NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 1
Chapter 1: Constitution: Why and How? (Constitution: Why and How?)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 1: Constitution: Why and How? (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on the functions and authority of a constitution and the making of the Indian Constitution, plus the in-text questions and cartoons. All 25 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
Which of these is not a function of the constitution?
It gives a guarantee of the rights of the citizen.
It marks out different spheres of power for different branches of government.
It ensures that good people come to power.
It gives expression to some shared values.
Solution
(c) It ensures that good people come to power. A constitution guarantees rights (limits on government), marks out the spheres of power of different branches (who gets to decide) and expresses shared values and aspirations. It cannot ensure that good people are elected; that depends on the voters and the leaders themselves.
Which of the following is a good reason to conclude that the authority of the constitution is higher than that of the parliament?
The constitution was framed before the parliament came into being.
The constitution makers were more eminent leaders than the members of the parliament.
The constitution specifies how parliament is to be formed and what are its powers.
The constitution cannot be amended by the parliament.
Solution
(c) The constitution specifies how parliament is to be formed and what are its powers. Parliament gets its authority to make laws from the Constitution, which constitutes the government in the first place. The other reasons are weak: being earlier or having eminent makers does not make a document superior, and Parliament can in fact amend the Constitution within the limits the Constitution itself sets.
(c) The constitution specifies how parliament is to be formed and what are its powers.
State whether the following statements about a constitution are True or False.
Constitutions are written documents about formation and power of the government.
Constitutions exist and are required only in democratic countries.
Constitution is a legal document that does not deal with ideals and values.
A constitution gives its citizens a new identity.
Solution
True. In most countries a constitution is a compact document of articles about how the state is to be constituted and what norms it should follow.
False. Monarchical constitutions and the old Soviet Union’s one-party constitution also existed; every society needs basic rules, not only democracies.
False. Constitutions express the aspirations and goals of a society and its fundamental values, as the Indian Constitution does through the Preamble and Directive Principles.
True. By agreeing to a basic set of norms a people forms a collective political identity and also a moral identity.
State whether the following inferences about the making of the Indian Constitution are Correct or Incorrect. Give reasons to support your answer.
The Constituent Assembly did not represent the Indian people since it was not elected by all citizens.
Constitution making did not involve any major decision since there was a general consensus among the leaders at that time about its basic framework.
There was little originality in the Constitution, for much of it was borrowed from other countries.
Solution
Incorrect. The Assembly was not elected by universal suffrage, but there was a serious attempt to make it representative: members of all religions were represented, it had twenty-eight members from the Scheduled Castes, and the Congress, which held 82 per cent of the seats after Partition, itself accommodated almost all shades of opinion. Its authority also came from its procedures of open, reasoned deliberation, with each member thinking of the interests of the whole nation.
Incorrect. There was a background consensus on main principles, inherited from the nationalist movement, but on many issues there were serious differences of principle: a centralised or decentralised system, relations between the States and the centre, the powers of the judiciary and whether to protect property rights. The Assembly met for 166 days over two years and eleven months, and only universal suffrage was passed virtually without debate.
Incorrect. The framers did borrow provisions from other constitutions, but this was not slavish imitation. Each provision had to be defended as suited to Indian problems and aspirations, and the Constitution was innovative, for example in its enabling provisions for removing inequality. As Dr Ambedkar said, the only new things in a late constitution are the variations made to remove faults and meet the needs of the country.
Give two examples each to support the following conclusions about the Indian Constitution:
The Constitution was made by credible leaders who commanded peoples’ respect.
The Constitution has distributed power in such a way as to make it difficult to subvert it.
The Constitution is the locus of people’s hopes and aspirations.
Solution
(a) Credible leaders
The Assembly’s eight major Committees were chaired by leaders such as Jawaharlal Nehru, Rajendra Prasad, Sardar Patel and B.R. Ambedkar, men who enjoyed immense public credibility and could negotiate and command the respect of a wide cross-section of society.
The Constitution came out of the nationalist movement, which had a remarkable ability to take different sections of society together. Though it was not put to a referendum, it carried public authority because it had the backing of popular leaders, and the people adopted it by abiding by its provisions.
(b) Power distributed so that it is hard to subvert
Power is fragmented horizontally across the Legislature, Executive and Judiciary and independent statutory bodies like the Election Commission, so if one institution tries to subvert the Constitution the others can check it (checks and balances).
The Constitution balances flexibility and authority: it can be changed but with limits on such changes, so no section or group can on its own subvert it.
