Introducing Western Sociologists Class 11 Question Answer | NCERT Sociology Chapter 4 Solutions Skip to content
Smart Notes for Every Exam · instant PDF download after payment +91 92520 37565
NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Sociology · NCERT Introducing Sociology and Understanding Society Understanding Society · Chapter 4

Chapter 4: Introducing Western Sociologists (Western Sociologists)

NCERT solutions for Class 11 Sociology Understanding Society Chapter 4: Introducing Western Sociologists (2026-27). Answers to all twelve exercises and the in-text activities on Marx, Durkheim and Weber. All 16 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.

NCERT textbook Chapter 4 (PDF)

Exam revision? Chapter 4 notes with key points, diagrams and practice questions: see the free sample · US$2.99 for all 10 chapters

Free NCERT solutions by Notes Bazar · www.notesbazar.in/ncert-solutions/class-11-sociology/introducing-western-sociologists

Exercises

1
Why is the Enlightenment important for the development of sociology?
Solution

The Enlightenment (late 17th and 18th centuries) was one of the three processes, with the French Revolution and the Industrial Revolution, that paved the way for sociology. Its importance lies in the following ideas given in the chapter:

  1. These new philosophies placed the human being at the centre of the universe, and rational thought as the central feature of the human being. The ability to think rationally and critically made the individual both the producer and the user of all knowledge, the "knowing subject".
  2. Society, being the handiwork of humans, was amenable to rational analysis and thus comprehensible to other humans. This made a scientific study of society possible.
  3. For reason to become the defining feature of the human world, nature, religion and the divine acts of gods had to be displaced from the central position they held in earlier ways of understanding the world. So the Enlightenment was made possible by, and helped to develop, secular, scientific and humanistic attitudes of mind.

The chapter also notes a limitation: only those who could think and reason were considered fully human, so the natives of primitive societies ("savages") were treated as not fully evolved humans.

The Enlightenment put reason and the human being at the centre and made society open to rational, scientific analysis, which sociology needed.

2
How was the Industrial Revolution responsible for giving rise to sociology?
Solution

The Industrial Revolution began in Britain in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. It had two aspects: the systematic application of science and technology to industrial production (new machines such as the Spinning Jenny, new sources of power such as the steam engine), and new ways of organising labour and markets on a larger scale than ever. It gave rise to the factory system and mass manufacture for distant markets across the world.

It changed social life greatly, and these changes gave rise to sociology:

  • Factories in urban areas were manned by workers uprooted from rural areas. Low wages meant men, women and even children worked long hours in hazardous conditions.
  • Cities and towns became the dominant forms of settlement, with large and unequal populations in densely populated areas. The rich lived there, but so did the working classes in slums amidst poverty and squalor.
  • Modern forms of governance, with the state assuming control of health, sanitation, crime control and general "development", created a demand for new kinds of knowledge. The social sciences, particularly sociology, emerged partly as a response to this need.

From the outset sociology was concerned with the scientific analysis of developments in industrial society, so it has been called the "science of the new industrial society". The scientific information generated by the state to monitor the health of its social body became the basis for reflection on society, and sociological theory was the result of this self-reflection.

3
What are the various components of a mode of production?
Solution

For Marx, a mode of production is a broad system of production associated with an epoch or historical period (primitive communism, slavery, feudalism and capitalism). It consists of a base and a superstructure.

  1. The economic base, which is primarily economic and has two parts:
    • Productive forces: all the means or factors of production such as land, labour, technology and sources of energy (electricity, coal, petroleum and so on).
    • Production relations: all the economic relationships and forms of labour organisation involved in production. They are also property relations, based on the ownership or control of the means of production.
  2. The superstructure, erected on the base: social, cultural and political institutions such as religion, art, law, literature and different forms of beliefs and ideas.

Example: in primitive communism the productive forces were mostly nature (forests, land, animals) with rudimentary technology like stone tools and hunting weapons, and the production relations were based on community property and tribal forms of hunting and gathering.

A mode of production = economic base (productive forces + production relations) + superstructure (institutions and ideas built on it).

4
Why do classes come into conflict, according to Marx?
Solution

Marx classified people into groups by their position in the production process. Those who occupy the same position in the production process and property relations form a class and share the same interests. Classes are formed through historical processes shaped by changes in the conditions and forces of production.

  1. As the mode of production changes, conflicts develop between classes, which result in struggles. The Communist Manifesto opens, "The history of all hitherto existing societies is the history of class struggle", between oppressor and oppressed (freeman and slave, patrician and plebeian, lord and serf, guild master and journeyman).
  2. The opposing classes arise from contradictions of the production process. In capitalism the bourgeoisie (capitalists) own all the means of production, while the working class has lost the means of production it once had, and has to sell its labour for wages in order to survive. Their interests are thus opposed.
  3. For conflict to occur, classes must become subjectively conscious of their class interests and identities and of their rivals', which develops through political mobilisation. Then class conflicts occur, and given favourable conditions they culminate in revolution, the overthrow of the ruling class by the dominated classes.
  4. Ideology complicates this: the ruling class promotes a dominant ideology that justifies its domination, for example by making the poor believe they are poor because of fate or deeds in a previous life, though it may be challenged by rival ideologies.

Economic processes thus generate contradictions and class conflict, but social and political processes are also needed for total transformation.

Classes conflict because their positions in production give them opposed interests (owners vs wage workers), and conflict occurs once they become class-conscious.

5
What are social facts? How do we recognise them?
Solution

According to Durkheim, social facts are aspects of social reality related to collective patterns of behaviour and beliefs, which are not created by individuals but exert pressure on them and influence their behaviour. Social facts are like things: they are external to the individual but constrain their behaviour. Institutions like law, education and religion are social facts. They are collective representations that emerge from the association of people; they are not particular to a person but of a general nature, independent of the individual. Beliefs, feelings and collective practices are examples.

How we recognise them. Social facts are abstract, so they cannot be seen directly like a tree or a boy. But they can be observed indirectly through patterns of behaviour. Because social ties exert pressure on individuals to conform, behaviour follows a pattern, and by observing it the norms, codes and solidarities behind it can be identified, so they can be empirically verified. The best example is Durkheim's study of Suicide: each suicide is specific to the individual, but the average rate of suicide aggregated across hundreds of thousands of individuals in a community is a social fact. Moral codes, which are rules of action with distinctive characteristics, can also be observed, described and classified.

Social facts are collective ways of acting, thinking and feeling that are external to individuals and constrain them; they are recognised through patterns of behaviour, such as suicide rates.

6
What is the difference between `mechanical' and `organic' solidarity?
Solution
Mechanical solidarityOrganic solidarity
SocietyPrimitive societyModern society
BasisSimilarity of its individual membersHeterogeneity of its members and interdependence
PopulationSmall populationsLarge populations; relationships mostly impersonal
GroupsA collection of different self-sufficient groups, each person doing similar activitiesGroups or units are not self-sufficient but depend on others for survival
ToleranceNot tolerant of differences; any violation of norms attracts harsh punishmentCelebrates individuals and allows for their need to be different; recognises multiple roles
LawRepressive: to prevent deviation and enforce collective revengeRestitutive: to repair or correct the wrong done
IndividualTotally submerged in the collectivityGiven some autonomy and many identities

Mechanical solidarity rests on similarity and repressive law; organic solidarity rests on difference and interdependence and restitutive law.

7
Show, with examples, how moral codes are indicators of social solidarity.
Solution

Durkheim held that the social is found in the codes of conduct imposed on individuals by collective agreement. Moral codes are manifestations of particular social conditions, so the morality appropriate to one society is inappropriate for another, and the prevailing social conditions can be deduced from moral codes. Moral facts can be observed, described and classified like other phenomena.

