERT Political Science Chapter 5 Solutions Skip to content
Smart Notes for Every Exam · instant PDF download after payment +91 92520 37565
NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 5

Chapter 5: Legislature (Legislature)

NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 5: Legislature (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on Parliament, the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, law making, control of the executive and committees, plus the in-text questions and cartoons. All 25 questions are answered in full.

NCERT textbook Chapter 5 (PDF)

Exam revision? Chapter 5 notes with key points, diagrams and practice questions: see the free sample · ₹199 for all 18 chapters

Free NCERT solutions by Notes Bazar · www.notesbazar.in/ncert-solutions/class-11-polsci/legislature

Exercises

1
Alok thinks that a country needs an efficient government that looks after the welfare of the people. So, if we simply elected our Prime Minister and Ministers and left to them the task of government, we will not need a legislature. Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer.
Solution

No, I do not agree. A legislature is needed even if the Prime Minister and ministers are elected, for these reasons:

  1. It controls the executive. Without it a government with unlimited and arbitrary powers could slip into a Cabinet dictatorship. The legislature can question ministers, approve or refuse laws, control the money and, through a no-confidence motion, dismiss the government.
  2. It makes sure the government stays accountable. Even a strong leader must face the Parliament and answer to its satisfaction, and the legislature helps the people hold their representatives accountable.
  3. It is the most representative organ. It represents the divergent views of regional, social, economic and religious groups and is the highest forum of debate on every national issue.
  4. It performs financial, constituent, electoral and judicial functions: no new tax can be levied without its approval, and it amends the Constitution and elects the President and Vice President.

Efficiency is not the only aim of government; a government that is not under the control of an elected legislature would not be democratic. A genuine democracy is inconceivable without a representative, efficient and effective legislature.

2
A class was debating the merits of a bicameral system. The following points were made during the discussion. Read the arguments and say if you agree or disagree with each of them, giving reasons.
  1. Neha said that bicameral legislature does not serve any purpose.
  2. Shama argued that experts should be nominated in the second chamber.
  3. Tridib said that if a country is not a federation, then there is no need to have a second chamber.
Solution
  1. Disagree with Neha. A second house gives representation to all sections of society and all regions in large and diverse countries, and it makes it possible to have every decision reconsidered: every bill is discussed twice, which gives a double check and lets haste be corrected.
  2. Agree with Shama. The Rajya Sabha has twelve members nominated by the President from persons who have made their mark in literature, science, art and social service. As Purnima Banerji said in the Constituent Assembly, those who cannot enter the rough and tumble of active politics can advise the lower house. Such persons can raise the quality of debate.
  3. Partly disagree with Tridib. A second chamber is especially important in a federation, as in India, where the Rajya Sabha represents the States and protects their powers (a matter affecting the State list needs its approval). But it is not only for federations: large size and diversity, and the need for a revising, second look at laws, are other reasons for two houses.
3
Why can the Lok Sabha control the executive more effectively than the Rajya Sabha can?
Solution

The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha and not to the Rajya Sabha. A ministry that loses the confidence of the Lok Sabha must resign, and only the Lok Sabha can pass a no-confidence motion. The Lok Sabha also controls the purse: it approves taxation, the budget and the annual financial statements, and the Rajya Sabha cannot initiate, reject or amend money bills. The Rajya Sabha can ask questions and criticise the government but cannot remove it. The reason is that the Lok Sabha is directly elected by the people, who are the final authority in a democracy, whereas the Rajya Sabha is elected by the MLAs. So the Constitution gave the crucial powers of removing a government and controlling finances to the directly elected house.

4
Rather than effective control of the executive, the Lok Sabha is a platform for the expression of popular sentiments and people’s expectations. Do you agree? Give reasons.
Solution

Sample answer: I agree only in part. The Lok Sabha is a platform for the views of different regions, groups and parties, and the debates and walkouts do express popular feelings. It is the highest forum of debate with no limitation on discussion. But it has real powers of control: the Question Hour and Zero Hour, committees, approval or refusal of laws (the Prevention of Terrorism Bill 2002 was rejected by the Rajya Sabha, and the opposition forced rollback of fertiliser prices), financial control, and the no-confidence motion. Since 1989 several governments have had to resign after losing the confidence of the Lok Sabha.

However, when a government has a disciplined majority, the power to dismiss is largely fictional, the Cabinet decides the agenda, and the Lok Sabha often merely approves legislation. Declining sittings, absence of quorum and boycotts reduce its control. So the Lok Sabha does both, and its effectiveness in control depends on the political conditions and the working of the House.

5
The following are some proposals for making the Parliament more effective. State if you agree or disagree with each of them and give your reasons. Explain what would be the effect if these suggestions were accepted.
  1. Parliament should work for longer period.
  2. Attendance should be made compulsory for members of Parliament.
  3. Speakers should be empowered to penalise members for interrupting the proceedings of the House.
Solution

Sample answers:

  1. Agree. The chapter notes a gradual decline in the number of sittings and time spent on debates in the last two decades. Longer sessions would give adequate time for thorough discussion of bills, the Question Hour and control of the executive. Effect: better scrutiny and more accountable government, though it would cost more and need members to be available.
  2. Agree, with limits. Attendance matters because the House suffers from absence of quorum and members who are not interested in discussion; compulsory attendance would increase participation and fulfil the duty of representing constituents. But presence alone does not guarantee meaningful debate, and members may have valid reasons to be absent. Effect: fuller House and better quorum, but possibly passive attendance.
  3. Agree, with safeguards. Disruptions waste legislative time. The presiding officer is already the final authority on regulating business, so penalties against persistent interruption would make debate orderly. But walkouts and protests are also political techniques to force executive accountability, so power to penalise must not be used to silence the opposition. Effect: more orderly sessions, but risk of misuse by the ruling side.
6
Arif wanted to know that if ministers propose most of the important bills and if the majority party often gets the government bills passed, what is the role of the Parliament in the law making process? What answer would you give him?
Solution

Although the Cabinet decides the substance and timing of important bills and the government usually has a majority, the Parliament’s role is real:

  1. No bill becomes a law unless the Parliament approves it, and approval cannot be taken for granted; it is the product of bargaining among members of the ruling party or coalition and even between government and opposition. The government must make concessions where it has no majority in the Rajya Sabha (as in 1977 and 2000), and bills have failed, such as the Lok Pal Bill and the Prevention of Terrorism Bill (2002).
  2. Bills are debated in the House, and a large part of the discussion takes place in committees, which act as miniature legislatures and can suggest changes. The Question Hour and debates let members scrutinise the government’s policy.
  3. Public opinion, parties, interest groups and the media influence the Parliament through its members; the opposition can delay a bill, expose its defects or force the government to roll it back.
  4. Members other than ministers can introduce private members’ bills, and the two Houses can reconsider the same bill.

So Parliament is not a rubber stamp; it legitimises, shapes and scrutinises laws and keeps the executive accountable.

7
Which of the following statements you agree with the most? Give your reasons.
  1. Legislators must be free to join any party they want.
  2. Anti-defection law has contributed to the domination of the party leaders over the legislators.
  3. Defection is always for selfish purposes and therefore, a legislator who wants to join another party must be disqualified from being a minister for the next two years.
Solution

Sample answer: I agree most with (b). The chapter says that experience of the past twenty years shows that the anti-defection amendment (52nd Amendment, 1985, modified by the 91st) has not been able to curb defections, but it has given additional powers to the party leadership and the presiding officers over the members. A member who is absent when asked by the party leadership to be present, who votes against the party’s instructions, or voluntarily leaves the party is deemed to have defected and loses membership, so legislators fear to differ from the party line even on matters of conscience.

(a) is not acceptable in full: members are elected on a party ticket, and freedom to change parties at will would let them betray the voters’ mandate for personal gain. (c) is too sweeping: not every defection is for selfish reasons, but a disqualification already exists under the anti-defection law, including from political office such as ministership.

8
Dolly and Sudha are debating about the efficiency and effectiveness of the Parliament in recent times. Dolly believed that the decline of Indian Parliament is evident in the less time spent on debate and discussion and increase in the disturbances of the functioning of the House and walkouts etc. Sudha contends that the fall of different governments on the floor of Lok Sabha is a proof of its vibrancy. What other arguments can you provide to support or oppose the positions of Dolly and Sudha?
Solution

Supporting Dolly:

  • The book notes a gradual decline in the sessions of the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies and the time spent on debates in the last two decades, along with absence of quorum and boycott of sessions by the opposition.
  • The Cabinet initiates policy and sets the agenda, and the Parliament often merely approves legislation; much work has gone to committees.
  • The anti-defection law has increased the control of party leaders over members.