(c) Locus of hopes and aspirations
The Preamble and the Fundamental Rights contain enabling provisions that let the government take positive welfare measures, some legally enforceable, so that each person can lead a life of minimal dignity and social self-respect.
The Directive Principles of State Policy enjoin the government to fulfil certain aspirations of the people; the Objectives Resolution also promised social, economic and political justice, equality and freedoms to all.
Why is it necessary for a country to have a clear demarcation of powers and responsibilities in the constitution? What would happen in the absence of such a demarcation?
Solution
A constitution has to settle who gets to decide what the laws will be, and how the government is to be constituted. Powers and responsibilities of the legislature, executive, judiciary and of the centre and the States must therefore be clearly marked out. This gives everyone certainty about who may do what, and no single institution can gather a monopoly of power. Each institution can check the others, which makes it hard for small groups to subvert the Constitution.
In the absence of such a demarcation there would be disputes about who has the authority to make laws, and laws could be challenged as having no clear source of authority. Institutions would overlap and clash, citizens would be insecure about what rulers could do to them, and a single group could take over all power and misuse it.
Why is it necessary for a constitution to place limitations on the rulers? Can there be a constitution that gives no power at all to the citizens?
Solution
Even a government that has come to power by proper procedures can pass laws that are patently unjust: banning a religion, allowing arbitrary arrest, or denying property or water to a group of people. A constitution therefore sets limits that the government may never trespass, most commonly by specifying fundamental rights such as protection from arbitrary arrest and freedom of speech, conscience, association and trade. These limits protect citizens, especially minorities, from a ruler who might misuse power.
A constitution can in principle be written to give citizens no power at all: a monarchical constitution gives the decision to a monarch, and the old Soviet Union’s constitution gave it to a single party. But such a constitution would not give people any reason to go along with it. The chapter says a successful constitution must give everyone some reason to follow it, and democratic constitutions let the people decide; so a constitution that denies citizens all power would lack authority and be unlikely to last.
The Japanese Constitution was made when the US occupation army was still in control of Japan after its defeat in the Second World War. The Japanese constitution could not have had any provision that the US government did not like. Do you see any problem in this way of making the constitution? In which way was the Indian experience different from this?
Solution
Yes. The authority of a constitution depends partly on who made it and how much authority they had. A constitution framed under the control of an outside power is not the free choice of the people who must live by it, and it may not carry them along or earn their voluntary allegiance. It would be seen as imposed rather than as their own.
The Indian experience was different. The Constitution was made by the Indians themselves in the Constituent Assembly, led by respected leaders of the nationalist movement. It gave concrete form to principles forged in the long struggle for freedom, summed up in the Objectives Resolution moved by Nehru in 1946. The Assembly deliberated openly for 166 days, and every provision had to be justified by reasons. It therefore reflected the broad national consensus, and the people adopted it as their own.
Rajat asked his teacher this question: “ The constitution is a fifty year old and therefore outdated book. No one took my consent for implementing it. It is written in such tough language that I cannot understand it. Tell me why should I obey this document?” If you were the teacher, how would you answer Rajat?
Solution
Sample answer: Rajat, a constitution is not an old book to be thrown away. It is a living document that provides for change: it can be amended, but with limits, so it adapts to new needs while keeping core values. It was framed by credible leaders after open debate, and the people adopted it by abiding by it, so consent is expressed in everyday life even without a referendum.
Further, it protects you: it guarantees your rights, limits the power of rulers, sets out who makes laws and how, and gives you an equal status and identity as a citizen. Without such basic rules there would be insecurity and no assurance that others would follow rules. As for the language, it is complex, but it can be understood step by step; this very book is meant to explain it. Obeying it is in everyone’s interest because it keeps the framework of freedom and equality that we all share.
In a discussion on the experience of the working of our Constitution, three speakers took three different positions:
Harbans: The Indian Constitution has succeeded in giving us a framework of democratic government.
Neha: The Constitution made solemn promises of ensuring liberty, equality and fraternity. Since this has not happened, the Constitution has failed.
Nazima: The Constitution has not failed us. We have failed the Constitution.
Do you agree with any of these positions? If yes, why? If not, what is your own position?
Solution
Sample answer: I largely agree with Harbans and Nazima. Harbans is right that the Constitution has given us a lasting framework of democratic government, with checks and balances among the Legislature, Executive and Judiciary and bodies like the Election Commission, which has helped it survive when many other constitutions have perished.
Neha is right that liberty, equality and fraternity are not fully realised, but that does not mean the Constitution has failed. It sets goals and provides enabling provisions; whether they are achieved depends on governments and citizens who act on them. Nazima’s view is the most convincing: where the promises are unfulfilled, the fault lies in how we have worked the Constitution, and the remedy is to use its provisions, such as rights and institutions, more faithfully. A constitution is a living document that gives a framework for pursuing justice, not perfect justice by itself.
This group is very much like the people of my village. / Yes, this could be my colony as well! Does this apply to your village or town or colony too?
Solution
Sample answer: Yes. Like the imagined group, my town has people of different religions, professions, abilities and tastes, rich and poor, old and young. They disagree about questions such as property, schooling and spending on safety or parks, yet they must live together and depend on one another. So some basic rules known and enforceable for everyone are needed here too.
Activity: Enact the thought experiment of this section in the classroom. The entire class should discuss and arrive at some decisions that would apply to everyone for this entire session. (How would the class representatives be chosen? Which decisions will the representative be able to take on behalf of the entire class? Are there some decisions that the class representative cannot take without consulting the entire class? ... How to revise these decisions in case you need to? ... Which problems did you encounter in this decision? Were there differences among different students? How did you resolve these differences? Did the entire class gain something from this exercise?)
Solution
Guidance: Hold a class meeting and write the rules on paper. A sample set: the representative is chosen by secret ballot for the session; he or she may handle routine matters such as the notice board and duty roster; spending the common kitty, picnics and trips need the approval of the whole class; rules can be revised only by a majority vote in a class meeting. Typical difficulties are differing preferences and who should decide; these are resolved by discussion and voting. The class gains a feel for why basic rules, a decision-making body and limits on its powers are needed, which are the functions of a constitution.
Read a Cartoon (“European Constitution”): Countries of the European Union tried to create a European constitution. The attempt failed. Here is a cartoonist’s impression of this attempt. Does this always happen in any constitution making?
Solution
The cartoon shows leaders seated around a table on which lies a document marked “European Constitution”, quarrelling instead of agreeing; its caption reads “The Feuding Fathers”, a play on “Founding Fathers”.
No, it does not always happen. Making a constitution is not always easy and smooth (Nepal needed several constitutions), but successful constitutions such as those of India, South Africa and the United States were created after popular national movements by leaders who had public credibility. In India, differences were many but they were settled by reasoned debate and consensus.
Ah! So you first create a monster and then start worrying about saving yourself from it! I would say, why create this monster called government in the first place?
Solution
Without a government there would be no one to make the basic rules binding on all, no assurance that others will follow them and no coordination in the society, so people would be insecure. A government is needed; the answer is not to have none but to constitute it by a constitution that limits its power. Fundamental rights and a balanced division of power among institutions ensure that the government can never trespass certain limits.
Read a Cartoon (Shankar, 4 December 1949): The constitution makers have to address themselves to very different aspirations. Here is Nehru trying to balance between different visions and ideologies. Can you identify what these different groups stand for? Who do you think prevailed in this balancing act?
Solution
In the cartoon Nehru, drawn with two faces, conducts a group of musicians. On one side are men in Western suits playing Western-style instruments, under the words “Jana Gana Mana”. On the other side are men in Indian dress, sitting on the floor and singing, under the words “Vande Mataram”.
The groups stand for different visions: a modern, Western-influenced outlook and a traditional, indigenous one, with differing views on the form of government and the values to uphold. Sample answer: neither side wholly prevailed; the Constitution balanced them by borrowing the best from other constitutions while adapting it to Indian aspirations, and the Assembly tried to reach consensus. Who prevailed is left to the reader’s opinion.
What does it take to write nice things in the constitution? What is the point in writing down lofty aspirations and goals if they cannot change the life of the people?
Solution
Writing aspirations is only the first step; what it takes is enabling provisions that give the government the power and duty to act, citizens who insist on them, and institutions that work. Where the Constitution empowers the government to take positive measures, such as to reduce inequality, ensure health care or housing (South Africa) or run a national education system (Indonesia), the aspirations can change lives. Some Indian welfare measures are also legally enforceable. A constitution that exists only on paper is of little use.
Read a Cartoon (“Iraqi Constitution”): The writing of the new Iraqi constitution after the collapse of Saddam Hussain’s regime saw a lot of conflict between different ethnic groups in the country. What do these different people stand for? Compare the conflict depicted here with that depicted in earlier cartoons for the European Union and India.
Solution
The cartoon shows a speaker in Baghdad saying, “Now that they’ve agreed to join hands, we expect a constitution very soon”, while people labelled Shiites, Sunnis and Kurds each grab for the paper, the pen and the ink, each shouting that he will write it. The groups stand for the major ethnic and religious communities of Iraq, each seeking to shape the constitution.
Comparison: in the European Union cartoon the conflict is between the leaders of different countries and it ended in failure. In the Iraqi cartoon the conflict is between ethnic and religious groups within one country, who struggle to control the writing itself. In the Indian cartoon, Nehru is balancing different visions and ideologies like a conductor holding a group together; the differences were accommodated through consensus and deliberation rather than a scramble.
Check your progress: Here are some provisions of the Indian and other constitutions. For each of these write the function that this provision performs.
Solution
Provision
Function
The government cannot order any citizen to follow or not to follow any religion
Limitations on the power of the government (this is the example given in the book)
The government must try to reduce inequalities in income and wealth
Enabling the government to fulfil the aspirations of society and create conditions for a just society
The President has the power to appoint the Prime Minister
Specifying who has the power to make decisions; deciding how the government is to be constituted
The Constitution is the supreme law that everyone has to obey
Providing a set of basic rules that allow for minimal coordination among members of a society (the rules are known and enforceable)
Indian citizenship is not limited to people of any race, caste or religion
What do people do if they find out that their constitution is not just? What happens to people when a constitution exists only on paper?
Solution
If a constitution is not just, people have no reason to go along with it. A constitution that lets permanent majorities oppress minorities, or one that privileges some groups, ceases to command allegiance, and groups whose identity is stifled may agitate for a change of the constitution (as in Nepal, where agitations led to a new constituent assembly and a new constitution). When a constitution exists only on paper, it has no impact on people’s lives; it is mere words on parchment and fails to protect rights or limit the rulers.
Do this thought experiment. Ask yourself this question: What would be the content of some basic rules in society, such that they gave everyone a reason to go along with them?
Solution
Sample answer: such rules would have to preserve the freedom and equality of all members: equal rights and protection from arbitrary arrest, basic liberties of speech, conscience, association and trade, no permanent oppression of minorities, and a say for all in decisions. The more a constitution preserves freedom and equality, the more likely it is to succeed.
Read a Cartoon (“Castle of Cards”): Why does the cartoonist describe the new Iraqi Constitution as the castle of cards? Would this description apply to the Indian Constitution?
Solution
The cartoon shows a huge book labelled “Iraqi Constitution” perched on top of a flimsy castle of playing cards. The cartoonist suggests that the new constitution rests on a weak base: it was written amid conflict between groups and may collapse at the first shock.
The description does not apply to the Indian Constitution. It was framed by credible leaders after a popular national movement, it gives everyone reasons to follow it, and it distributes power across institutions with checks and balances. It also strikes a balance between rigidity and flexibility and is a living document, which is why it has survived.
Are the principles of liberty, equality and fraternity being practised in your classroom? How can they coexist? Discuss this with your friends.
Solution
Sample answer: partly. Liberty is seen when students may express their views; equality when all are treated alike in rules and opportunities; fraternity when classmates cooperate and respect one another. They can coexist only together: as Dr Ambedkar said, without equality liberty would produce the supremacy of the few over the many; equality without liberty would kill individual initiative; and without fraternity, liberty and equality could not become a natural course of things.
What would have happened if the Constituent Assembly was elected by all the people of India? Could it be very different from what it was?
Solution
Sample answer: it would have been more directly representative, but it may not have been very different. The Assembly was already broadly representative, and the main principles had been settled during the nationalist movement. The book notes that the Assembly’s authority came from its procedures, deliberation and public reason, and that universal suffrage itself was accepted without debate.
What would have happened if we got independence in 1937? Or if we had to wait till 1957? Would our Constitution be very different from what it is today?
Solution
Sample answer: the Constitution gave concrete form to principles forged in the long nationalist struggle and was framed by the leaders of that movement, who enjoyed public credibility. Had independence come at a different time, the leaders, the circumstances (such as the experience of Partition) and the details might have differed. But the basic values of the movement, such as equality, liberty and democracy, would probably have remained the foundation.
Was it a borrowed constitution then? Why could we not have a constitution that does not borrow anything from anywhere else?
Solution
The framers did borrow provisions from other constitutions (for example, the parliamentary form of government, rule of law and the Speaker from Britain; the Fundamental Rights and judicial review from the United States; the Directive Principles from Ireland; the quasi-federal form and residual powers from Canada). But this was not slavish imitation: each provision had to be defended as suited to Indian problems and aspirations. Since many good ideas already existed, the wise course was to take the best available and make it their own; as Dr Ambedkar noted, the only new things in a late constitution are variations made to remove faults and meet the needs of the country.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF