Politics of Planned Development Class 12 Question Answer | NCERT Political Science Chapter 3 Solutions Skip to content
Smart Notes for Every Exam · instant PDF download after payment +91 92520 37565
NCERT Solutions · Class 12 Political Science · NCERT Contemporary World Politics and Politics in India since Independence Politics in India since Independence · Chapter 3

Chapter 3: Politics of Planned Development (Planned Development Politics)

NCERT solutions for Class 12 Political Science Politics in India since Independence Chapter 3: Politics of Planned Development (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on the Bombay Plan, the First and Second Five Year Plans and the debate on development, plus the in-text questions. All 11 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.

NCERT textbook Chapter 3 (PDF)

Exam revision? Chapter 3 notes with key points, diagrams and practice questions: see the free sample · ₹199 for all 15 chapters
Board exam? CBSE previous year questions from this chapter, with solutions

Free NCERT solutions by Notes Bazar · www.notesbazar.in/ncert-solutions/class-12-polsci/politics-of-planned-development

Exercises

1
Which of these statements about the Bombay Plan is incorrect?
  1. It was a blueprint for India's economic future.
  2. It supported state-ownership of industry.
  3. It was made by some leading industrialists.
  4. It supported strongly the idea of planning.
Solution

(b) It supported state-ownership of industry is the incorrect statement.

The Bombay Plan was drafted in 1944 by a section of the big industrialists as a joint proposal for a planned economy. It wanted the state to take major initiatives in industrial and other economic investments. The chapter nowhere says that it supported state ownership of industry, so statement (b) is the one that the chapter does not support and is taken as incorrect. Statements (a), (c) and (d) are correct: it was a blueprint for the economy, made by leading industrialists, and it strongly supported planning.

(b) It supported state-ownership of industry

2
Which of the following ideas did not form part of the early phase of India's development policy?
  1. Planning
  2. Liberalisation
  3. Cooperative Farming
  4. Self sufficiency
Solution

(b) Liberalisation. The early phase (the 1950s and 1960s) rested on planning, with a central role for the government, a strong public sector, protection of domestic industry by import tariffs, and, through those tariffs, self-sufficiency. Cooperative farming, too, belonged to the state-led approach of the time. Liberalisation, the opening up of the economy to the market, belongs to the later period, when this development strategy was given up.

(b) Liberalisation

3
The idea of planning in India was drawn from
  1. the Bombay plan
  2. experiences of the Soviet bloc countries
  3. Gandhian vision of society
  4. Demand by peasant organisations
  1. b and d only
  2. d and c only
  3. a and b only
  4. all the above
Solution

(iii) a and b only. The chapter traces the planning idea to the Bombay Plan of 1944, drafted by industrialists, and to the experience of the Soviet Union in the 1930s and 1940s (Five Year Plans), along with the Great Depression and the post-war reconstruction of Japan and Germany. The chapter does not mention the Gandhian vision or demands of peasant organisations as a source of the idea of planning.

(iii) a and b only

4
Match the following.
(a) Charan Singhi. Industrialisation
(b) P C Mahalanobisii. Zoning
(c) Bihar Famineiii. Farmers
(d) Verghese Kurieniv. Milk Cooperatives
Solution
ItemMatchNote
(a) Charan Singhiii. FarmersA leader who stood for the farmers' cause (outside this edition's text).
(b) P C Mahalanobisi. IndustrialisationArchitect of the Second Plan, supporter of rapid industrialisation and an active public sector (as in the chapter).
(c) Bihar Famineii. ZoningThe food crisis of the mid-1960s is linked with the zonal system, which restricted the movement of food grains between zones of the country (outside this edition's text; the only pairing that fits).
(d) Verghese Kurieniv. Milk CooperativesLeader of the milk cooperative movement (outside this edition's text).

(a)-iii, (b)-i, (c)-ii, (d)-iv

5
What were the major differences in the approach towards development at the time of Independence? Has the debate been resolved?
Solution

At Independence almost everyone agreed that development meant both economic growth and social and economic justice, and that the government must play a key role. The differences were over the kind of path and role:

  • Models: the liberal-capitalist model of Europe and the US versus the socialist model of the USSR. Many leaders (the CPI, the Socialist Party, Nehru in the Congress) were impressed by the Soviet model, and there were very few supporters of American-style capitalist development.
  • Priorities: for some, industrialisation was the preferred path; for others, agriculture and the alleviation of rural poverty came first.
  • Role of the state: whether a centralised institution should plan for the whole country, whether the government should itself run key industries and businesses, and how much weight justice should get if it differed from the needs of growth.
  • Meaning of development: it meant different things to an industrialist, an urban consumer and an Adivasi, as the Orissa steel plant case showed.

The debate has not been resolved. The chapter says these questions involved contestation "which has continued ever since" and that any discussion on development generates conflicts and debates; the Orissa case shows it is still alive.

6
What was the major thrust of the First Five Year Plan? In which ways did the Second Plan differ from the first one?
Solution

First Plan (1951-56): its thrust was to get the economy out of the cycle of poverty. It addressed mainly the agrarian sector, including investment in dams and irrigation (large allocations for projects like the Bhakra Nangal Dam), because agriculture was hit hardest by Partition. It identified the pattern of land distribution as the main obstacle to agricultural growth and treated land reforms as the key. It also tried to raise savings. K.N. Raj argued that India should "hasten slowly".

Second Plan (1956): drafted by a team under P.C. Mahalanobis, it differed in the following ways:

  • It stressed heavy industries instead of agriculture, aiming at rapid structural transformation by changes in all directions simultaneously (the first plan "preached patience").
  • It followed the Avadi resolution of the Congress, which declared a "socialist pattern of society" as its goal.
  • It imposed heavy tariffs on imports to protect domestic industries, and electricity, railways, steel, machinery and communication were developed mainly in the public sector.
  • Its problems: technological backwardness meant spending precious foreign exchange, and with more investment in industry than in agriculture, the possibility of food shortage loomed large.
7
Read the following passage and answer the questions below:
"In the early years of Independence, two contradictory tendencies were already well advanced inside the Congress party. On the one hand, the national party executive endorsed socialist principles of state ownership, regulation and control over key sectors of the economy in order to improve productivity and at the same time curb economic concentration. On the other hand, the national Congress government pursued liberal economic policies and incentives to private investment that was justified in terms of the sole criterion of achieving maximum increase in production." -- Francine Frankel
(a) What is the contradiction that the author is talking about? What would be the political implications of a contradiction like this?
(b) If the author is correct, why is it that the Congress was pursuing this policy? Was it related to the nature of the opposition parties?
(c) Was there also a contradiction between the central leadership of the Congress party and its State level leaders?
Solution

(a) The contradiction is between the party and its government. The national party executive endorsed socialist principles (state ownership, regulation and control of key sectors to raise productivity and curb concentration of wealth), but the Congress government followed liberal economic policies and gave incentives to private investment, justified only by the aim of maximum production. Implications (sample): the Congress could claim to be socialist while backing private business, so both the left and the right could find something in it; this made it difficult for the opposition to present a clear alternative, but it could also create disappointment among those who expected socialist measures.

(b) The Congress followed this mixed policy because it was a broad "rainbow-like" coalition of classes, castes and ideologies; it avoided extreme positions and took up what the different groups, including the opposition, wanted in its own programme. Business groups also supported planning (the Bombay Plan), and the Second Plan protected both public and private industry. The opposition parties were small and divided, kept at the margins and trying only to influence the Congress from outside, so they could not force a choice. Hence the nature of the opposition did help the Congress to follow both tendencies.

(c) Sample answer: the chapter itself does not discuss this directly. The Congress was made up of many factions, especially in the state units, whose members had their own local interests and ambitions. The Centre announced policies (for example, the First Plan's stress on land reforms), but carrying them out lay with the state governments, where local factions and interests mattered. So differences of emphasis between the central leadership and the state leaders are likely, although the party managed to contain them.

In-text questions

1
Can you identify the various interests involved in this case? What are their key points of conflict? Do you think there are any common points on which everyone can agree? Can this issue be resolved in a way which satisfies all the various interests? What kind of development does Orissa need? Indeed, whose need can be called Orissa's need?
Solution

Interests: (1) the State government, which wants capital investment and jobs by using the iron ore; (2) steel makers (international and domestic) who want to invest, such as the Korean company POSCO; (3) the tribal people of the underdeveloped districts, who fear displacement from their homes and livelihood; (4) environmentalists, who fear that mining and industry will pollute the environment; (5) the Central government, which feels that stopping the industry would set a bad example and discourage investment.

Conflict: investment, jobs and growth versus livelihood, land and the environment; the present against future generations.

Common ground (sample): everyone wants Orissa to be better off, and no one wants the people to be left poorer or the environment ruined.

Resolution: it is difficult to satisfy all interests, since the questions cannot be answered by an expert alone. The chapter says that advice from experts is important but the final decision must be a political decision, taken or at least approved by the people's representatives in touch with the people. Orissa's "need" is therefore what is decided after weighing the interests of one group against another and present against future generations (sample view: development that gives fair compensation and a say to the local people, along with protection of the environment).

2
Can you tell which of the parties in the 1960s were Rightist and which were the Left parties? Where would you place the Congress party of that time?
Solution

The chapter defines the Left as those in favour of state control of the economy and state regulation over free competition, and the Right as those who believe free competition and the market economy alone ensure progress. On this basis (sample answer): the Communist Party of India and the socialist parties, which criticised the Congress for favouring capitalists and landlords, were Left parties. Parties that wanted a free economy without state control, such as the Swatantra Party (which is not described in this edition), were on the Right. The Congress was in the centre: in 1955 it declared a "socialist pattern of society" as its goal and relied on planning and the public sector, but it also protected and encouraged private industry.

3
Are you saying we don't have to be western in order to be modern? Is that possible?
Solution

Yes, it is possible. The chapter notes that in the first decades "development" was commonly seen as becoming more like the industrialised West, with its breakdown of traditional structures and rise of capitalism and liberalism. But India chose its own path: a mixed approach with planning, a large public sector and the aim of justice along with growth, and its leaders did not simply copy either the US or the USSR. Modern here means growth, material progress and scientific rationality, which can be pursued in different ways. (The chapter itself raises this as a question and leaves the discussion open.)

4
Niti Aayog: The Government of India replaced the Planning Commission with a new institution named NITI Aayog (National Institution for Transforming India). This came into existence on 1 January 2015. Find out about its objectives and composition from the website, http://niti.gov.in
Solution

This is a research activity. From the chapter: NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission and came into existence on 1 January 2015. The Planning Commission was set up in March 1950 by a simple resolution of the Government of India (not by the Constitution), had only an advisory role, and the Prime Minister was its Chairperson. For the objectives and composition of NITI Aayog, read the "About us" pages of the website given in the question and note down its chairperson, vice-chairperson, members and aims.

Cover of Complete Political Science Notes for Class 12 (CBSE 2026-27)
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 12 Political Science notes
  • For CBSE Class 12 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Contemporary World Politics (7 chapters) and Politics in India since Independence (8 chapters)
  • All NCERT exercise questions solved
  • Every question on each chapter from the 16 CBSE board papers of 2024, 2025 and 2026 fully answered, including passage, cartoon and map questions
₹199₹24920% off · all 15 chapters · instant PDF
Read free sample

What is inside the Chapter 3 notes →

Board questions from this chapter (CBSE previous years), with solutions →

Board exam? Add the Class 12 Political Science PYQ book · ₹99

Found a mistake or need help with a question? Message us on WhatsApp. Free study tips and new solutions: join our WhatsApp Channel.

Prices shown in Indian rupees. Show prices in: ₹ INR · US$ USD