Opposing Dolly: Walkouts and noisy protests are also political techniques to force the government to make concessions and be accountable (the fertiliser price hike was rolled back in 1998 and 2002 under opposition pressure). Parliament still elects the government, controls money, asks questions every day in the Question Hour and has committees.

Supporting Sudha: The no-confidence motion is the most powerful weapon of control, and after 1989 several governments were forced to resign for lack of confidence, so the House does hold the executive accountable.

Opposing Sudha: These governments fell because they could not keep the support of their coalition partners, not because the House exercised effective scrutiny; and the fall of governments also indicates instability. As long as a government has a disciplined majority, the power to dismiss is fictional. So the fall of governments does not by itself prove the vibrancy of the Parliament.

9
Arrange the different stages of passing of a bill into a law in their correct sequence:
A resolution is passed to admit the bill for discussion
The bill is referred to the President of India - write what happens next if s/he does not sign it
The bill is referred to other House and is passed
The bill is passed in the house in which it was proposed
The bill is read clause by clause and each is voted upon
The bill is referred to the subcommittee - the committee makes some changes and sends it back to the house for discussion
The concerned minister proposes the need for a bill
Legislative department in ministry of law, drafts a bill
Solution

The correct sequence is:

  1. The concerned minister proposes the need for a bill.
  2. The legislative department in the Ministry of Law drafts a bill.
  3. A resolution is passed to admit the bill for discussion (the bill is introduced in the House).
  4. The bill is referred to the sub-committee (committee); the committee makes some changes and sends it back to the House for discussion.
  5. The bill is read clause by clause and each is voted upon.
  6. The bill is passed in the House in which it was proposed.
  7. The bill is referred to the other House and is passed (after going through the same procedure; if the two Houses disagree, a joint session is called).
  8. The bill is referred to the President of India.

If the President does not sign it: for a bill other than a money bill the President can send it back to the Parliament for reconsideration; if the Parliament passes it again and sends it back, the President has to give assent. There is no time limit for the President to act, so the President can also keep the bill pending (the ‘pocket veto’), in which case the bill does not become a law.

10
How has the system of parliamentary committee affected the overseeing and appraisal of legislation by the Parliament?
Solution

Parliament meets only in sessions and has very limited time, so committees have taken on much of its detailed work. Since 1983 over twenty departmentally related standing committees supervise the work, budgets, expenditure and bills of the departments. Joint Parliamentary Committees, with members from both Houses, study particular bills or investigate financial irregularities.

Effect: a large part of the discussion on bills now takes place in committees (called miniature legislatures), which can study an issue in depth, and the House then receives their recommendations. This has reduced the burden on the Parliament and improved scrutiny of bills, demands for grants and expenditure. But it also means that the Parliament has merely approved the committees’ work with few alterations and rarely rejects their suggestions, so the committees have a strong influence on what the Parliament finally decides.

In-text questions

1
Activity: Consider these newspaper reports and then think: what would happen if there were no legislatures? After reading each news report, state how the legislature succeeded or failed in maintaining control over the executive.
Solution

If there were no legislatures, the executive could take decisions, including on prices and taxes, without discussion or any need to answer to the people.

  • Fertiliser prices, February-March 2002: The Finance Minister announced a rise in fertiliser prices in the budget but had to roll it back on 11 March 2002 under intense opposition pressure. The legislature succeeded in controlling the executive.
  • Urea and petroleum prices, June 1998: The opposition staged a walkout and the issue rocked the House for two days, which forced the Finance Minister to roll back the hike in urea prices. The legislature succeeded.
  • Assam debate, 22 February 1983: The Lok Sabha unanimously decided to suspend official business and give precedence to a debate on Assam, and the Home Minister sought the cooperation of all members. This shows the legislature acting as the centre of national concern and cooperation, making the government explain its policy.
  • Atrocities on Harijans, March 1985: Congress members themselves voiced protest in the legislature, showing that even members of the ruling party can raise questions and hold the government to account.
2
Read a Cartoon (Shankar, 3 April 1955): The Parliament is the boss and the ministers are looking very humble here. That is the effect of the Parliament’s power to sanction money to different ministries.
Solution

The cartoon shows a crowd of ministers queuing, with files and papers in hand, at a window marked “Parliament”, behind which bags of money are kept, as if they have come to ask for funds. It shows the financial power of the legislature: the government must get the approval of the Parliament for taxes and for the money it spends through the budget and annual financial statements, and must account for how it spent it, so the Parliament controls the purse and the executive has to approach it for resources.

3
What would happen if we were to follow the American system of equality of representation in the Rajya Sabha?
Solution

If every State had equal representation, as in the US Senate, a small State would have the same number of seats as a large one. The book gives the example: Uttar Pradesh with a population of 1998.12 lakhs would get seats equal to those of Sikkim, whose population is only 6.10 lakhs. The framers wanted to prevent such a discrepancy, so States with larger populations get more representatives (Uttar Pradesh 31 members, Sikkim one seat).

4
Activity: Find out the number of representatives elected from different States. Prepare a chart showing number of representatives and the population of the State according to the 2011 census.
Solution

Guidance: Take the number of Rajya Sabha seats of each State from the Fourth Schedule of the Constitution (given in the Rajya Sabha website) and the Lok Sabha seats from the Election Commission, and the 2011 census population, and tabulate them. The chart should show that more populous States have more seats (for example Uttar Pradesh sends 31 members to the Rajya Sabha and Sikkim one), though seats are not exactly proportional to population.

5
I don’t understand why there is a provision for nominating these sportspersons and artists and scientists. Whom do they represent? And, do they really contribute much to the proceedings of the Rajya Sabha?
Solution

The President nominates twelve members from persons who have made their mark in literature, science, art and social service. They do not represent any State or party; their purpose is to bring expertise and experience into the House, which people who cannot or do not wish to enter the rough and tumble of electoral politics can give. Whether they contribute much is open to debate, and depends on their participation in the proceedings (sample answer).

6
Check your progress: Do you think that composition of Rajya Sabha has protected the position of States of India? Should indirect election of Rajya Sabha be replaced by direct elections? What would be its advantages and disadvantages? Since 1971 census the number of seats in the Lok Sabha has not increased. Do you think that it should be increased? What should be the basis for this?
Solution

Protection of States: Partly. Any matter that affects the States must be referred to the Rajya Sabha; to remove a matter from the State list to the Union or Concurrent List, its approval is necessary. States with larger populations get more seats. But experience shows that the members of the Rajya Sabha represent their parties more than their States.

Direct election: Advantage: members would be directly accountable to the people and the House might gain more legitimacy and powers. Disadvantages: it would make the Rajya Sabha a copy of the Lok Sabha, weaken its character as the representative of the States, and lose the benefit of a second look by a differently elected body; it would also be costly. (Sample answer.)

Lok Sabha seats: Sample answer: the number of constituencies has been 543 since the 1971 census, while the population has grown greatly, so each MP now represents many more people. An increase, on the basis of the population of each State, would give better representation, but it would be a large House and may reduce the share of States whose population has grown slowly. This is a matter for debate.

7
So, the Lok Sabha controls the purse! Then it must be the more powerful House.
Solution

The Lok Sabha is more powerful in the matters of money and of controlling the government: the Rajya Sabha cannot initiate, reject or amend money bills, and the Council of Ministers is responsible to the Lok Sabha alone. In a disagreement over an ordinary bill, a joint session has always gone in favour of the Lok Sabha. But the Rajya Sabha is co-equal in other spheres, such as passing non-money bills, constitutional amendments, and impeaching the President and removing the Vice President, and has special powers regarding the State list. So the Lok Sabha is more powerful in the crucial matters, but the Rajya Sabha is not weak.

8
Check your progress: From the discussion of the law making process, do you think that Parliament can devote enough time for thorough discussion of the bills? If not, then what remedies would you suggest to overcome this difficulty?
Solution

Sample answer: Not fully. The Parliament meets only in sessions, the number of sittings has declined, and time is lost in disruptions, so it cannot discuss every bill in depth. Remedies: refer more bills to committees, which already do much of the detailed discussion; hold longer sessions and have a fixed calendar of sittings; ensure that the House works orderly with no unnecessary disruption; give enough time to opposition members and give notice before bills are taken up; and take public inputs through committees.

9
Read a Cartoon (R.K. Laxman): Is this how they follow the ‘rules of the game’?
Solution

The cartoon’s caption reads: “OK, let’s not argue! Let’s settle the issue through consensus! You support the bill and I will oppose it!” The joke is that the ‘consensus’ is only a quick arrangement between two members to take opposite sides without any real argument, instead of deciding the bill on its merits after discussion. The book says that approval of bills is a product of intense bargaining and negotiation among members of the ruling party, coalition parties and even government and opposition. Some give-and-take is normal in democratic law-making, but if it replaces reasoned debate, it does not follow the rules of the game, which require discussion, committees and voting.

10
With so many sting operations are MPs still free to speak anything anywhere?
Solution

Parliamentary privilege protects what members say inside the legislature: no action can be taken against a member for whatever he or she may have said in the legislature, and the presiding officer has the final power to decide matters of breach of privilege. The purpose is to enable members to represent the people and to control the executive effectively and fearlessly. The privilege applies to the proceedings of the House; it does not make members free to say anything anywhere.

11
It must be difficult to be a minister. This is like giving an examination almost every day!
Solution

This refers to the Question Hour, held every day during the sessions of Parliament, when ministers have to respond to searching questions raised by the members. It is perhaps the most effective method of keeping vigil on the executive, and attendance is maximum at this time. It is difficult for ministers because they must be ready with answers on price rise, food grains, atrocities on weaker sections, riots and so on, and these are the means by which the government is made to answer for its actions.

12
Activity: Watch the Doordarshan telecast of Parliament sessions for three continuous days. Or collect the newspaper reports for three continuous days and make a wallpaper. Take care to observe the issues being discussed, the role of the speaker, questions being asked, the political parties of the representatives, representatives from your region, nature of the issues of discussion - whether they were all of national or regional in character.
Solution

Guidance: Make a chart with the date, the issue discussed, the party and State of the speakers, whether the issue was national or regional, and the Speaker’s role (calling members to speak, maintaining order, deciding on rules). Note whether the Question Hour and Zero Hour took place and how much time went into debate and how much into disruption. Compare with the functions of the Parliament given in this chapter.

13
Read a Cartoon (Irfan): Walkout is a frequently adopted measure by the opposition to register their protest against the government. Has there been an overuse of that weapon?
Solution

The cartoon (titled “Fifty years of Parliament”, with Hindi text) shows an MP carrying a bag (marked shows an MP with a bag marked “Parliament” being asked by a child how manyldquo;MPshows an MP with a bag marked “Parliament” being asked by a child how manyrdquo; in Hindi) who offers to take any question about Parliament, and a child asks him how many walkouts there have been in the past fifty years.

Sample answer: Walkouts are a legitimate way of protest, and the book notes that many such actions are political techniques to gain concessions from the government and force accountability. But a walkout and boycotts have become so frequent that they cost considerable legislative time and deprive the House of discussion through which it controls the executive; the book also mentions boycott of sessions by the opposition as a problem. So when used too often, the weapon loses its force; it should be kept for serious occasions.

14
Read a Cartoon (Irfan): “We are not walking out, we have been ordered out,” said the MPs. Why do you think such situations occur?
Solution

In the cartoon, the MPs say in Hindi: “We are not walking out, we have been ordered out”. Such situations occur because the presiding officer is the final authority in regulating the business of the House and controls the behaviour of the members. When members disturb the proceedings, the Speaker can order them out of the House. Sample answer: such situations occur when members persist in disorderly conduct or defy the rules, and the walkout of the opposition and the Speaker’s order to leave then become hard to tell apart; the cartoonist makes a joke of the fact that a protest has turned into an expulsion.

15
I don’t understand why they change parties. Do they even come back to the party they once left?
Solution

Sample answer: legislators change parties mainly for personal or political gain, such as office or better chances of winning, or because of disagreement with their own party. The anti-defection amendment (52nd Amendment, 1985, later modified by the 91st) says that a member who defects loses membership of the House and is disqualified from holding political office such as ministership, but the book notes that it has not been able to curb defections. Whether a member returns to the old party depends on the political circumstances; the book does not discuss it.

Cover of Complete Political Science Notes for Class 11 (CBSE 2026-27)
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
  • For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
  • All NCERT exercises solved
  • Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
₹199₹24920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF
Read free sample

What is inside the Chapter 5 notes →

Found a mistake or need help with a question? Message us on WhatsApp. Free study tips and new solutions: join our WhatsApp Channel.

Prices shown in Indian rupees. Show prices in: ₹ INR · US$ USD