NCERT Solutions · Class 12 History · NCERT Themes in Indian History, Parts I, II and III Themes in Indian History Part III · Chapter 4
Chapter 4: Framing the Constitution: The Beginning of a New Era (Framing the Constitution)
NCERT solutions for Class 12 History Themes in Indian History Part III Chapter 4: Framing the Constitution: The Beginning of a New Era (2026-27). Answers to the 100-150 word and short essay questions, map work, project and in-text questions. All 21 questions are answered in full.
What were the ideals expressed in the Objectives Resolution?
Solution
Jawaharlal Nehru moved the Objectives Resolution in the Constituent Assembly on 13 December 1946. It outlined the defining ideals of the Constitution and the framework for the work of constitution-making.
It proclaimed India an "Independent Sovereign Republic".
It guaranteed citizens justice, equality and freedom.
It assured that "adequate safeguards shall be provided for minorities, backward and tribal areas, and Depressed and Other Backward Classes".
In his speech Nehru said the resolution gave the content of democracy and also of economic democracy, and that he stood for socialism. He did not define the form of democracy, saying the system must "fit in with the temper of our people and be acceptable to them", and that India was "not going just to copy" other countries. He wanted to learn from the success and failure of earlier revolutions, such as the American, French and Russian, and to fuse liberal democracy with the socialist idea of economic justice.
How was the term minority defined by different groups?
Solution
The term was understood in different ways, as the debates showed.
Religious minorities. B. Pocker Bahadur argued that Muslims were a minority who could not be wished away, and needed separate electorates to have a real voice. Religious minorities also asked for special safeguards, and linguistic minorities wanted their mother tongue protected.
The poor as minorities. N.G. Ranga said that the real minorities were the masses: the tribals losing land to merchants, villagers in the grip of moneylenders and landlords, who were too oppressed to use ordinary civil rights.
Tribals. Jaipal Singh said tribals were not a numerical minority but needed protection, since they had been dispossessed of land and forests and kept apart.
Depressed Castes. J. Nagappa said they were between 20 and 25 per cent of the population, so their problem was not numerical but marginalisation, and Dakshayani Velayudhan refused to consider seventy million Harijans a minority, wanting removal of social disabilities.
What were the arguments in favour of greater power to the provinces?
Solution
The rights of the states were defended most eloquently by K. Santhanam from Madras and several others.
Santhanam argued that adding powers to the Centre did not make it strong: an overburdened Centre could not function effectively, and transferring some functions to the states would strengthen both.
He said the proposed allocation would cripple the states, because the fiscal provisions made the Centre the preserve of most taxes except land revenue. Without finances the states could not develop, educate people or build roads, and would have to beg the Centre for a dole. In a few years all the provinces would "revolt against the Centre".
Others wanted fewer items in the Concurrent and Union lists, and a member from Orissa warned that the "Centre is likely to break".
Sir A. Ramaswamy Mudaliar said one is not a better patriot for proposing a strong Centre, and that those who want a more vigorous examination of its resources do not lack patriotism.
Why did Mahatma Gandhi think Hindustani should be the national language?
Solution
By the 1930s the Congress had accepted Hindustani as the national language. Gandhiji felt that everyone should speak in a language that common people could easily understand. Hindustani, a blend of Hindi and Urdu, was the popular language of a large section of the people of India. It was a composite language enriched by the interaction of diverse cultures, which had taken words from many sources and was therefore understood by people of various regions.
Gandhiji thought this multi-cultural language would be the ideal language of communication between diverse communities, able to unify Hindus and Muslims and the people of the north and the south. He wanted it to be neither Sanskritised Hindi nor Persianised Urdu but a happy combination of both. To confine oneself to Hindi or Urdu would be "a crime against intelligence and the spirit of patriotism".
What historical forces shaped the vision of the Constitution?
Solution
The Constitution was framed between December 1946 and November 1949, and its vision was shaped by several historical forces.
The national movement. The Constituent Assembly was expected to express the aspirations of those who took part in the freedom struggle. Democracy, equality and justice had become associated with social struggles since the nineteenth century: reformers who opposed child marriage and supported widow remarriage, Vivekananda, Jyotiba Phule, and Communists and Socialists organising workers and peasants. The national movement was inevitably a struggle for democracy, rights and equality.
Earlier constitutional reforms. The Acts of 1909, 1919 and 1935 gradually enlarged Indian participation in provincial governments, and Congress came to power in eight of 11 provinces in 1937. But these were enacted by the colonial government with a limited electorate and no universal franchise, so there was no unbroken continuity.
Events of the time. The Quit India struggle, Bose's armed struggle, the naval rising of 1946, and the Hindu-Muslim unity in these were fresh in memory. But the Calcutta Killings, riots and Partition, with millions of refugees, made the makers fear violence and favour a strong Centre and oppose separate electorates. The princely states, too, posed a problem.
World history. Nehru recalled the American, French and Russian revolutions, to learn from their successes and failures, but said India would not just copy.
Public opinion. Debates were reported in the press, and the public sent in views, so linguistic and religious minorities and dalits raised issues of cultural rights and social justice.
Thus the Constitution came from a mix of nationalist ideals, the experience of colonial rule and the trauma of Partition.
Discuss the different arguments made in favour of protection of the oppressed groups.
Solution
In the Constituent Assembly different members made different arguments for protecting oppressed groups.
Economic protection. N.G. Ranga said the real minorities were the poor masses, who could not use legal rights unless conditions were created for them. "They need props. They need a ladder." Tribals lost land to merchants and became bond-slaves, and villagers were exploited by moneylenders and landlords.
Tribals. Jaipal Singh said the history of his people was one of continuous exploitation and dispossession, and that they had been neglected for 6,000 years. They needed protection, though they were not a numerical minority, and reservation of seats would compel others to hear their voice. He asked for breaking of the emotional and physical distance between tribals and the rest of society.
Depressed Castes. J. Nagappa said they had suffered but would suffer no more. They were 20 to 25 per cent of the population but had no education or share in administration. K.J. Khanderkar spoke of suppression for thousands of years. Dakshayani Velayudhan wanted moral safeguards and removal of social disabilities, not just safeguards. The problem came from social norms and caste values, so protection alone could not solve it.
Women. Hansa Mehta asked not for reserved seats, but for social, economic and political justice and equality.
The Assembly finally recommended abolition of untouchability, opening Hindu temples to all castes, and reservation of seats in legislatures and jobs in government for the lowest castes. Many recognised that social discrimination could not be erased by law alone, and that attitudes in society had to change.
What connection did some of the members of the Constituent Assembly make between the political situation of the time and the need for a strong Centre?
Solution
The Constituent Assembly met against the background of Partition, riots and violence. Many members therefore argued for a strong Centre.
Ambedkar said he wanted "a strong and united Centre much stronger than the Centre we had created under the Government of India Act of 1935".
Reminding the members of the riots and violence ripping the nation apart, many repeated that the powers of the Centre had to be greatly strengthened to stop the communal frenzy.
Gopalaswami Ayyangar said the Centre should be made "as strong as possible". Balakrishna Sharma argued that only a strong centre could plan for the well-being of the country, mobilise economic resources, set up a proper administration and defend the country against foreign aggression.
Nehru wrote that now that partition was a settled fact, a weak central authority would be injurious, since it could not ensure peace, coordinate vital matters or speak effectively for the country abroad.
Before Partition the Congress had agreed to considerable autonomy for the provinces, to assure the Muslim League that the Centre would not interfere where it came to power. After Partition that pressure was gone. A unitary system had been imposed by the colonial government, and the violence gave a push to centralisation, seen as necessary to prevent chaos and to plan economic development. The Constitution thus showed a bias towards the Union: it gave the Union more subjects in the Union and Concurrent lists than in other federations, control of minerals and key industries, and Article 356.
How did the Constituent Assembly seek to resolve the language controversy?
Solution
The language issue was debated over many months and caused intense arguments. Gandhiji and the Congress favoured Hindustani, but Hindi and Urdu had been drifting apart. R.V. Dhulekar argued aggressively for Hindi in the Assembly, and later wanted it declared the national language, which angered many members.
The Language Committee prepared a compromise formula. Hindi in the Devanagari script would be the official language, not the national language, with a gradual transition. For the first fifteen years English would continue to be used for all official purposes. Each province could choose one of its regional languages for official work within the province. By calling Hindi the official language and not the national one, the Committee hoped to placate ruffled emotions and arrive at a solution acceptable to all.
Members from the non-Hindi areas voiced the fear of domination. Durgabai, who had carried on Hindi propaganda in the south on Gandhiji's call, said the opposition in the south was strong and that the change of Hindustani by removing Urdu and regional words created anxiety. Shankarrao Deo and T.A. Ramalingam Chettiar urged caution and mutual adjustment, with no forcing of things on people. The President told Dhulekar that he was not advancing his case by speaking like that, and many members appealed for a spirit of accommodation. The provisions were thus arrived at by give-and-take, forging a middle ground between opposed positions. In this way the Assembly tried to protect both the unity of the nation and the confidence of the regional language groups, instead of imposing one language on all.
On a present-day political map of India, indicate the different languages spoken in each state and mark out the one that is designated as the language for official communication. Compare the present map with a map of the early 1950s. What differences do you notice? Do the differences say something about the relationship between language and the organisation of the states?
Solution
Guidance: Mark each state with its main language, using colours, and show Hindi in Devanagari as the official language of the Union, with English continuing, and the regional language of each state for state work (the Language Committee's formula). Compare with an atlas map of the early 1950s. The differences will show that several states were reorganised later along linguistic lines, so language became a basis for organising states. Note the changes, and write a short paragraph on this link.
Choose any one important constitutional change that has happened in recent years. Find out why the change was made, what different arguments were put forward for the change, and the historical background to the change. If you can, try and look at the Constitutional Assembly Debates to see how the issue was discussed at that time. Write about your findings.
Solution
Guidance: Choose an amendment, for example one on rights, reservations, Centre-state relations or panchayats. Note the reason for the change, the arguments for and against in Parliament and the press, and its historical background. Then read what the Constituent Assembly debates said on the same subject, such as separate electorates, safeguards for the oppressed, powers of the Centre and the states or language, and compare. Write a short report.
Compare the Constitution of America, France or South Africa with the Indian Constitution, focusing on any two of the following themes: secularism, minority rights, relations between the Centre and the states. Find out how these differences and similarities are linked to the histories of the regions.
Solution
Guidance: Choose one country and two themes. For India, use the chapter: secularism through Articles 25-28, 29, 30 and 14, 16, 17 with a "judicious distance" between State and religion; minority rights and the rejection of separate electorates; and a Union-biased federation with Union, State and Concurrent lists, Article 356 and fiscal federalism. Compare these with the other constitution, and link the differences to history, such as colonial rule and Partition in India and the revolutions and settlement in the other country.
Look again at Chapter 11. Discuss how the political situation of the time may have shaped the nature of the debates within the Constituent Assembly.
Solution
Chapter 11 shows that the Constituent Assembly met during the rise of communal tension, the Cabinet Mission failure, Direct Action Day (16 August 1946), riots, and Partition. The League boycotted the Assembly, the Congress dominated it, and members feared more violence. This explains why many opposed separate electorates and demanded a strong Centre and a unified nation, why language was debated so anxiously, and why the rights of minorities and the oppressed were discussed so passionately.
What explanation does Jawaharlal Nehru give for not using the term "democratic" in the Objectives Resolution in Source 1?
Solution
Nehru said it was conceivable that a republic may not be democratic, but the whole of our past is witness that India stood for democratic institutions, so the word "republic" already contained the idea. They did not want unnecessary or redundant words, and had done more than use the word: the Resolution gave the content of democracy, including economic democracy.
Why does the speaker in Source 2 think that the Constituent Assembly was under the shadow of British guns?
Solution
Somnath Lahiri said the British plan made any future Constitution dependent on a treaty satisfactory to the British, and for every difference one would have to run to the Federal Court or the British Prime Minister. He said that the Assembly was under the shadow of British guns, the British Army and their economic and financial stranglehold, the final power was still in British hands and Attlee could threaten division. So he thought there was no freedom, and suggested declaring independence there and then.
What were the ideas outlined by Jawaharlal Nehru in his speech on the Objectives Resolution?
Solution
Nehru outlined these ideas: the placing of India in the history of struggle for liberty, recalling the American, French and Russian revolutions; the resolve to have an independent sovereign republic; commitment to democracy, including economic democracy, though its form was to be decided by the House; not merely copying other democracies but improving on them, fitting the temper of the people; learning from others' successes and avoiding failures; and his own belief in socialism and hope that India would move towards a socialist state. He also stressed that the Assembly derived its strength from the will of the people.
Read Sources 3 and 4. What are the different arguments being put forward against separate electorates?
Solution
Patel said separate electorates were a "poison", a legacy of the British that had turned one community against another and led to Partition. He challenged the House to show him one free country that had separate electorates, and urged members to forget the past because the British had left the mischief behind. Pant said they would be "suicidal to the minorities": the minorities would be isolated for ever and could never become a majority, would be frustrated and have no effective voice, and be kept in an air-tight compartment relying on others. Dhulekar said the British had used them under the cover of safeguards to mislead the minorities. Another argument was that they would prevent national unity and divide loyalties.
How does G. B. Pant define the attributes of a loyal citizen?
Solution
Pant said that a loyal citizen practises self-discipline and cares less for himself and more for others in a democracy. There cannot be divided loyalty: all loyalties must be centred round the State, and a citizen should not create rival loyalties or care nothing for larger interests. He added that people must think in terms of citizens and not communities, because the citizen is the base and summit of the social pyramid.
Ranga said the real minorities were not the Hindus in the Pakistan provinces, nor the Sikhs or even the Muslims, but the masses of the country: the depressed, oppressed and suppressed people who cannot take advantage of ordinary civil rights, such as tribals losing land to merchants and villagers exploited by moneylenders, landlords and zamindars, with no elementary education. So he defined minority in economic terms.
What were the different arguments that Jaipal Singh put forward in demanding protective measures for the tribals?
Solution
Jaipal Singh said the tribals had been shabbily and disgracefully treated and neglected for 6,000 years, and their history was one of continuous exploitation and dispossession by non-aboriginals, punctuated by rebellions. They had been dispossessed of land and forests and forced to move, and others perceived them as primitive and backward and spurned them. They were not a numerical minority but needed protection to come up to the general level. He asked for reservation of seats in the legislature to let them represent themselves and compel others to hear them, though not separate electorates, and he pleaded that the emotional and physical distance between tribals and the rest of society be broken. He took Nehru at his word of a new chapter with equality of opportunity.
What different arguments were put forward by those advocating a strong Centre?
Solution
Ambedkar wanted a strong and united Centre, stronger than under the 1935 Act. Members cited the riots and violence and said the Centre needed power to stop communal frenzy. Gopalaswami Ayyangar said it should be as strong as possible. Balakrishna Sharma said only a strong centre could plan for the well-being of the country, mobilise economic resources, set up a proper administration and defend against foreign aggression. Nehru said a weak central authority would be injurious after partition. After Partition the pressures for decentralisation were gone, and a strong Centre was seen as necessary to forestall chaos and to plan economic development.
What should the qualities of a national language be?
Solution
Gandhiji, in Source 10, said that the national language, Hindustani, should be neither Sanskritised Hindi nor Persianised Urdu but a happy combination of both. It should freely admit words wherever necessary from the different regional languages and also assimilate words from foreign languages, provided that they mix well and easily with the national language. In this way it should develop into a rich and powerful instrument capable of expressing the whole gamut of human thought and feelings. To confine oneself to Hindi or Urdu alone would be, in his words, "a crime against intelligence and the spirit of patriotism".
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 12 History notes
For CBSE Class 12 History (027), 2026-27: all 12 themes of Themes in Indian History Parts I, II and III
All NCERT exercise questions solved, including the essay questions and map work
Every question on each theme from the 16 CBSE board papers of 2024, 2025 and 2026 fully answered, including source-based and map questions