NCERT Solutions · Class 12 Political Science · NCERT Contemporary World Politics and Politics in India since Independence Politics in India since Independence · Chapter 8
Chapter 8: Recent Developments in Indian Politics (Recent Developments in India)
NCERT solutions for Class 12 Political Science Politics in India since Independence Chapter 8: Recent Developments in Indian Politics (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on coalition politics, Mandal, Ayodhya and the BJP, plus the in-text questions. All 18 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
The new consensus has four elements; the first is agreement among most parties on the new economic policies.
(b) Caste based parties
ii. Rise of OBCs
The political rise of the Other Backward Classes produced parties that sought better opportunities and a share of power for them.
(c) Personal Law and Gender Justice
i. Shah Bano case
The Supreme Court ruled in favour of the divorced Muslim woman Shah Bano, and the 1986 Act nullified the judgment; the case raised the issue of personal law and gender justice.
(d) Growing strength of Regional parties
iii. Coalition government
Since 1989 no government could be formed without the participation or support of regional parties.
State the main issues in Indian politics in the period after 1989. What different configurations of political parties these differences lead to?
Solution
Main issues after 1989
Defeat of the Congress and end of the Congress system: the party that won 415 Lok Sabha seats in 1984 was reduced to 197 in 1989. It remained important but lost its earlier centrality in the party system.
The Mandal issue: in 1990 the National Front government decided to implement the Mandal Commission recommendation of reserving central government jobs for the OBCs, leading to violent anti-Mandal protests and the political rise of the OBCs.
New economic policy: the structural adjustment programme or new economic reforms, visible from 1991, changed the direction the economy had followed since Independence.
Ayodhya and the Ram Janmabhoomi movement: it changed the discourse on secularism and democracy, and led to the debate on politics based on religious identity (communalism, secularism and democracy).
Change of leadership in the Congress: the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi in May 1991.
Configurations of parties that followed
1989: the National Front (Janata Dal and regional parties) formed a coalition government supported from outside by two opposite groups, the BJP and the Left Front.
1990-91: a section of the National Front led by Chandra Shekhar governed with Congress support.
1991-96: a Congress government headed by Narasimha Rao, supported by the AIADMK and some smaller parties.
1996: a BJP minority government, then the United Front (Janata Dal and regional parties) supported by the Congress and the Left, with Deve Gowda and later I. K. Gujral as Prime Minister.
1998-2004: the BJP-led National Democratic Alliance under Atal Behari Vajpayee; the 1999 government completed its full term.
2004 and 2009: the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance under Manmohan Singh.
2014 and 2019: the BJP won a clear majority on its own but still governed as the NDA.
Thus the period moved from one-party dominance to a multi-party system and an era of coalition and alliance politics, in which regional parties played a crucial role.
After 1989 the issues were the decline of the Congress, Mandal, new economic policy and Ayodhya, leading to coalitions such as NF, UF, NDA and UPA.
“In the new era of coalition politics, political parties are not aligning or re-aligning on the basis of ideology.” What arguments would you put forward to support or oppose this statement?
Solution
Arguments in support
The chapter says coalition politics has shifted the focus from ideological differences to power-sharing arrangements; the fourth element of the new consensus is emphasis on pragmatic considerations rather than ideological positions.
Most NDA parties did not agree with the Hindutva ideology of the BJP, yet they formed a government with it and stayed in power for a full term.
In 1989 both the BJP and the Left, two opposite groups, supported the National Front to keep the Congress out; in 1996 the Congress and the Left supported the United Front to keep the BJP out. Support changed with the situation, not with ideology.
The Left supported the UPA in 2004 and withdrew in July 2008 on the Indo-US nuclear deal.
Arguments against
Some parties kept to ideological positions: the BJP stressed nationalism and Hindutva, and the Left supported governments from outside without joining them.
Parties representing Dalits and OBCs were formed on clear social programmes (for example the BSP on bahujan empowerment) and entered alliances to advance these claims.
The chapter itself says that political competition was divided between a BJP-led and a Congress-led coalition, and that the 1989 and 1996 alignments were guided by a shared aim of keeping a rival out, which is itself a political position.
Conclusion: alliances are formed mainly for power and shared minimum goals, so ideology has become less important, though parties have not given up their basic ideas.
Support: pragmatism and power-sharing dominate (NDA partners and Hindutva). Oppose: parties still hold ideological positions.
Trace the emergence of BJP as a significant force in post-Emergency politics.
Solution
Origin: after the Emergency the Bharatiya Jana Sangh merged with the Janata Party. When the Janata Party fell and broke up, supporters of the erstwhile Jana Sangh formed the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in 1980.
Early ideology: it first adopted a broader platform than the Jana Sangh, embracing ‘Gandhian Socialism’ along with cultural nationalism. It did not do well in 1984 (2 seats against 415 for the Congress, vote share 7.4 per cent).
Hindutva and nationalism: after 1986 it made nationalism the core of its ideology and pursued Hindutva for political mobilisation. Two developments around 1986 became central: the Shah Bano case and the 1986 Act that nullified the Supreme Court judgment, which the BJP criticised as appeasement of the minority, and the Ayodhya Ram Janmabhoomi issue, including the unlocking of the structure in 1986.
Electoral rise: 85 seats in 1989 (11.4 per cent votes), 120 seats in 1991 (20.1 per cent), 160 in 1996. In 1996 it became the largest party and was invited to form the government, but could not get a majority.
Power: it led a coalition government from May 1998 to June 1999 and was re-elected in October 1999; Vajpayee was Prime Minister and the 1999 government completed its term.
Later: it declared Narendra Modi its Prime Ministerial candidate in 2013 and won 282 seats on its own in 2014, the first single-party majority in 30 years, and 303 in 2019.
The BJP formed in 1980 from the Jana Sangh, adopted Hindutva after 1986 and grew from 2 seats in 1984 to 303 in 2019.
In spite of the decline of Congress dominance, the Congress party continues to influence politics in the country. Do you agree? Give reasons.
Solution
Yes, I agree. The chapter says the Congress lost the kind of centrality it enjoyed earlier, but it remained an important party. The reasons are:
It ruled the country more than any other party even in the period since 1989.
It came back to power after the mid-term elections of 1991 as the single largest party, and Narasimha Rao became Prime Minister.
In 1996 the Congress supported the United Front government from outside, to keep the BJP out of power, so it influenced the formation of governments even when it was not in power.
In 2004 it entered coalitions in a big way and led the UPA, with Left support. It increased its seats after 1991, and in 2009 it rose from 145 to 206 seats; Manmohan Singh was Prime Minister for two terms.
Congress and BJP remained the two main rivals. Their combined vote share was above fifty per cent in most elections after 1989, and in 2004 there was a negligible difference between the votes of the Congress with its allies and of the BJP with its allies.
Even in 2014 and 2019 it kept a vote share of 19.5 per cent (44 and 52 seats).
So the Congress no longer dominates, but it still shapes politics as a major rival and an anchor of one of the two coalitions.
Yes. The Congress ruled most often since 1989, led the UPA in 2004 and 2009 and remains a main rival of the BJP.
Many people think that a two-party system is required for successful democracy. Drawing from India’s experience of last 30 years, write an essay on what advantages the present party system in India has.
Solution
Introduction. Many people feel that stable democracy needs two big parties. India's experience since 1989 shows that a multi-party system, which began after the end of Congress dominance, has served a country as large and diverse as ours well.
Wider representation. The nineties saw powerful parties and movements representing Dalits and the backward castes. The BSP gave political expression to the bahujan, and OBC parties claimed adequate representation and a due share of power. Many of these parties also expressed regional assertion. Two parties alone could not have carried all these voices.
Regional voices in national governance. State level parties now share power at the Centre and have played a central role in the country's politics for twenty years or so. The distinction between State level and national level parties has become less important.
Accommodation and consensus. Competition is intense, but a broad agreement has formed on new economic policies, backward caste claims, the role of State parties and pragmatism. Policy is thus fairly stable even when governments change.
Peaceful settlement of conflict. The Mandal issue and the Ayodhya dispute were sensitive, but they were settled through the courts and democratic procedures, such as the 1992 Supreme Court ruling on OBC reservation and the 2019 verdict on Ayodhya.
Choice and alternation. Since 1989 there were eleven governments at the Centre, all coalitions or minority governments until 2014, and power moved among the National Front, United Front, NDA and UPA. Voters could change governments without a breakdown of democracy. Even when the BJP won clear majorities in 2014 and 2019, coalition politics stayed relevant.
Conclusion. The present system is not free of problems, but it is more inclusive and adaptable than a two-party system could be. A successful democracy needs responsiveness and accommodation, and India's multi-party competition has provided both, which is why democratic politics is here to stay.
A multi-party system gives wider representation, shares power with regional parties, builds consensus and resolves conflict peacefully.
Read the passage and answer the questions below: Party politics in India has confronted numerous challenges. Not only has the Congress system destroyed itself, but the fragmentation of the Congress coalition has triggered a new emphasis on self-representation which raises questions about the party system and its capacity to accommodate diverse interests, .... . An important test facing the polity is to evolve a party system or political parties that can effectively articulate and aggregate a variety of interests. — Zoya Hasan (a) Write a short note on what the author calls challenges of the party system in the light of what you have read in this chapter. (b) Given an example from this chapter of the lack of accommodation and aggregation mentioned in this passage. (c) Why is it necessary for parties to accommodate and aggregate variety of interests?
Solution
(a) The author says that the Congress system, in which one party held together many interests like a coalition, broke up. As sections left the Congress and formed their own parties, each group began to emphasise self-representation. The chapter shows this in the rise of Dalit and OBC parties, regional parties and religion-based politics. The challenge is that no single party now accommodates all interests; many parties compete, no party won a clear majority in any Lok Sabha election from 1989 to 2014, and governments have depended on coalitions. The test is to build a party system, or parties, that can articulate and aggregate (bring together) varied interests.
(b) The chapter says that in many parts of India Dalit politics and OBC politics have developed independently and often in competition with each other, instead of coming together. Another example is the Mandal issue: the 1990 decision on OBC reservations led to violent anti-Mandal protests. A third is the Shah Bano case, where the 1986 Act was opposed by women's organisations and many Muslim groups, while the BJP called it appeasement; the interests of different groups were not reconciled.
(c) India is a society of many castes, religions, regions and classes. If the parties do not accommodate these interests, groups will feel left out and conflicts, protests and violence may follow, as with Mandal and Ayodhya. When parties articulate the interests of different groups and aggregate them into common policies, governments become stable, decisions have wider support and everyone gets a share of power. This is also how conflicts are settled by democratic means, which keeps democracy inclusive.
Talk to your parents about their memories of the events happening since the 1990s. Ask them what they felt were the most significant events of the period. Sit together in groups and draw a comprehensive list of the events reported by your parents, see which events get cited most, and compare them with what the chapter suggests were the most significant. You can also discuss why some events are more important for some and not for others. (Let's re-search)
Solution
Guidance and sample answer. Make a list of the events your parents mention and count how often each is cited. Events often named are the economic reforms of 1991, the Mandal protests, the Ayodhya dispute and its 2019 verdict, the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi, and changes of government. Compare with the chapter, which treats as most significant: the defeat of the Congress in 1989, the Mandal issue, the new economic policy, the Ram Janmabhoomi movement and the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi.
Events matter differently to different people because of age, region, occupation and caste or community. For example, those affected by prices and jobs may stress economic reforms, while others stress reservations or religious issues.
Now let us try to understand the meaning of the information given in the figure (seats and vote share of BJP and Congress). You will notice that BJP and Congress were engaged in a tough competition in this period. What is the difference between their electoral fortunes if you compare these with the 1984 elections?
Solution
In 1984 the Congress was far ahead: it won 415 seats and 48.1 per cent of the votes, while the BJP won 2 seats and 7.4 per cent. Afterwards the two parties' fortunes moved in opposite directions.
Year
Congress seats / vote %
BJP seats / vote %
1984
415 / 48.1
2 / 7.4
1989
197 / 39.5
85 / 11.4
1991
232 / 36.4
120 / 20.1
1996
140 / 28.8
160 / 20.3
2014
44 / 19.5
282 / 31.3
2019
52 / 19.5
303 / 37.4
Thus the Congress fell from a huge majority to a low position, while the BJP rose from a marginal party to the largest party, and the two were in close competition in the years in between (for example 1996, 1998 and 2004).
The Congress fell from 415 seats (1984) to 52 (2019); the BJP rose from 2 seats to 303.
Look at both the charts showing Congress and Janata ‘family’ of parties. Which among the parties that exist today are neither part of Congress family of parties nor part of Janata family of parties?
Solution
Sample answer. The charts of the ‘families’ are not printed in this edition of the chapter, so this answer uses the parties named in it and, for their origins, general knowledge. Parties from the Congress side include the Nationalist Congress Party; those from the Janata side include the Janata Dal (United), Janata Dal (Secular), Rashtriya Janata Dal, Samajwadi Party, Biju Janata Dal and Lok Jan Shakti Party. Parties named in the chapter that belong to neither family include the Communist parties (CPI and CPI-M), the BSP (formed by Kanshi Ram), the Shiv Sena, the Shiromani Akali Dal, the DMK and the AIADMK. The BJP, which grew out of the Jana Sangh, is also usually counted separately, although the Jana Sangh had merged into the Janata Party in 1977.
The political competition during the nineties is divided between the coalition led by BJP and the coalition led by the Congress. Can you list the parties that are not part of any of these two coalitions?
Solution
Sample answer. Parties outside both coalitions in the nineties included the Left Front parties (CPI and CPI-M), which supported the National Front in 1989 and the United Front in 1996 but did not join the government, and some regional and Dalit based parties such as the BSP. The list changed from one election to another, since alliances were flexible; you can check it against the 'Others' group in the seat tables.
OK, coalitions are the logic of democratic politics in our kind of society. Does that mean that we will always have coalitions? Or can the national parties consolidate their positions again?
Solution
Sample answer. The chapter explains that coalitions came from long-term changes: the Congress, once a coalition itself, was left by many sections who formed their own parties, and regional, Dalit and OBC parties grew. So coalitions are rooted in India's diversity. At the same time the BJP won a clear majority on its own in 2014 (282 seats) and 2019 (303), so a single party can win a majority again. Even then the chapter says the recognition of coalition politics is still relevant, since the BJP chose to form the NDA government with its partners. Hence both are possible, but coalition politics is unlikely to disappear.
I am not worried about whether it is a single party or coalition government. I am more worried about what they do. Does a coalition government involve more compromises? Can we not have bold and imaginative policies in a coalition?
Solution
Sample answer. Yes, a coalition involves more compromises because partners with different views must share power. The chapter says coalition politics has shifted the focus from ideological differences to power-sharing and that parties came together without ideological agreement. Even so, bold policies are possible in a coalition: the new economic policy was continued by the various governments that came to power after 1991, and the NDA government of 1999 completed its full term. What matters is whether partners agree on the main policy goals and the quality of what the government does.
Will this benefit leaders of all the backward and Dalit communities? Or will the gains be monopolised by some powerful castes and families within these groups? The real point is not the leaders but the people! Will this lead to better policies and effective implementation for the really deprived people? Or will it remain just a political game?
Solution
Sample answer. The chapter says that OBC reservation, now supported by all major parties, and the rise of the BSP and similar parties have given Dalits and OBCs political voice, and that these parties claimed adequate representation and a share of power for these large groups. It also notes that Dalit politics and OBC politics often developed independently and in competition. Whether the gains reach the really deprived cannot be answered from the chapter alone: benefits will reach them only if reservations and policies are properly implemented, if the poorer sections within each group are included and if voters hold leaders accountable. The people, and not only their leaders, must be the real beneficiaries.
Discuss amongst yourselves the factors that have enabled democracy to thrive in India.
Solution
Sample answer. Points that can be drawn from the chapter: (1) conflicts are usually settled by the due process of law and democratic procedures, as with the 5-0 Supreme Court verdict on Ayodhya (9 November 2019); (2) the Constitution's commitment to equality before the law and to equal treatment of all faiths; (3) a flexible party system in which regional, Dalit and OBC groups find representation and share power; (4) a broad consensus on key issues despite fierce competition; (5) popular movements and organisations that put issues of poverty, livelihood, justice and democracy on the political agenda; (6) the willingness of political actors to accommodate each other, as seen in coalitions.
Compare and contrast the electoral performances of various political parties since 2004. The table given below can be used for this. (Party Positions in Indian Parliament since 2004; Total seats 543.)
Solution
From the table of seats won in 2004, 2009, 2014 and 2019:
Party
2004
2009
2014
2019
BJP
138
116
282
303
INC
145
206
44
52
CPI-M
43
16
9
3
BSP
19
21
-
10
SP
36
23
5
5
DMK
16
18
-
24
AIADMK
0
9
37
1
BJP: fell after 2004 (138 to 116 in 2009), then jumped to 282 in 2014 and 303 in 2019, its own majority both times.
Congress: rose from 145 to 206 (2004 to 2009), then fell sharply to 44 (2014) and 52 (2019).
Left parties: the CPI-M fell steadily from 43 seats in 2004 to 3 in 2019.
Regional parties: their results vary by year: the AIADMK won 37 seats in 2014 but 1 in 2019; the DMK has a dash (no seats) in 2014 but won 24 in 2019; the BSP has a dash in 2014 and won 10 in 2019; the Samajwadi Party fell from 36 to 5.
Overall, the BJP and the Congress won the largest numbers of seats; in 2004 and 2009 the Congress led the winning alliance, while in 2014 and 2019 the BJP won a clear majority alone and all remaining parties taken together as ‘Others’ won 98 and 82 seats.
Prepare a timeline of the major political events in India since 2004. Share and discuss it in your classroom.
Solution
Timeline from the chapter:
2004: Lok Sabha elections; NDA defeated; Congress-led UPA formed the government with Left support; Manmohan Singh Prime Minister; Congress had 145 seats.
July 2008: the Left parties withdrew support to the UPA over the Indo-US nuclear deal; the government completed its term.
2009: 15th Lok Sabha elections; Congress won 206 seats; Manmohan Singh sworn in for a second term heading the UPA.
September 2013: BJP declared Narendra Modi as its Prime Ministerial candidate.
2014: 16th Lok Sabha elections; BJP won 282 seats, the first single-party majority in 30 years; NDA government formed.
2019: BJP won 303 seats in the 17th Lok Sabha elections.
9 November 2019: constitutional bench of the Supreme Court gave its 5-0 verdict on the Ayodhya issue.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 12 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 12 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Contemporary World Politics (7 chapters) and Politics in India since Independence (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercise questions solved
Every question on each chapter from the 16 CBSE board papers of 2024, 2025 and 2026 fully answered, including passage, cartoon and map questions