Activity 4.1Visit a market or shopping area in the town or city where you live. Find out who the important traders are. To which community do they belong? Are there particular areas of business that are controlled by particular communities, for instance, jewellery shops, kirana (provisions) shops, the hardware trade, furniture making shops, and so on? Visit some of these shops and find out about the traders who run them and their communities. Are they hereditary family businesses?
Solution
Guidance. Visit a market, list four or five shop types and note the community of the owners and whether the business is hereditary. Tabulate the findings: shop type, owner's community, family business (yes/no), year started.
Expected conclusion, in line with the chapter: trade often runs through caste and kin networks (as with the Nakarattars and Marwaris), and particular communities tend to dominate some lines of business because traders trust members of their own community, which creates a kind of caste monopoly. Report what you actually find, including any shops run by new entrants.
Activity 4.2Can you think of other examples of things that have been commodified relatively recently? Remember, a commodity need not only be a thing or object; it can also be a service. Try also to think of things that are not commodities today but could become commodities in the future. What are the reasons why this could happen? Finally, try to think of things that were commodities in the past but have stopped being commodities today (i.e., they used to have market or exchange value before but do not have it now). When and why do commodities stop being commodities?
Solution
Sample answer.
- Recently commodified: bottled drinking water; marriage bureaus and matrimonial websites; private coaching classes and personality-development courses (examples from the chapter); also paid online services such as tutoring and entertainment streaming.
- Could become commodities in future: for example, clean air in cities (sold in bottles or through purifiers), or personal data. This could happen as scarcity grows and people are willing to pay to avoid a problem, or as technology makes it possible to sell it.
- Stopped being commodities: human beings as slaves (now considered immoral and illegal); services like professional letter-writing, which have lost market value because of changing technology and demand.
A thing stops being a commodity when it is declared immoral or illegal to sell it, or when it becomes outdated, freely available or no longer in demand. Students may give their own examples.
Activity 4.3Interpretation of Advertisements. Make a collection of advertisements from newspapers and magazines. From the collection, choose two or three that you find interesting. For each of these advertisements, try to answer the following questions. 1. What is the product that is being advertised, and what image has been created of that product? 2. How has the advertiser tried to relate this product to a desirable lifestyle or social status?
Solution
Guidance (sample). For each advertisement note the product (for example a mobile phone, a car or a soft drink), the image created (modern, successful, youthful, luxurious) and the way it is linked to lifestyle or status through the people shown, the setting, slogans and brand symbols.
Use the chapter's ideas: consumption has symbolic meaning, goods act as status symbols (Max Weber), and advertisers attach meanings of status or culture to goods to sell them. Conclude by noting which social group the advertisement is aimed at.
Exercise for Box 4.3Read the passages in Box 4.3, which are taken from a guide book meant for foreign tourists. The passage illustrates the way in which a market - in this case the traditional annual cattle market and fair at Pushkar - can itself become a kind of product for sale in another market, in this case the market for tourism. Discuss the passages in class before you go on to answer the questions: 1. What are the new circuits of goods, services, money, and people that have been created at Pushkar because it is now a part of the international tourist circuit? 2. How do you think the coming of large numbers of foreign and Indian tourists has changed the way in which this fair operates? 3. How does the religiosity of the place add to its marketability? Can we say that there is a market for spirituality in India? 4. Can you think of other examples of how religions, traditions, knowledge, or even images (for instance, of a Rajasthani woman in traditional dress) become commodities in the global market?
Solution
1. New circuits. Sample answer based on the box. People: foreign and Indian tourists, musicians, mystics, traders and devotees (around 200,000 people each year, with 50,000 camels and cattle, according to the box). Goods and services: camel grooming and decoration, souvenirs, accommodation, guides and entertainment for tourists. Money: tourist spending, which flows to the local economy along with the earnings from livestock trade. Cultural symbols and religious merit are also exchanged, as the chapter notes.
2. Change in the fair. Sample answer. The fair continues to be a major social and economic event for local people, but it is now also marketed internationally as a tourist attraction. It is likely that the fair has become more of a show, with more services for tourists, commercial activity, crowds and organised arrangements, and the traditional livestock trade shares attention with tourism.
3. Religiosity and marketability. The fair is more attractive to tourists because it comes just before Kartik Purnima, when pilgrims bathe in the holy Pushkar Lake. The incense, chanting, processions and the bathing on ‘dousing day’ make an exotic and meaningful experience. Hindu pilgrims, camel traders and foreign tourists mingle, exchanging livestock, money, cultural symbols and religious merit. Yes, we can say there is a market for spirituality in India, as the marketing of yoga and ayurveda in the West also shows.
4. Other examples. The book gives yoga and ayurveda marketed in the West and international tourism that sells culture. Other examples: traditional dance and music shows, handicrafts and festivals packaged for tourists, pilgrimage tours, and images of a Rajasthani woman in traditional dress used on posters, souvenirs and advertisements.