Examples from the chapter:

  • Mechanical solidarity. In primitive societies based on similarity and personal relationships, the individual and community were tightly integrated and any violation of the code was feared to disintegrate the community. So the moral and legal codes were repressive, with harsh punishment and a sort of collective revenge. The harsh punishment for deviation indicates strong solidarity based on sameness.
  • Organic solidarity. In modern societies, based on heterogeneity and interdependence, the law is restitutive: it aims to repair the wrong. Individuals give voluntary consent to goal-oriented groups and associations, and impersonal rules govern relations. The nature of these codes indicates a solidarity founded on difference and interdependence.

Thus by studying the moral codes and laws of a society, we can identify the type of solidarity that binds it.

8
What are the basic features of bureaucracy?
Solution

Weber saw bureaucracy as the form of rational-legal authority of modern times: a mode of organisation based on the separation of the public from the domestic world, with behaviour in the public domain regulated by explicit rules and regulations. It restricts the power of officials and does not give them absolute power. Its features are:

  1. Functioning of officials. Officials have fixed areas of official jurisdiction governed by rules, laws and administrative regulations. Duties are distributed in a fixed way, commands flow from higher authorities to subordinates, and responsibilities are strictly delimited by the authority available. Only those with the requisite qualifications are employed, and positions continue beyond the tenure of any occupant.
  2. Hierarchical ordering of positions. Offices are placed on a graded hierarchy where higher officials supervise lower ones, allowing appeal to a higher official.
  3. Reliance on written documents. Management is carried out on the basis of written files preserved as records, so decisions accumulate; it is part of the public domain, separate from the officials' private life.
  4. Office management. A specialised and modern activity needing trained and skilled personnel.
  5. Conduct in office. Official activity demands full-time attention, and conduct is governed by exhaustive rules that separate public conduct from private behaviour. Since these rules have legal recognition, officials can be held accountable.
9
What is special or different about the kind of objectivity needed in social science?
Solution

Weber argued that the social world is founded on subjective human meanings, values, feelings, prejudices and ideals, so social science must deal with them, unlike the natural sciences, which discover objective laws of nature. The objectivity needed is therefore a special and complex kind:

  1. Sociologists must use "empathetic understanding", putting themselves imaginatively in the place of the people they study (feeling "with", which is empathy, not feeling "for", which is sympathy), to recover the subjective meanings and motivations of actors.
  2. Yet the investigation has to be done objectively even though it is concerned with subjective matters. The sociologist must faithfully record the meanings of actors without letting personal beliefs and opinions influence the process: to describe, not judge. Weber called this "value neutrality".
  3. This is difficult because social scientists are also members of society with their own beliefs and prejudices, so they must practise great self-discipline, an "iron will", to remain value neutral.

Thus social science objectivity means neutrally recording subjective values without being affected by one's own feelings about them.

The objectivity needed is value neutrality combined with empathetic understanding: recording subjective meanings of others without judging them.

10
Can you identify any ideas or theories which have led to the formation of social movements in India in recent times?
Solution

Sample answer. The chapter shows how ideas lead to social movements: the ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity of the French Revolution became the watchwords of the modern state, and Marx's theory of class struggle was a programme of action for the working class. In India, ideas of this kind have inspired movements. Following the chapter's argument (the examples that follow are well-known facts outside the text):

  • Marxist ideas about exploitation and class struggle have inspired trade union and peasant movements in India.
  • Movements for the rights of women, Dalits and Adivasis demand equality before the law and an end to privileges or disadvantages inherited by birth, the same ideal of equality that the chapter links to the French Revolution.

You may add a movement you know of and name the idea behind it.

11
Try to find out what Marx and Weber wrote about India.
Solution

Guidance. This is a research task. The chapter itself lists Weber's work The Religion of India (1958 translation) among his major works; the chapter also says that a major concern of Weber was the process of rationalisation in modern society and the relationship of the various religions of the world with this process. Marx wrote newspaper articles in the 1850s on British rule in India (a well-known fact outside the text). Look these up in the library or from reliable sources and note their main arguments.

12
Can you think of reasons why we should study the work of thinkers who died long ago? What could be some reasons to not study them?
Solution

Sample answer. Reasons to study them: the chapter says Marx, Durkheim and Weber laid the foundation of the subject as part of the classical tradition, and their ideas and insights remain relevant even in the contemporary period. Their concepts such as alienation, social facts, solidarity, authority and bureaucracy are still used to understand present-day society. Ideas about society are themselves influenced by social conditions, so studying the context in which they emerged helps us understand the discipline.

Reasons not to: their ideas have also been subjected to criticism and have undergone major modifications; they wrote about the conditions of their own time, and societies have changed since. The chapter itself notes that Enlightenment thinking treated the natives of "primitive" societies as not fully evolved humans, a view we would now question. So they should be studied critically and not accepted as final.

Activities

1
Revisit the discussion of the coming of the modern age in Europe in Chapter 1 of Introducing Sociology. What sorts of changes were these three processes associated with?
Solution
  • Enlightenment: changes in ways of thinking. Reason and the human being were placed at the centre, society was seen as open to rational analysis, and secular, scientific and humanistic attitudes developed.
  • French Revolution (1789): political changes. Political sovereignty of individuals and nation-states was announced; equality of citizens and privileges by birth were questioned; serfs were freed and feudal and church taxes cancelled; the public realm of the state was separated from the private realm of the household; and the nation-state became a sovereign entity with centralised government. Liberty, equality and fraternity became watchwords of the modern state.
  • Industrial Revolution: economic and social changes. New machines and power sources, the factory system and mass manufacture, a world-wide industry, the growth of cities, slums and a working class, and new state functions in health and sanitation.
2
Although it is also called a `class', does the group formed by you and your classmates form a class in the Marxian sense? What arguments can you give in favour and against this view? Do factory workers and agricultural workers belong to the same class? What about workers and managers working in the same factory -- do they both belong to the same class? Does a rich industrialist or factory owner who lives in the city and owns no agricultural land belong to the same class as a poor agricultural labourer who lives in the village and owns no land? What about a landlord who owns a lot of land and a small peasant who owns a small piece of land -- do they belong to the same class if they live in the same village and are both landowners? Think carefully about the reasons for your responses to these examples. [Suggestion: Try to imagine what interests the people mentioned in these examples may have in common; think of the position they occupy in the larger social system, particularly in relation to the production process.]
Solution

For Marx, a class is formed by people who occupy the same position in the social production process and property relations, and so share the same interests. Religion, language or nationality are not the basis. So the test in each case is the relation to production and property.

  • Classmates. They are not a class in the Marxian sense: they do not occupy a position in the production process and do not differ in relation to ownership of the means of production. In favour: they share common interests as students. Against: this is not a position in production.
  • Factory and agricultural workers. Both are property-less people who sell their labour for wages, so they share a similar location in the production process and can be seen as belonging to the same working class, though they may not yet realise it.
  • Workers and managers. They work in the same factory but occupy different positions: workers sell labour and have no control over the work process, while management decides the content of the working day. Their interests are not identical, so they are not obviously the same class.
  • Industrialist and agricultural labourer. No: the owner holds the means of production and the labourer owns nothing but labour. Living in the city or village is not what matters.
  • Landlord and small peasant. Both own land, but their position in property relations differs sharply, since the landlord has much land and the peasant a small piece, so their interests may differ. They are not clearly in the same class.

The chapter itself leaves these as questions for discussion; the answers above apply its criterion of position in the production process.

3
Try to compare what Durkheim and Marx say about the social division of labour. They both agree that as society evolves, the social organisation of production grows more complex, the division of labour becomes more detailed, and this creates unavoidable interdependencies among different social groups. But where Durkheim emphasises solidarity, Marx emphasises conflict. What do you think about this? Can you think of reasons why Marx may be wrong about modern society? For example, can you think of situations or examples where people are joining together to form groups or collectivities despite being from different class backgrounds and having conflicting interests? What counter arguments could you give to persuade someone that Marx may still have a point? Can you think of reasons why Durkheim may be wrong about modern society giving more freedom to the individual? For example, isn't it true that the spread of mass communication (specially through television) has tended to standardise popular fashion in things like clothes or music? Today, young people in different social groups, different countries, states or regions are now more likely to be listening to the same music, or wearing the same kind of clothes than ever before. Does this make Durkheim wrong? What could be the arguments for and against in this context?
Solution

Sample answer. The chapter says there may be many right answers in sociology, so the aim is to reason carefully.

  • Comparison. Durkheim sees the division of labour as creating organic solidarity, with interdependence binding people together. Marx sees it under capitalism as dividing owners and workers, producing alienation and class conflict.
  • Marx may be wrong: people from different classes may join together, for example in a cricket team, a festival or a neighbourhood or national cause, despite conflicting interests. Marx may still have a point: such unity may not remove the conflict of interest between owners and workers over wages, as the chapter says classes have opposed interests even when they do not act on them, and ideology can hide conflict.
  • Durkheim may be wrong: mass communication standardises fashion and music, so individual choice seems limited, and people across the world copy the same styles. Defence of Durkheim: he spoke of autonomy in roles and in joining different groups voluntarily; people still choose among styles and hold many identities, and sharing a fashion does not mean they have lost the ability to choose or to be different in other spheres.
4
To what extent do you think the following groups or activities involve the exercise of bureacratic authority in Weber's sense? (a) your class; (b) your school; (c) a football team; (d) a panchayat samiti in a village; (e) a fan association for a popular film star; (f) a group of regular commuters on a train or bus route; (g) a joint family; (h) a village community; (i) the crew of a ship; (j) a criminal gang; (k) the followers of a religious leader; and (l) an audience watching a film in a cinema hall. Based on your discussions, which of these groups would you be willing to characterise as `bureaucratic'? Remember, you must discuss reasons both for as well as against, and listen to people who disagree with!
Solution

Weber's bureaucratic authority has fixed jurisdictions governed by rules, a graded hierarchy, written records, trained personnel and conduct governed by rules that separate public from private life. Using these tests (sample answer):

  • (b) School and (d) panchayat samiti: largely bureaucratic. They have written rules, offices, hierarchy and records; the panchayat samiti is a public body with defined powers.
  • (a) Your class: partly. It is part of the school's rules and timetable, but the class itself has no hierarchy of offices.
  • (c) Football team and (i) crew of a ship: partly. They have roles, rules and a command structure, but not written files and a formal office system; the ship's crew has a hierarchy.
  • (e) Fan association, (f) commuters, (l) cinema audience: not bureaucratic. They are informal or temporary groups without jurisdictions, offices or written rules.
  • (g) Joint family and (h) village community: not bureaucratic. Authority rests on custom and tradition, which Weber calls traditional authority, and relations are personal.
  • (j) Criminal gang: not bureaucratic; Chapter 2 of this book (Social Change and Social Order) notes that a gang leader may exercise absolute authority without formal specification.
  • (k) Followers of a religious leader: not bureaucratic. Authority rests on charisma (the "gift of grace"), not on legal demarcation of authority.
Cover of Complete Sociology Notes for Class 11 (CBSE 2026-27)
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Sociology notes
  • For CBSE Class 11 Sociology (039), 2026-27: Introducing Sociology (5 chapters) and Understanding Society (5 chapters)
  • All NCERT exercises solved
  • Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short and long answer) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 10 chapters · instant PDF
Read free sample

What is inside the Chapter 4 notes →

Found a mistake or need help with a question? Message us on WhatsApp. Free study tips and new solutions: join our WhatsApp Channel.

Prices shown in US dollars. Show prices in: ₹ INR · US$ USD