NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 4
Chapter 4: Executive (Executive)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 4: Executive (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on the parliamentary executive, the President, the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers and the bureaucracy, plus the in-text questions and cartoons. All 24 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
Executive that is dependent on support of the majority in the parliament
Solution
(d) Executive that is dependent on support of the majority in the parliament. In a parliamentary system the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers must have the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha; the moment this support is lost, they lose office.
(d) Executive that is dependent on support of the majority in the parliament
Read this dialogue. Which argument do you agree with? Why? Amit: Looking at the constitutional provisions, it seems that the President is only a rubber stamp. Shama: The President appoints the Prime Minister. So, he must have the powers to remove the Prime Minister as well. Rajesh: We don’t need a President. After the election, the Parliament can meet and elect a leader to be the Prime Minister.
Solution
I agree most with Amit, with a qualification. The President is the formal head, and under Article 74(1) the advice of the Council of Ministers is binding; the President can ask it to reconsider once but must accept the reconsidered advice. So in most cases the President is a ceremonial head, as Nehru said, a head that “neither reigns nor governs”. Yet the President is not a mere rubber stamp: the President can send advice back for reconsideration, can withhold assent to Bills (other than Money Bills) or keep them pending (the “pocket veto”, used on the Indian Post Office Bill in 1986), and has discretion in choosing the Prime Minister when no party has a clear majority.
Shama is wrong: the Prime Minister holds office as long as he or she has the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha, and the President cannot remove the Prime Minister at will. Rajesh is wrong: the Council of Ministers can be removed at any time, so a Head of State with a fixed term is needed, who symbolically represents the entire country, appoints the Prime Minister and decides whom to appoint when no party has a clear majority.
Match the following: i. Works within the particular State in which recruited ii. Works in any central government office located either at the national capital or elsewhere in the country iii. Works in a particular State to which allotted; can also be sent on deputation to the centre iv. Works in Indian missions abroad a. Indian Foreign Service b. State Civil Services c. All India Services d. Central Services
Solution
Description
Service
i. Works within the particular State in which recruited
b. State Civil Services
ii. Works in any central government office, at the national capital or elsewhere
d. Central Services
iii. Works in a particular State to which allotted; can also be sent on deputation to the centre
c. All India Services
iv. Works in Indian missions abroad
a. Indian Foreign Service
Reason for iii: IAS and IPS officers are assigned to a State and work under the State government, but are appointed by the central government, can return to central service, and only the central government can take disciplinary action against them.
Identify the ministry which may have released the following news items. Would this be a ministry of the central government or the State government? Why?
An official release said that in 2004-05 the Tamil Nadu Textbooks Corporation would release new versions for standards VII, X and XI.
A new railway loop line bypassing the crowded Tiruvallur-Chennai section to help iron ore exporters. The new line, likely to be about 80 km long, will branch off at Puttur and then reach Athipattu near the port.
The three-member sub-divisional committee formed to verify suicide by farmers in Ramayampet mandal has found that the two farmers who committed suicide this month have had economic problems due to failure of crops.
Solution
The Ministry (Department) of School Education of the Tamil Nadu State government. The corporation is a State body producing textbooks for the State’s school standards, so it comes under the State government.
The Ministry of Railways of the central (Union) government. Railways are run by the central government, and this is a rail project.
The State government, through its Revenue (or Agriculture) department. The committee is at the sub-divisional and mandal level, which belong to the State administration, and agriculture and the district machinery are the responsibility of the State government.
While appointing the Prime Minister, the President selects
Leader of the largest party in the Lok Sabha
Leader of the largest party in the alliance which secures a majority in the Lok Sabha
The leader of the largest party in the Rajya Sabha
Leader of the alliance or party that has the support of the majority in Lok Sabha
Solution
(d) Leader of the alliance or party that has the support of the majority in Lok Sabha. Formally, a leader who has the support of the majority is appointed Prime Minister. The largest party need not have a majority (a), the leader of the largest party in an alliance need not be the choice (b), and the Rajya Sabha has no role (c).
(d) Leader of the alliance or party that has the support of the majority in Lok Sabha
Read this discussion and say which of these statements applies most to India. Alok: Prime Minister is like a king, he decides everything in our country. Shekhar: Prime Minister is only ‘first among equals’, he does not have any special powers. All ministers and the PM have similar powers. Bobby: Prime Minister has to consider the expectations of the party members and other supporters of the government. But after all, the Prime Minister has a greater say in policy making and in choosing the ministers.
Solution
Bobby’s statement applies most to India. The Prime Minister has a pre-eminent place: he or she chooses and ranks the ministers, the Council of Ministers cannot exist without the Prime Minister, and the Prime Minister is the linchpin of government who decides on the policies of the government. But the Prime Minister depends on the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha and, especially in coalition governments, has to consult partners and act more as a negotiator. So Alok is wrong (the PM is not a king), and Shekhar is wrong (the PM has special powers over the Council).
Why do you think is the advice of the Council of Ministers binding on the President? Give your answer in not more than 100 words.
Solution
In a parliamentary system the real executive is the Council of Ministers, which has the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha and is collectively responsible to it. The President is only the formal head and is not elected directly by the people. If the President could override the Council, accountability to the legislature would be lost. So Article 74(1) says the President “shall” act on its advice; amendments make the advice binding, with only one reconsideration allowed. This keeps government democratic and prevents a personality cult.
The parliamentary system of executive vests many powers in the legislature for controlling the executive. Why, do you think, is it so necessary to control the executive?
Solution
The modern executive is a very powerful institution; it enjoys greater powers than the other organs and implements laws and policies and also often frames them. This creates a need for democratic control. Without control the executive could misuse its power, ignore the wishes of the people, become unresponsive, and make unaccountable decisions. The makers of the Constitution wanted a government sensitive to public expectations, responsible and accountable, and a strong executive with enough safeguards against a personality cult. In the parliamentary system the executive is routinely under the supervision of the legislature, and the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, so it must resign if it loses the House’s confidence. Periodic elections and constitutional limits add to this control.
It is said that there is too much political interference in the working of the administrative machinery. It is suggested that there should be more and more autonomous agencies which do not have to answer to the ministers.
Do you think this will make administration more people-friendly?
Do you think this will make administration more efficient?
Does democracy mean full control of elected representatives over the administration?
Solution
Sample answers:
Not necessarily. Autonomy from ministers may protect officials from unfair pressure, but then nobody elected answers to the people for their actions. The bureaucracy is often seen as insensitive and people are afraid to approach officers; the book suggests that more control by the elected government and measures like the Right to Information would make it more responsive, not less.
It may improve efficiency in some technical matters by reducing interference, as the UPSC does in recruitment. But without accountability the agencies may become arbitrary and slow to respond; efficiency also needs clear policy direction from elected leaders.
Democracy means that the elected representatives and ministers are in charge and the administration works under their control and supervision. But it does not mean full or partisan control: too much political interference turns the bureaucracy into an instrument in the hands of politicians. The bureaucracy is expected to be politically neutral and professional while being politically accountable.
Write an essay of two hundred words on the proposal to have an elected administration instead of an appointed administration.
Solution
Sample essay: In India the administration is made up of permanent civil servants who are selected on merit by the Union Public Service Commission and the State Commissions, not elected. The proposal is to replace them by elected officers. It has an attractive side. Elected officers would have to face the voters and so might become more answerable and less arrogant, and people who fear approaching officers would feel that the officer is their own representative.
However, the arguments against it are stronger. First, the administration needs trained and skilled professionals who stay in office for years; elections would bring in persons chosen for popularity and not competence, and officers would change with every election. Second, the bureaucracy is expected to be politically neutral and to carry out the policies of whichever government is elected; elected administrators would belong to parties and work for them. Third, recruitment by merit through an independent commission, with reservation for SC, ST, women, OBC and EWS, makes the bureaucracy impartial and representative; elections could favour dominant groups. Fourth, the people already control the administration indirectly: officers are under the supervision of ministers, who are accountable to the legislature, which is elected.
The better course is to make the appointed administration more accountable and responsive through political control, the Right to Information and protection from political interference, rather than make it elected.
Who is in charge of the administration of your school? Who takes important decisions in a school or a university?
Solution
Sample answer: in a school the principal (head of the school), with the vice-principal and the teachers in charge of different areas, administers the school and takes the important decisions, usually under the school management or board; in a university the vice-chancellor and the university’s executive bodies do so. In every organisation some office holders decide the policies, rules and regulations and others implement them in day-to-day functioning; the body that looks after implementation is the executive. (Check the names of the office holders in your own school.)
I remember somebody saying that the executive in a democracy is accountable to people. Is that also true of executives in big companies? Aren’t they called CEOs? Who are they accountable to?
Solution
No. The executive of a government is answerable, directly or indirectly, to the people through elections and, in the parliamentary system, to the legislature. The executive of a company, such as a chief executive officer (CEO), is accountable to the owners of the company, that is, its board of directors and shareholders, not to the general public. The word executive in both cases means the body that looks after the implementation of rules and decisions.
Activity: Procure a photograph of the SAARC summit meeting or the meeting of G-7 countries and list those who attended the meeting. Can you imagine why those people and not some others are attending the meeting?
Solution
Guidance: The people in the photograph are the heads of government or state of the member countries (for example, Prime Ministers, Presidents or Chancellors). They attend because the executive is the branch that represents the country and takes the major policy decisions; in parliamentary systems this is mostly the head of government and in presidential systems the President. Other leaders, such as members of the legislature or judges, do not attend because they do not carry out the executive function of representing the government.
Semi-Presidential Executive in Sri Lanka: How is the position of the President and Prime Minister in Sri Lanka different from India? Compare the role of Supreme Court in the impeachment of the President in India and Sri Lanka.
Solution
Point
Sri Lanka
India
Election of the President
Directly elected by the people
Indirectly elected by elected MPs and MLAs
Powers of the President
Vast powers; head of State, head of the Government and Commander-in-Chief; chooses the Prime Minister and can remove the Prime Minister or ministers
Formal head; acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister, who has the real power
Prime Minister
Chosen by the President; can be removed by the President
Leader with the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha; the President cannot remove the PM at will
Term
Six years
Five years
Role of the Supreme Court in impeachment
If a resolution is passed by not less than one-half of the MPs and the Speaker is satisfied that the allegations merit inquiry, the Speaker can report the matter to the Supreme Court; removal needs a resolution passed by at least two-thirds of the total MPs
Only Parliament removes the President by impeachment with a special majority, on the ground of violation of the Constitution; the Supreme Court has no role
Check your progress: Neha: It is really very simple. A country having a president has a presidential executive and one with a prime minister has parliamentary executive. How would you explain to Neha that this is not always the case?
Solution
The existence of a president or prime minister alone does not decide the type. In a parliamentary system the prime minister is the head of government and the president or monarch is a nominal head: Germany, Italy, India and Japan have presidents (or an emperor) but are parliamentary. In the semi-presidential system, as in France, Russia and Sri Lanka, there is both a president, who has significant day-to-day powers, and a prime minister. Only in a presidential system, such as the USA and Brazil, is the president both head of state and head of government and not accountable to the legislature. So the type depends on where real power lies and to whom the executive is responsible, not on the title.
Haven’t we had very strong Prime Ministers? Does it mean that even the parliamentary system is not fool proof against personality cult? That means people and the legislatures have to be constantly vigilant!
Solution
The comment is right. The makers of the Constitution chose the parliamentary system so that there are mechanisms to control the executive and guard against a personality cult, but no system is fool-proof. The Prime Minister is very powerful when one party has a majority, so the legislature, the opposition and citizens need to be constantly vigilant.
It is very well to talk of the President as He or She, but has a woman ever become the President?
Solution
Yes. Pratibha Patil, the first woman President, held office from 2007 to 2012, and Droupadi Murmu became President in 2022. (These facts are not given in this chapter.)
Check your progress: Imagine that the Prime Minister wants to impose ‘President’s rule’ in one State because the State government has failed to effectively curb atrocities against the Dalits in that State. The President has a different position. He is saying that the provision regarding President’s rule should be used only sparingly. In this situation which of the following courses are open to the President?
Tell the Prime Minister that he will not sign on the order promulgating President’s rule.
Dismiss the Prime Minister.
Ask the Prime Minister to send CRPF to that State.
Make a press statement about how the Prime Minister is wrong.
Discuss the matter with the Prime Minister and try to dissuade him from taking this action, but if he insists, agreeing to sign the said order.
Solution
(e) is open to the President. The President has the right to be informed of all matters and can write to the Prime Minister and express views; he can also send the advice back for reconsideration once, but must accept it when it is repeated by the Council of Ministers. So the President can discuss and try to dissuade the Prime Minister but must finally sign.
The other courses are not open: (a) the President cannot refuse to sign the advice after reconsideration; (b) the President cannot dismiss a Prime Minister who has the majority; (c) sending the CRPF is not a function of the President acting alone, and it would not be what the Prime Minister wants; (d) a public statement against the Prime Minister would go against the convention that the President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers and gives his views to the Prime Minister privately (this reasoning goes slightly beyond the text).
Read a Cartoon (Shankar, 22 August 1954): There is no Council of Ministers without the Prime Minister. This cartoon shows how, literally, the Prime Minister ‘leads’ the Council of Ministers!
Solution
The cartoon shows the Prime Minister walking in front, with a crowd of ministers carrying files and briefcases following behind him towards a door marked “Lok Sabha”; as the book says, the Prime Minister literally ‘leads’ the Council of Ministers. The point is that the Council of Ministers cannot exist without the Prime Minister: it comes into existence only after the Prime Minister takes the oath, and the death or resignation of the Prime Minister dissolves the Council automatically, while the resignation of a minister only creates a vacancy. This is why Nehru called the Prime Minister the linchpin of government.
No discussion of government or politics in India, would normally take place without mentioning one office: the Prime Minister of India. Can you imagine why this is so?
Solution
Because the Prime Minister is the most important functionary of the government. The President exercises powers only on the advice of the Council of Ministers, and the Council is headed by the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister, who has the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha, chooses the ministers, allocates their ranks and portfolios, links the Council with the President and Parliament, and decides the policies of the government.
Read a Cartoon (R.K. Laxman): Why do people want to be ministers? This cartoon seems to suggest that it is only for perks and status! Then why is there competition for some portfolios?
Solution
The cartoon shows a newspaper headline, “Minister unhappy with portfolio”, and an official asking the dhoti-clad minister whether the portfolio is all that matters; the caption lists the house, the car, the servants, travel, foreign trips, security and secretaries as other attractions.
Sample answer: perks and status are one reason, but not the only one. Some portfolios carry real power over policy, budgets, appointments and projects, give a minister public visibility and political weight, and the chance to do things for the people and for his or her party and region. That is why there is competition for some portfolios (the Prime Minister allocates ranks and portfolios by seniority and political importance), and coalition partners bargain over them.
Is it that a person becomes Prime Minister because he/she is powerful or is it that you become powerful once you have become the Prime Minister?
Solution
Both are partly true. A person becomes Prime Minister by commanding the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha, which already requires political strength. After that, the office adds power from several sources: control over the Council of Ministers, leadership of the Lok Sabha, command over the bureaucracy, access to media, projection as a national leader, and international summitry. But how much power the Prime Minister actually uses depends on political conditions: it is unassailable when one party has a majority, but reduced in coalition governments.
Read a Cartoon (R.K. Laxman): This Chief Minister is not happy even after winning the confidence motion! Can you imagine why this is so?
Solution
The cartoon’s caption has the Chief Minister say, “My troubles are not over - I won the confidence vote!” Sample answer: winning the confidence vote only keeps the government in office; the Chief Minister of a coalition has to keep satisfying the allies and supporters, who bargain for ministerial posts and policies, as the book notes that in coalitions policies and ministers are decided after negotiations, so the leader acts more as a negotiator. The vote may also have been won only with concessions, and the next trouble may begin at once.
Check your progress: Suppose the Prime Minister is to select the Council of Ministers. What will he/she do? a. Select those who are experts in the various subjects. b. Select only those who are from his/her party. c. Select those who are personally loyal and dependable. d. Select those who are supporters of the government. e. Take into account the political weight of the various aspirants and choose from among them.
Solution
In practice the Prime Minister does (e), with (d) and, in a single-party government, (b). The ministers come from the party or coalition that supports the government (all ministers must be MPs, or get elected within six months), and the Prime Minister assigns ranks and portfolios by seniority and political importance. In a coalition, the PM has to accept the choices and demands of the allies, so (b) cannot be followed. (a) expertise and (c) personal loyalty may count, but they are not the main criteria; the Prime Minister cannot pick only experts, because ministers must be MPs and must have political support.
(e), together with (d)
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF