NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 6
Chapter 6: Judiciary (Judiciary)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 6: Judiciary (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on the independence of the judiciary, the Supreme Court jurisdiction, judicial activism, PIL and judicial review, plus the in-text questions and cartoons. All 28 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
What are the different ways in which the independence of the judiciary is ensured? Choose the odd ones out.
Chief Justice of the Supreme Court is consulted in the appointment of other judges of Supreme Court.
Judges are generally not removed before the age of retirement.
Judge of a High Court cannot be transferred to another High Court.
Parliament has no say in the appointment of judges.
Solution
Ways in which independence is ensured: (i), (ii) and (iv). The odd one out is (iii).
The CJI is consulted in appointments, and under the collegium principle the decision of the group of senior judges carries great weight, so the executive cannot appoint on political grounds alone.
Judges have a fixed tenure till retirement and security of tenure, as removal is extremely difficult.
This is the odd one out. It is not a safeguard of independence, and it is not correct as stated: the Supreme Court can transfer judges of the High Courts.
The legislature is not involved in the appointment of judges, so that party politics should not play a role.
Does independence of the judiciary mean that the judiciary is not accountable to any one? Write your answer in not more than 100 words.
Solution
No. Independence of the judiciary means that the executive and legislature must not restrain its functioning or interfere with its decisions, and that judges can work without fear or favour. It does not imply arbitrariness or absence of accountability. The judiciary is part of the democratic political structure, so it is accountable to the Constitution, to democratic traditions and to the people. Judges can be removed by Parliament for proven misbehaviour or incapacity, and the Supreme Court can review its own decisions. Independence protects judges from pressure, not from the law.
What are the different provisions in the constitution in order to maintain the independence of judiciary?
Solution
The Constitution ensures the independence of the judiciary through these measures:
Appointment: the legislature is not involved in the appointment of judges, so party politics should not play a role. A person must have experience as a lawyer and/or be well versed in law; political opinions or loyalty should not be the criteria.
Fixed tenure: judges hold office until the age of retirement and have security of tenure, so they can function without fear or favour.
Removal: the Constitution prescribes a very difficult procedure: only on proven misbehaviour or incapacity, by a motion approved by a special majority in both Houses of Parliament.
Financial independence: the salaries and allowances of judges are not subject to the approval of the legislature, so the judiciary is not financially dependent on the executive or the legislature.
Protection from criticism: the actions and decisions of judges are immune from personal criticism; the court can punish contempt of court; and Parliament cannot discuss the conduct of judges except in a removal proceeding.
Read the news report below and identify the following aspects: What is the case about? Who has been the beneficiary in the case? Who is the petitioner in the case? Visualise what would have been the different arguments put forward by the company. What arguments would the farmers have put forward? (Report: Supreme Court orders REL to pay Rs 300 crore to Dahanu farmers, 24 March 2005)
Solution
The case: It is about pollution caused by Reliance Energy’s thermal power plant at Dahanu outside Mumbai. After the plant started working in 1989, crops failed from 1990, 70 per cent of the crop was lost, fisheries shut and the forest cover thinned; fly ash is said to have polluted the ground water. The pollution control unit ordered by the Dahanu Taluka Environment Protection Authority was not set up even by 2002 despite a Supreme Court order, so the Authority asked Reliance for a bank guarantee of Rs 300 crore, and the Supreme Court ordered Reliance to pay Rs 300 crore.
Beneficiaries: the chikoo (sapota) growers and farmers of the Dahanu area, whose crop and livelihood were damaged.
Petitioner: the chikoo growers who petitioned the court against the pollution (the Dahanu Taluka Environment Protection Authority also acted for environmental protection).
Arguments the company may have put forward (imagined): that it acquired the station only in 2003 and so is not responsible for the delay since 1989; that it had submitted a schedule for installing the pollution control plant in 2004 and was acting on it; that the power plant is needed for electricity supply and development; that the cause of the crop loss was not proved to be only the plant; and that a demand for Rs 300 crore was excessive.
Arguments of the farmers (imagined, from the report): that the fertile belt, a self-sustaining agricultural and horticultural economy, was devastated after the plant began working in 1989; that the first crop failure came the next year and 70 per cent of the crop is gone; that fly ash entered the ground water and polluted the entire ecosystem; that the authority’s order and even the Supreme Court’s order to set up a pollution control unit were not obeyed for years; and that pollution violates their right to life and livelihood and so they must be compensated.
Read the following news report and, Identify the governments at different levels. Identify the role of Supreme Court. What elements of the working of judiciary and executive can you identify in it? Identify the policy issues, matters related to legislation, implementation and interpretation of the law involved in this case. (Report: Centre, Delhi join hands on CNG issue, The Hindu, 23 September 2001)
Solution
Governments at different levels: the central government (the Union Petroleum and Natural Gas Minister, Ram Naik) and the State government of Delhi (Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit).
Role of the Supreme Court: it gave directions that buses in Delhi should run on CNG and refused to relax the CNG norm for buses (though it had not insisted on CNG for taxis and auto rickshaws). The governments are approaching it to ask for more time and a changed policy, so the Court is deciding a policy matter of public interest, as an active judiciary.
Judiciary and executive: the judiciary issues directives and decides; the executive (ministers and governments) meets, decides its stand, files affidavits, plans implementation, and sets up the Mashelkar Committee for an auto fuel policy. Both governments act together before the Court, and the executive must implement the Court’s directions.
Policy issues: single-fuel (CNG) mode versus dual fuel for the city’s transport, low sulphur diesel, Euro-II standards, discouraging CNG for private vehicles, and the national Auto Fuel Policy. Legislation: no new law is mentioned; the Court’s directions have the force of law, and the Mashelkar Committee’s recommendations could lead to policy or law. Implementation: converting the 10,000-odd bus fleet to CNG, queues at filling stations, pipeline supply of CNG, and the time frame for compliance. Interpretation: the Court interpreted the public interest and environmental protection and its CNG norms; whether they cover only buses or also taxis and autos.
The following is a statement about Ecuador. What similarities or differences do you find between this example and the judicial system in India? “It would be helpful if a body of common law, or judicial precedent, existed that could clarify a journalist’s rights. Unfortunately, Ecuador’s courts don’t work that way. Judges are not forced to respect the rulings of higher courts in previous cases. Unlike the US, an appellate judge in Ecuador (or elsewhere in South America, for that matter) need not provide a written decision explaining the legal basis of a ruling. A judge may rule one way today and the opposite way, in a similar case, tomorrow, without explaining why.”
Solution
The statement describes a system with no binding precedent, no duty to give written reasons and inconsistent rulings. India differs:
In India the judiciary is a single integrated, pyramidal system, and the decisions of the Supreme Court are binding on all other courts within the territory of India; lower courts function under the superintendence of higher courts. Judges in India are therefore bound to respect the rulings of higher courts.
Courts in India give written judgements stating the reasons, and appeals can be made to the higher courts (appellate jurisdiction), which will reconsider the legal issues and, if the law has a different meaning, change the ruling and give a new interpretation. So similar cases are decided in a similar way.
Similarity: in both countries, judges hear appeals and interpret the law, and a fair system of rights of journalists, such as freedom of expression, depends on courts. Where Indian courts still differ from case to case, or give diverse rulings, citizens may find the system uncertain, but there is a mechanism of appeal and review (the Supreme Court can even review its own ruling).
Read the following statements: Match them with the different jurisdictions the Supreme Court can exercise - Original, Appellate, and Advisory.
The government wanted to know if it can pass a law about the citizenship status of residents of Pakistan-occupied areas of Jammu and Kashmir.
In order to resolve the dispute about river Cauvery the government of Tamil Nadu wants to approach the court.
Court rejected the appeal by people against the eviction from the dam site.
Solution
Advisory jurisdiction. The government seeks the opinion of the Supreme Court before acting on a matter of public importance or interpretation of the Constitution; the President can refer it, though the Court is not bound to advise and the President is not bound to accept.
Original jurisdiction. A dispute between States (and between the Union and States) can be taken directly to the Supreme Court alone.
Appellate jurisdiction. The Court heard an appeal against the decision of a lower court and rejected it.
In what way can public interest litigation help the poor?
Solution
In normal course only a person personally aggrieved can go to court, but the poor often cannot approach the courts because of poverty, ignorance and lack of resources. Through PIL, public spirited citizens, social organisations and lawyers can file petitions on behalf of the needy and the deprived, and the court has even considered cases on the basis of newspaper reports and postal complaints. The poor have benefited as the court has taken up cases such as the long detention of undertrial prisoners (Hussainara Khatoon vs. Bihar), the torture of prisoners, the blinding of jail inmates, inhuman working conditions in stone quarries, bonded labour and sexual exploitation of children. As Justice Bhagwati said, the problems of the poor need a different judicial approach. PIL has also expanded rights such as clean air, unpolluted water and decent living, and made rights meaningful for the poor and disadvantaged.
Do you think that judicial activism can lead to a conflict between the judiciary and the executive? Why?
Solution
Yes. Judicial activism can lead to conflict because the court is involved in resolving questions that belong to the executive, such as reducing air or sound pollution, investigating corruption or bringing electoral reform. The court has given directions to executive agencies like the CBI to start investigations against politicians and bureaucrats (the hawala case, the Narasimha Rao case, the petrol pumps allotment). The executive may feel that the court is taking over its functions, and it may find the directions hard to implement. This blurs the line between the organs and makes the balance among them delicate. Democratic government rests on each organ respecting the powers and jurisdiction of the others, and judicial activism may strain this principle. At the same time, it has forced executive accountability and made the executive more responsive.
How is judicial activism related to the protection of fundamental rights? Has it helped in expanding the scope of fundamental rights?
Solution
Judicial activism, mainly through public interest litigation (PIL), has widened the ways in which fundamental rights are protected. Courts allowed petitions on behalf of persons whose rights were violated, and also took up cases on the basis of letters and newspaper reports (Sunil Batra vs. Delhi Administration, 1980). This made it possible to consider violations of the right against exploitation, such as forced labour, trade in human beings and child labour in hazardous jobs.
Yes, it has expanded the scope of rights. The court has treated clean air, unpolluted water and decent living as rights of the entire society, so that individuals may seek justice where these are violated. Together with the Court’s reading of the right to life (see Chapter 2) it has widened rights to include dignity, shelter and livelihood. It has also allowed groups to approach the courts, made the electoral system more free and fair by asking candidates to file affidavits of their assets, income and educational qualifications, and made rights meaningful for the poor.
Read a Cartoon (R.K. Laxman): No fisticuffs please, this is rule of law!
Solution
The cartoon shows a brawl in a courtroom, with a lawyer lying on the floor among scattered books and a man in a black coat saying, in the caption, “as an eminent lawyer you ought to know that your action is tantamount to, under sub-section ... read along with I.P.C. ...”. The point is that in a society disputes are settled in accordance with the rule of law, under which all persons, rich and poor, are subject to the same law, and not by force. The courts protect the rule of law and the supremacy of law.
I remember the case of Machal mentioned in chapter two. Don’t they say, ‘justice delayed is justice denied’? Somebody should do something about this.
Solution
Machal Lalung spent 54 years in custody without his case ever coming up for hearing, so the delay denied him justice altogether. The Constitution gives every citizen the right to life and liberty, which includes the right to a fair and speedy trial. The judiciary should be independent and its work should be quick; remedies include fast-track and speedy trials, reviewing the cases of undertrial prisoners (which the Supreme Court did in the Hussainara Khatoon case), more judges and courts, and the Right to Constitutional Remedies (the writ of habeas corpus), and the work of bodies such as the National Human Rights Commission, which freed Machal.
Activity: Hold a debate in class on the following topic. Which of the following factors do you think, work as constraints over the judges in giving their rulings? Do you think these are justified? Constitution; Precedents; Opinion of other courts; Public opinion; Media; Traditions of law; Laws; Time and staff constraints; Fear of public criticism; Fear of action by executive.
Solution
Guidance: Constraints that are justified in a rule-of-law system are the Constitution, laws, precedents (decisions of higher courts are binding), the opinion of other courts and the traditions of law, since judges must decide in accordance with the law and be consistent. Time and staff constraints are real but should be reduced by providing resources. The constraints that are not justified are fear of public criticism and fear of action by the executive: independence means that judges must perform their functions without fear or favour. Public opinion and media may inform judges, but they must not decide the case.
I am afraid, I am getting confused. In a democracy, you can criticise the Prime Minister or even the President, but not the judges! And what is this contempt of court? But am I being guilty of contempt if I asked about these matters?
Solution
The actions and decisions of judges are immune from personal criticism, and the court has the power to penalise those who are found guilty of contempt of court. This is seen as protecting the judges from unfair criticism and lets them decide without fear of being criticised. It does not mean that judgements cannot be discussed, as the book itself discusses them; the protection is against unfair, personal attacks and disobedience of orders. Asking questions about these matters in good faith, as the student does, is not contempt. (The final answer rests on the court, which decides contempt cases.)
But I think, finally the Council of Ministers would have greater say in appointing judges. Or is it that the judiciary is a self-appointing body?
Solution
Neither is quite true. Judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts are appointed by the President after ‘consulting’ the CJI, which in effect meant that the final decision rested with the Council of Ministers. Between 1982 and 1998 the Supreme Court changed this: first it held the CJI’s role to be purely consultative, then that his opinion must be followed, and finally it evolved the principle of collegiality, by which the CJI recommends names in consultation with the four senior-most judges. At present the decision of the group of senior judges carries greater weight, so the Supreme Court and the Council of Ministers both play an important role. Parliament has no part in appointments.
Check your progress: Why is independence of the judiciary important? Do you think that executive should have the power to appoint judges? If you were asked to make suggestions for changing the procedure of appointing judges, what changes would you suggest?
Solution
Why important: the judiciary settles disputes between individuals, groups and the government in accordance with the rule of law, safeguards the rights of the individual and prevents democracy from turning into dictatorship. It can do this only if it is free of political pressures and judges can act without fear or favour.
Executive power to appoint: Sample answer: the executive should not have the final say, because it may appoint judges for political loyalty and expect favours, which defeats independence; but the executive is a part of the process in a democracy and should be consulted. The role of the executive in the process has made appointments controversial and a part of political process.
Suggestions (sample): an independent, broad-based appointment commission with the Chief Justice and senior judges, the government and representatives of the legal profession and perhaps the leader of the opposition; published criteria based on merit and experience; transparent procedures and reasons; and a fixed time for filling vacancies.
Isn’t it funny that giving advice is optional and accepting that advice is also optional? I thought that the Courts gave decisions that were binding!
Solution
The courts’ decisions are binding in cases decided under its original, appellate and writ jurisdiction. Under advisory jurisdiction the President may refer a matter of public importance or constitutional interpretation, but the Court need not give advice and the President need not accept it. Its utility is two-fold: the government gets a legal opinion before acting, which may prevent unnecessary litigation, and in the light of the advice it can change its action or legislation. The opinion carries the weight of the highest court, even though it is not a decision in a dispute.
Why is the Supreme Court allowed to change its own ruling? Is it because courts can also make mistakes? Is it possible that the same judge is part of the ‘Bench’ that revises the ruling and was also on the Bench that gave the ruling in the first place?
Solution
Article 137 gives the Supreme Court the power to review any judgment or order made by it; the Court is not bound by its own decision and can review it at any time. Yes, the reason is that courts can also make mistakes or may need to change a ruling with changed circumstances. The book does not say who sits on the review Bench. It is possible that a judge who was on the first Bench is part of the Bench which reviews, since reviews are normally heard by the same judges who decided the case (a general legal practice, not stated in this chapter).
Check your progress: Match the following: Dispute between State of Bihar and Union of India will be heard by; Appeal from District court of Haryana will go to; Single Integrated Judiciary; Declaring a law unconstitutional. (Options: High Court; Advisory Jurisdiction; Judicial review; Original Jurisdiction; Supreme Court; Single Constitution)
Solution
Item
Match
Dispute between State of Bihar and Union of India will be heard by
Original Jurisdiction (of the Supreme Court)
Appeal from District court of Haryana will go to
High Court
Single Integrated Judiciary
Supreme Court (the pyramid has the Supreme Court at the top)
Declaring a law unconstitutional
Judicial review
Advisory Jurisdiction and Single Constitution are the two extra options and do not match any item.
Read a Cartoon (Irfan): Do you know that in recent times the judiciary has ruled that bandhs and hartals are illegal?
Solution
The cartoon shows a huge gavel shouting “Order! Order! Order!” and striking a letter box, under a newspaper headline in Hindi which reads, “Postal strike: court intervenes”. It shows the judiciary stepping into an area that belongs to the executive and the administration, which is judicial activism. Sample answer: restraining bandhs and hartals protects the daily life and rights of the public, but some argue that it is the work of the executive to maintain order, so activism of this kind should be used carefully.
I have heard someone say that PIL means ‘private interest litigation’. Why would that be so?
Solution
PIL means public interest litigation, a case filed on behalf of the public, especially those who cannot approach the courts. The remark points to a danger: the large number of PILs has overburdened the courts, and some petitioners may use PIL to advance their own or a group’s private interests, or to harass others, under the label of public interest. So the court has to examine whether the petition really involves public interest. This is also why the book’s ‘You are the Judge’ asks whether a PIL to remove slums is in the public interest.
Activity: Find out the details about at least one case involving a PIL and study the way in which that case helped in serving public interest.
Solution
Sample answer: Hussainara Khatoon vs. Bihar (1979), one of the early PILs. Newspapers reported that many prisoners in Bihar had been in jail as undertrials for longer than they would have spent in jail if punished for the offences with which they were charged. This report prompted an advocate to file a petition, and the Supreme Court heard it. The case served the public interest by drawing attention to the right to a speedy trial of the poor undertrial prisoners and opened the gates for many PILs on prisoners’ rights. Another example is Sunil Batra vs. Delhi Administration (1980), begun from a letter sent from Tihar jail to Justice Krishna Iyer on the physical torture of prisoners.
I think judicial activism is more about telling the legislature and the executive what they should do. What will happen if the legislature and executive started giving justice?
Solution
The comment is partly right: judicial activism does lead the courts to give directions to the executive and sometimes the legislature, and this blurs the line between the organs. If the legislature and the executive started giving justice, the principle of the separation of powers and checks and balances would break down: the Parliament is supreme in making laws, the executive in implementing them and the judiciary in settling disputes and deciding whether laws are in accordance with the Constitution. Persons who are interested parties (the government is often a party in disputes) would be deciding their own cases, there would be no independent protector of rights, and arbitrary use of power would grow.
You are the Judge: A group of citizens from a city have approached the court through a PIL asking for an order to the city municipal authorities to remove slums and beautify the city in order to attract investors to the city. They argue that this is in the ‘public interest.’ The residents of the slum localities have responded by saying that this will encroach on their right to life. They argue that right to life is more central to ‘public interest’ than the right to a clean city. Imagine that you are the judge. Write a judgement deciding if the PIL involves ‘public interest’.
Solution
Sample judgement: The PIL asks for the removal of slums to beautify the city and attract investors. Public interest litigation was developed so that the courts can protect rights and improve the lives of the poor and disadvantaged who cannot approach the courts, not to harm them. The right to life, which includes the right to shelter and livelihood and to live with human dignity (Article 21), is a fundamental right guaranteed to the slum dwellers. A clean and attractive city is desirable, but it is not a fundamental right in the same sense, and the investment motive shows that the interest is of a section, not of the public as a whole.
Therefore, this petition does not involve public interest in the sense of the PIL, and I dismiss it. The municipal authorities may improve the city, but not by evicting people without providing alternative housing and livelihood; they must follow a fair procedure, give notice, rehabilitate those displaced, and improve the slums. (A different view is possible if the slums are shown to be a danger to the health and safety of the residents themselves; it should then be addressed by their relocation with rehabilitation.)
Check your progress: When does the Court use the review powers? What is the difference between judicial review and writ?
Solution
Review powers: The Court uses judicial review when it examines whether a law is consistent with the Constitution. It does so if a law is held to violate the fundamental rights (Article 13), or to violate the federal distribution of powers (for example, the centre makes a law on a State subject and the States challenge it). If the Court finds the law inconsistent, it declares it unconstitutional and inapplicable. The review power extends to laws passed by State legislatures also.
Difference: A writ is a special order (habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari or quo warranto) issued by the Supreme Court (Article 32) or the High Courts (Article 226) to restore a fundamental right that has been violated, directing the executive to act or not to act in a particular way. Judicial review is the power to examine the constitutionality of a law (or action) itself and strike it down if it conflicts with the Constitution. A writ gives a remedy to an individual in a case; review decides the validity of a law.
Why can’t the Court tell us once and for all what are those aspects that are ‘basic structure’ of the Constitution?
Solution
In the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973) the Court ruled that there is a basic structure of the Constitution which nobody, not even Parliament through amendment, can violate; it also reserved to itself the right to decide whether various matters are part of the basic structure. The Court has not given a fixed list so that it can decide each case as it comes up, as the circumstances and amendments differ; a list would also be rigid. This keeps the Constitution a living document, though it also leaves some uncertainty (sample answer).
Check your progress: The main issues in the conflict between the judiciary and the Parliament have been: Appointment of judges; Salaries and allowances of judges; Scope of Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution; Interference by the Parliament in the functioning of the judiciary
Solution
The main issues discussed in the chapter are the third and the fourth:
Scope of Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution: the long conflict over the right to property, whether Parliament may abridge fundamental rights, and the Kesavananda Bharati case.
Interference by the Parliament in the functioning of the judiciary (and of the judiciary in the legislature): the conduct of judges cannot be discussed in the Parliament, yet legislatures have cast aspersions on the judiciary, while the judiciary has criticised legislatures; and whether courts can protect a person punished by the legislature for breach of privilege.
Appointment of judges is a matter of political controversy, but the chapter presents it mainly as concerning the executive and the judiciary, not as a conflict with the Parliament; and the salaries and allowances of judges are not subject to the approval of the legislature, so the chapter does not describe it as a main issue of conflict.
Read a Cartoon (R.K. Laxman): How active is the judiciary in trying to curb corruption in public life?
Solution
The cartoon shows a man in a courtroom, with arms spread, saying, “At last, I’ve been honourably acquitted! It was a nightmare all this time! I swear I’ll never again indulge in corruption!”
The judiciary has been active: it gave directions to the CBI to start investigations against politicians and bureaucrats in the hawala case, the Narasimha Rao case and the illegal allotment of petrol pumps, and has used PIL for electoral reform. The conclusion also notes that citizens wonder how many powerful people get easy acquittals and how witnesses change their testimony to suit the wealthy and mighty, and that the judiciary is concerned about these issues. So the judiciary is active but its success is limited by such problems. (Sample reading of the cartoon: the accused is celebrating an acquittal and then swears off corruption, which hints at the easy acquittals that the book mentions.)
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered