NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 2
Chapter 2: Rights in the Indian Constitution (Rights in Indian Constitution)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 2: Rights in the Indian Constitution (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on Fundamental Rights, writs and the Directive Principles, plus the in-text questions and activities. All 25 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
Write true or false against each of these statements:
A Bill of Rights lays down the rights enjoyed by the people of a country.
A Bill of Rights protects the liberties of an individual.
Every country of the world has a Bill of Rights.
The Constitution guarantees remedy against violation of Rights.
Solution
True. A list of rights mentioned and protected by the constitution is called a bill of rights.
True. It prohibits the government from acting against the rights of individuals.
False. It is only the practice in most democratic countries to list rights in the constitution; the chapter does not say that every country has one (the United Kingdom, for example, has no single constitutional document).
True. A bill of rights ensures a remedy in case of violation; in India this is the Right to Constitutional Remedies.
Which of the following is the best description of Fundamental Rights?
All the rights an individual should have.
All the rights given to citizens by law.
The rights given and protected by the Constitution.
The rights given by the Constitution that cannot ever be restricted.
Solution
(c) The rights given and protected by the Constitution. Fundamental Rights are listed in the Constitution and guaranteed by it; ordinary legal rights are protected by ordinary law. They are not absolute (d is wrong) because the government can put reasonable restrictions on them.
(c) The rights given and protected by the Constitution.
Read the following situations. Which Fundamental Right is being used or violated in each case and how?
Overweight male cabin crew are allowed to get promotion in the national airlines but their women colleagues who gain weight are penalised.
A director makes a documentary film that criticises the policies of the government.
People displaced by a big dam take out a rally demanding rehabilitation.
Andhra society runs Telugu medium schools outside Andhra Pradesh.
Solution
The Right to Equality is violated. Women are penalised for something men are not, which is discrimination on grounds of sex and goes against equality in public employment.
The Right to Freedom is being used, specifically the freedom of speech and expression, which includes criticising government policy (subject only to reasonable restrictions such as public order).
The Right to Freedom is being used: the freedom to assemble peacefully and to speak and express demands.
The Cultural and Educational Rights are being used. Telugu speakers outside Andhra Pradesh are a linguistic minority, and minorities have the right to conserve their language and culture and to set up their own educational institutions.
Which of the following is a correct interpretation of the Cultural and Educational Rights?
Only children belonging to the minority group that has opened educational institution can study there.
Government schools must ensure that children of the minority group will be introduced to their belief and culture.
Linguistic and religious minorities can open schools for their children and keep it reserved for them.
Linguistic and religious minorities can demand that their children must not study in any educational institution except those managed by their own community.
Solution
(c) Minorities, religious or linguistic, can set up their own educational institutions to preserve and develop their culture, and so can open schools for their own children. (a) and (d) go beyond the right (nothing in the chapter allows demanding that children study only in community institutions, and the government cannot discriminate against such institutions when giving aid), and (b) is not part of the right.
(c) Linguistic and religious minorities can open schools for their children and keep it reserved for them.
Which of the following is a violation of Fundamental Rights and why?
Not paying minimum wages
Banning of a book
Banning of loudspeakers after 9 pm.
Making a speech
Solution
A violation. Paying less than the minimum wage amounts to begar or forced labour, a violation of the Right against Exploitation (as in the 1982 Asian Games workers’ case).
Banning of a book is a restriction on freedom of speech and expression. A ban on a book is therefore a violation of this right, unless the government can show that it is a reasonable restriction (for example on grounds of public order or morality); the chapter says such restrictions must be reasonable.
Not a violation. It is a reasonable restriction, in the interest of public peace and the rights of others, and does not take away the freedom of speech.
Not a violation. Making a speech is the exercise of the right to freedom of speech and expression.
An activist working among the poor says that the poor don’t need Fundamental Rights. What they need are Directive Principles to be made legally binding. Do you agree with this? Give your reasons.
Solution
No, I do not agree. The poor need both, and Fundamental Rights are essential to them:
Fundamental Rights are enforceable in court. The poor construction workers of the 1982 Asian Games project got their minimum wages because the Supreme Court enforced the right against exploitation; a Directive Principle could not have been enforced that way.
Fundamental Rights protect the poor against forced labour, discrimination and arbitrary arrest, and the Supreme Court has held that the right to life includes the right to livelihood and shelter, so they also protect basic welfare.
The Directive Principles are non-justiciable on purpose: the framers did not want future governments bound by particular policy decisions, but expected the moral force of the principles and public pressure to make governments act on them. Making all of them binding would take away that flexibility and could conflict with Fundamental Rights.
The Fundamental Rights restrain the government from doing certain things, while the Directive Principles exhort it to do certain things; the two are complementary, so the poor are best served when both are respected.
Several reports show that caste groups previously associated with scavenging are forced to continue in this job. Those in positions of authority refuse to give them any other job. Their children are discouraged from pursuing education. Which of their Fundamental Rights are being violated in this instance?
Solution
Right to Equality: discrimination on grounds of caste, denial of equality of opportunity in public employment, and the practice of untouchability, which has been abolished.
Right against Exploitation: being forced to continue in a job against their will amounts to forced labour (begar).
Right to Freedom: the freedom to practise any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business is denied.
Right to Education: their children are discouraged from education, which is a fundamental right for children; and the right to life with human dignity, free from exploitation, is also denied.
A petition by a human rights group drew attention of the court to the condition of starvation and hunger in the country. Over five crore tonnes of food grains was stored in the godowns of the Food Corporation of India. Research shows that a large number of ration cardholders do not know about the quantity of food grains they can purchase from fair price shops. It requested the court to order the government to improve its public distribution system. a. Which different rights does this case involve? How are these rights interlinked? b. Should these rights form part of the right to life?
Solution
(a) The case involves the right to life (starvation and hunger threaten life), the right to live with human dignity and a livelihood, which the Supreme Court has read into the right to life, and the right to information, since cardholders do not know what they are entitled to. The Directive Principles on adequate livelihood, welfare of the people and raising the standard of living also apply.
They are interlinked: without food a person cannot enjoy life or any other right; people cannot claim their entitlement from fair price shops unless they know about it; and the government can only be made to improve the distribution system if the right to life and the right to move the courts (constitutional remedies) are used together.
(b) Yes. The Supreme Court has held that the right to life means a life of human dignity, free from exploitation, and that no person can live without the means of living. Food is the most basic of these means, so the right to food should form part of the right to life. (Sample answer: this is the view in the book’s reasoning on livelihood and shelter; other views are possible.)
Read the statement by Somnath Lahiri in the Constituent Assembly quoted in this chapter. Do you agree with him? If yes, give instances to prove it. If not, give arguments against his position.
Solution
Sample answer: I agree to a large extent. Lahiri said that many fundamental rights were framed from the point of view of a police constable, with very minimum rights conceded and almost every article followed by a proviso that takes away the right almost completely. The chapter itself shows such restrictions: freedom of speech is subject to public order, peace and morality; the freedom to assemble may be denied in areas where assembly of five or more persons is declared unlawful, which can be misused to refuse permission to genuine protests; and preventive detention can be used against people for reasons other than those really justified, creating a tension with the right to life and personal liberty.
At the same time, freedoms must be defined so that one person’s freedom does not threaten the freedom of others or law and order, so some reasonable restrictions are needed, and the courts can strike down unreasonable ones. The real problem is therefore misuse of the provisos, which citizens being aware and vigilant can reduce.
Which of the Fundamental Rights is in your opinion the most important right? Summarise its provisions and give arguments to show why it is most important.
Solution
Sample answer: I think the Right to Constitutional Remedies is the most important. Provisions: a citizen can approach a High Court or the Supreme Court to get any Fundamental Right restored if it is violated; the courts can issue directions and writs, namely habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto and certiorari, to enforce rights; in later years commissions such as the National Human Rights Commission have been created for protecting rights.
Reasons: a list of rights is not enough unless there is a way to realise and defend it. This is why Dr Ambedkar called it the heart and soul of the Constitution. Without it, the other rights, to equality, freedom, against exploitation, of religion and cultural and educational, would remain only promises on paper, as in Machal Lalung’s case, where rights were not available in practice. It also gives the judiciary the power to protect all other rights from the government.
What if Machal was a rich and powerful man? What if those working with the construction contractor were engineers? Would their rights have been violated?
Solution
Sample answer: A rich and powerful man would probably have been able to get a lawyer and have his case heard, so he would not have spent 54 years in custody without a trial; similarly, engineers would be paid fair wages and would know about their rights. But rights belong to all citizens equally; if the same things happened to them, their rights would be violated in the same way. The examples show that the poor and the powerless are the people most at risk of having their rights violated in practice, which is why implementation of rights matters.
I get it! The bill of rights is like a warrantee card that we get when we purchase a TV or a fan. Isn’t it?
Solution
The comparison is helpful. Just as a warranty promises a remedy if the product fails, a bill of rights lists the rights of citizens and ensures a remedy in case they are violated. It prohibits the government from acting against the rights of individuals. The difference is that a warranty is a favour by the seller, whereas the rights in the Constitution are guaranteed to citizens and the courts must enforce them.
Check your progress: Compare the Fundamental Rights in the Indian Constitution with the Bill of Rights in the South African Constitution. Make a list of rights that are: Common to both the constitutions; Available in South Africa but not in India; Clearly granted in South Africa but implicit in the Indian Constitution.
Solution
Group
Rights (as listed in this chapter)
Common to both
Equality and protection against discrimination on grounds such as religion, race, caste, sex and others; the rights of children (India prohibits child labour in hazardous jobs and has made education a fundamental right for children, as South Africa gives basic and higher education); freedom of religion, conscience and belief; rights of cultural, religious and linguistic minorities; protection against exploitation, forced labour (compare South Africa’s fair labour practices)
Available in South Africa but not in India (not listed among India’s Fundamental Rights)
Right to privacy; right to a healthy environment and its protection; right to adequate housing; right to health care, food, water and social security; right to information. (In India some of these appear only as Directive Principles or have come through court interpretation.)
Clearly granted in South Africa but implicit in the Indian Constitution
Right to dignity (the Supreme Court has said the right to life includes living with human dignity); housing and livelihood (the Supreme Court has held that the right to shelter and livelihood is part of the right to life); the right to fair labour practices (implied in the right against exploitation)
Consider the following two situations. These are imaginary situations. But similar things do happen and can happen. Do you think they involve violation of fundamental rights?
Swadesh Kumar is visiting his village. He is accompanied by one of his friends. They decided to have a cup of tea at the village roadside hotel. The shopkeeper knew Swadesh Kumar but asked the name of his friend to know his caste. After this the shopkeeper served tea to Swadesh Kumar in a nice mug while his friend was given tea in an earthen cup because he was dalit.
An order is served to four newsreaders of a television channel that they would no longer read the news on screen. They are all women. The reason given is that they are above the age of forty-five. Two male newsreaders above the same age are not barred from presenting the news.
Do such things really happen in our country? Or are these purely imaginary? These are examples of clear discrimination. In one instance the discrimination is based on caste and in another it is based on gender. Do you think that such discrimination is justified?
Solution
Yes, both involve a violation of the Right to Equality. In the first, the shopkeeper discriminates on the ground of caste (serving the Dalit friend tea in an earthen cup), which violates the equal access to public places such as shops and hotels and the abolition of untouchability. In the second, the women newsreaders are barred while men of the same age are not, which is discrimination on the ground of sex in employment.
The book says that similar things do happen and can happen. Such discrimination is clearly not justified: it denies equality of dignity and status, which the right to equality tries to do away with.
Have you read the Preamble to our Constitution? How does it describe equality?
Solution
The Preamble mentions two things about equality: equality of status and equality of opportunity. Equality of opportunity means that all sections of society enjoy equal opportunities; since society has various kinds of social inequalities, the Constitution clarifies that the government can implement special schemes and measures for improving the conditions of certain sections: children, women, and the socially and educationally backward classes. Article 16(4), which allows reservation of appointments or posts for backward classes not adequately represented in the services, is therefore not a violation of the right to equality.
You are the Judge: You have received a postcard from Hadibandhu, who identifies himself as a “member of the dalit community” in Puri district in Odisha. Men from this community refused to follow a custom that required them to wash the feet of the groom and guests of the ‘upper caste’ during marriage ceremonies. In revenge, four women from this community were beaten up and another was paraded naked. Assuming that the facts given above are correct, you have to decide: Does this case involve violation of Fundamental Rights? What would you order the government to do in this case?
Solution
Yes. Assuming the facts are correct, several Fundamental Rights are violated. The custom is discrimination on grounds of caste and a form of untouchability, which the Right to Equality abolishes. Forcing men to wash feet and clear leftovers without pay is begar or forced labour, prohibited by the Right against Exploitation. Beating the women and parading one naked violate the right to life and personal liberty, which includes the right to live with human dignity, and the Right to Freedom.
Orders (sample): the government must immediately ensure protection to the families; arrest and prosecute those who beat and humiliated the women; pay compensation to the victims; take steps to end the custom, including awareness campaigns, and strict action against anyone enforcing it; and report to the court on action taken.
Does it mean that in some cases someone’s life can be taken away by law? That sounds strange. Can you think of an example?
Solution
Article 21 says no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. So the state cannot take anyone’s life or liberty by an arbitrary act, but a person can be deprived of liberty, for instance imprisoned, after arrest and trial by a fair procedure of law. Sample example: a person held guilty of a grave crime by a court after a fair trial may be given a punishment, such as imprisonment, that the law prescribes; the death penalty, where the law provides for it, is a similar case. The point is that it can happen only by the procedure laid down in law.
Check your progress: Do you think that the following situations demand restrictions on right to freedom? Give reasons to support your answer.
People have assembled for a peace march after communal riots in the city.
Dalits are denied entry in a temple. A march is being organised to forcibly enter the temple.
Hundreds of Adivasis blocked the road demanding that the land taken away from them for an industry be returned.
A caste panchayat is meeting to decide the punishment to a young couple for marrying outside their caste.
Solution
Sample answers: freedom has to be exercised peacefully and without threatening the freedom of others or law and order.
No restriction is needed, as it is a peaceful assembly that promotes harmony. The administration may take care of security.
The denial of entry is itself a violation (equality, abolition of untouchability, freedom of religion); the march should be allowed to be peaceful. Forcible entry that may lead to violence calls for police protection and a legal remedy (approaching the court) rather than any restriction on the peaceful protest.
The protest demand is genuine and protest is a part of the freedom of expression and assembly, but blocking the road affects the freedom of others and public order, so reasonable regulation, such as allowing the protest at a place that does not block the road, is justified, along with a hearing of their demand.
Restriction is needed. A caste panchayat has no power to punish; its decision would violate the couple’s freedom and the right to life and liberty, so the meeting and its punishment should be prevented by law.
Name the fundamental rights whose violation is depicted in this photograph.
Solution
The photograph shows a small child working (sorting beans). It depicts the violation of the Right against Exploitation, as the Constitution forbids employment of children below 14 years in dangerous jobs like factories and mines, and, since education is now a fundamental right for children, of the Right to Education (and the Right to Freedom and right to life with dignity).
Activity: Make a list of public religious activities that take place in your village or city. Which of these involve an exercise of right to religious freedom? Discuss what could have happened if this right was not available to people in your locality.
Solution
Guidance: List activities such as festival processions, prayers at temples, mosques, churches and gurudwaras, religious fairs and the sharing of religious literature. All of these exercise the freedom to profess, practise and propagate religion, subject to public order, morality and health. If the right did not exist, the ruling group could have forced people to follow its own religion, as rulers did in history, and followers of other faiths could have been persecuted or forced to convert.
I am in minority in my locality but majority in the town, minority if you look at my language but majority if you go by my religion... Aren’t we all minorities?
Solution
In a sense a person may belong to a minority on one count and the majority on another. But the minority status in the Constitution refers to groups with a common language or religion that are outnumbered by another section in a particular part of the country or in the country as a whole. They have a culture, language and script of their own and the right to conserve and develop them. As Sardar Hukam Singh said, a heavy responsibility is cast on the majority to see that minorities feel secure.
Check your progress: It is estimated that there are about three million urban homeless in India. Night shelters are not available for more than five per cent of this population. Hundreds of these old, sick homeless people are killed by cold wave during winter. They cannot have ration and voting cards in the absence of any ‘proof of residence’. Without these documents they also cannot avail government help as needy patients. A large number of these homeless people are casual workers, who earn very low wages. They travel to the city in search of work from different parts of the country. Use these facts to write a petition to the Supreme Court of India under the Right to Constitutional Remedies. Your petition should mention:
What Fundamental Rights are being denied to the homeless in their everyday life?
What kind of order would you request the Supreme Court to issue?
Solution
Sample petition: To the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. Petitioner: a citizen acting for the urban homeless. Under the Right to Constitutional Remedies, I submit that about three million urban homeless people live in India, but night shelters are available for not more than five per cent of them. Many old and sick homeless people die in cold waves each winter. They cannot get ration and voting cards without proof of residence, and without these documents cannot avail government help as needy patients. Most are casual workers on very low wages.
(a) Rights denied: the right to life and personal liberty, which the Supreme Court has held includes shelter, livelihood and a life of human dignity, free from exploitation; the right to equality (equal protection of the laws), as they are excluded from welfare because they lack an address; the right against exploitation, as low-paid casual workers are open to exploitation; and, for their children, the right to education.
(b) Orders sought: a writ of mandamus directing the central and State governments to provide adequate night shelters, especially in winter; to issue ration cards, identity and voting cards without insisting on proof of residence; to give free medical treatment to the needy; to ensure that the minimum wage is paid to casual workers; and to report to the court on steps taken within a fixed time.
Tell me what is the point of saying nice things in the Constitution if these cannot be implemented by any court?
Solution
Directive Principles are non-justiciable, so a court cannot compel the government to implement them. Yet they have a point: they set the goals and policies that the framers wanted and were meant to carry a moral force; the framers expected the government to take them seriously and the people to hold governments responsible for implementing them. They have in fact guided action: zamindari abolition, nationalisation of banks, factory laws, minimum wages, support to cottage industries, reservations, panchayati raj, the right to education, the employment guarantee programme and the mid-day meal scheme. They also left future governments free to choose how to achieve them.
What difference, do you think, this change of status makes to the right to property?
Solution
When the right to property was a Fundamental Right, it was protected by the Constitution, and a person could go straight to the Supreme Court or a High Court if it was violated, under the Right to Constitutional Remedies, and it could not be changed by ordinary law-making; the Constitution only permitted the government to take property for public welfare. After the 44th amendment (1978) it is only a legal right under Article 300 A, so it can be limited by ordinary law and the government can acquire property more easily for public welfare, for example for land reform; a person can no longer approach the Supreme Court under Article 32 for its violation (a remedy is through ordinary legal processes).
Check your progress: Read the main points of the Bill of Rights in the South African Constitution and the Directive Principles in India. Which are the common points in the two lists? Why did the South African Constitution put these in the Bill of Rights? If you were writing the constitution for a new country, what would you suggest?
Solution
Common points: the welfare of the people and the raising of living standards; adequate livelihood and fair labour or the right to work; the right against economic exploitation; basic education and early childhood education; and social, economic and political justice, including provision for social security of the people.
Why South Africa put them in the Bill of Rights: it emerged from a history of deep racial discrimination and inequality and was threatened by civil war after apartheid, so it wanted these social and economic rights to be rights that people can claim and that a constitutional court enforces. Its constitution therefore requires the government to ensure progressively adequate housing, health care and so on.
Suggestion (sample): I would make basic rights to life, equality, freedom and education enforceable, and list the economic goals as directives or as progressively enforceable rights depending on what the country can afford, with a body to monitor their implementation.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered