NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Sociology · NCERT Introducing Sociology and Understanding Society Understanding Society · Chapter 5
Chapter 5: Indian Sociologists (Indian Sociologists)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Sociology Understanding Society Chapter 5: Indian Sociologists (2026-27). Answers to all nine exercises and the in-text activities on Ghurye, D.P. Mukerji, A.R. Desai and M.N. Srinivas. All 14 questions are answered in full.
How did Ananthakrishna Iyer and Sarat Chandra Roy come to practice social anthropology?
Solution
Both became anthropologists "by accident", and both were self-taught pioneers who practised a discipline that did not yet exist in India and had no institutions to promote it.
L.K. Ananthakrishna Iyer (1861-1937) began his career as a clerk, became a school teacher and later a college teacher in Cochin state (present-day Kerala). In 1902 the Dewan of Cochin asked him to assist with an ethnographic survey of the state, as the British government wanted similar surveys in all princely states and presidency areas. He did this work voluntarily, teaching at the Maharajah's College at Ernakulam during the week and working as the unpaid Superintendent of Ethnography on weekends. His work was much appreciated by British anthropologists and administrators, and he was invited to help with a similar survey in Mysore. He was probably the first self-taught anthropologist to receive national and international recognition, lectured at the University of Madras and was appointed Reader at the University of Calcutta (1917-1932), where he helped set up the first post-graduate anthropology department in India.
Sarat Chandra Roy (1871-1942) was a lawyer who had done graduate and post-graduate degrees in English before taking a law degree at Ripon College, Calcutta. In 1898 he went to Ranchi to teach English at a Christian missionary school and remained there for forty-four years. When he gave up the school job and practised law in the Ranchi courts, becoming the official interpreter in the court, he had to interpret tribal customs and laws, which led to a deep interest in tribal society. He travelled extensively among the tribal communities and did intensive fieldwork on an "amateur" basis, publishing over a hundred articles and monographs on the Oraon, the Mundas and the Kharias, and became the leading authority on Chhotanagpur. He founded the journal Man in India in 1922.
What were the main arguments on either side of the debate about how to relate to tribal communities?
Solution
In the 1930s and 1940s there was much debate on the place of tribal societies in India and how the state should respond to them. Both sides agreed that Indian tribals were hardly ever isolated primitive communities, and the difference lay in how the impact of mainstream culture was evaluated.
The protectionist view (many British administrator-anthropologists). They held that tribes were primitive peoples with a distinctive culture far from mainstream Hinduism, and that the innocent and simple tribals would suffer exploitation and cultural degradation through contact with Hindu society. So the state had a duty to protect them and help them sustain their way of life. They believed assimilation would result in severe exploitation and cultural extinction of the tribals.
The nationalist view (Ghurye and nationalist Indians). They believed in the unity of India and the need to modernise Indian society and culture, and thought attempts to preserve tribal culture were misguided, keeping tribals in a backward state as "museums" of primitive culture. Ghurye insisted on calling the tribes "backward Hindus", citing evidence of their long interaction with Hinduism to show they were only further behind in the same process of assimilation that all Indian communities had gone through. The ill-effects were not specific to tribes but common to all backward and downtrodden sections and were inevitable difficulties on the road to development.
Outline the positions of Herbert Risley and G.S. Ghurye on the relationship between race and caste in India.
Solution
Herbert Risley (a British colonial official) was the main proponent of the dominant view that human beings can be divided into distinct races on the basis of physical characteristics such as the circumference of the skull, the length of the nose and the volume of the cranium. He and others believed:
India was a unique "laboratory" for studying racial types because caste strictly prohibited inter-marriage among groups for centuries.
Caste must have originated in race, since different caste groups seemed to belong to distinct racial types: higher castes approximated Indo-Aryan traits, while lower castes seemed to belong to non-Aryan aboriginal, Mongoloid or other groups.
On the basis of average measurements, they suggested that the lower castes were the original aboriginal inhabitants who had been subjugated by an Aryan people who came from elsewhere.
G.S. Ghurye (in his doctoral work, published as Caste and Race in India, 1932) did not disagree with the basic argument but thought it only partially correct.
He pointed out the problem of using averages alone without considering the variation in the distribution of a measurement within a community.
He believed Risley's thesis of upper castes being Aryan and lower castes non-Aryan was broadly true only for northern India (Hindustan proper).
In other parts, except the Indo-Gangetic plain, differences between groups were not large or systematic, suggesting different racial groups had been mixing for a long time. "Racial purity" was preserved by the ban on inter-marriage only in north India; elsewhere endogamy may have been introduced into groups that were already racially varied.
The chapter adds that today the racial theory of caste is no longer believed.
Summarise the social anthropological definition of caste.
Solution
Ghurye's comprehensive definition emphasises six features:
Segmental division. Caste divides society into closed, mutually exclusive segments. Membership is decided by birth and can neither be avoided nor changed.
Hierarchical division. Each caste is strictly unequal to every other, higher or lower; in theory, though not in practice, no two castes are equal.
Restrictions on social interaction, especially sharing of food. There are elaborate rules on what food may be shared between which groups, governed by ideas of purity and pollution, most dramatically in untouchability, where even the touch of people of particular castes is thought polluting.
Differential rights and duties for different castes, extending from religious practices to the secular world.
Restriction on choice of occupation. Occupation is decided by birth and hereditary; caste is a rigid form of the division of labour, with specific occupations allocated to specific castes.
Strict restrictions on marriage. Endogamy (marriage only within the caste) together with rules of exogamy (whom one may not marry) helps reproduce the caste system.
This definition was based on what classical texts prescribed; in practice many features were changing, though all continue to exist in some form.
What does D.P. Mukerji mean by a `living tradition'? Why did he insist that Indian sociologists be rooted in this tradition?
Solution
Living tradition. D.P. Mukerji said that the root meaning of tradition is to transmit; its Sanskrit equivalents are parampara (succession) and aitihya (from the same root as itihas, history). Traditions are strongly rooted in the past, kept alive by recalling and retelling stories and myths. But the link with the past does not rule out change; it indicates a process of adaptation. A living tradition thus maintains links with the past by retaining something from it, and at the same time takes in new things, evolving over time. It includes old elements and new ones.
Why sociologists must be rooted in it.
He felt the crucial distinctive feature of India was its social system: India "had society, and very little else", with history, economics and philosophy centred in social groups. So each social science had to be rooted in this context.
Given the centrality of society in India, it was the first duty of the Indian sociologist to study and know its social traditions. In his words, the sociologist must be an Indian first, sharing in the folk-ways, mores, customs and traditions in order to understand the social system and what lies beneath it.
Sociologists should be familiar with both "high" and "low" languages and cultures, not only Sanskrit, Persian or Arabic but also local dialects.
It also guided him in criticising unthinking borrowing from western traditions: tradition is neither to be worshipped nor ignored, as modernity is needed but not to be blindly adopted.
What are the specificities of Indian culture and society, and how do they affect the pattern of change?
Solution
Following D.P. Mukerji's analysis in the chapter:
Specificities.
The social dimension is "over-developed": history, politics and economics were centred in social groups and less developed than in the west.
Indian culture and society are not individualistic in the western sense. The individual's pattern of desires is largely fixed by the socio-cultural group, and the social system is oriented to group, sect or caste action and not to "voluntaristic" individual action (though voluntarism was beginning to influence the urban middle classes).
Tradition is strong and rooted in the past, yet living and adaptive.
Class conflict has been "smoothed and covered by caste traditions", as new class relations had not emerged sharply.
Effect on the pattern of change.
The economy, the most commonly cited internal source of change in the west, has not been as effective in India; so an Indian sociology must study the internal, non-economic causes of change.
Of the three principles of change in Indian traditions (shruti, smriti and anubhava), the revolutionary one is anubhava (personal experience), which soon flowered into collective experience of groups and sects, as in the bhakti movement and among Sufis in Indian Islam. Experience and love (anubhava and prem) have been historically superior to discursive reason (buddhi-vichar) as agents of change.
Conflict and rebellion work through collective experiences, but the resilience of tradition means the pressure of conflict changes the tradition without breaking it. Dominant orthodoxy is challenged by popular revolts that transform it but are eventually reabsorbed into it, which is typical of a caste society where class formation and consciousness are inhibited.
What is a welfare state? Why is A.R. Desai critical of the claims made on its behalf?
Solution
Welfare state. After considering the definitions in sociological literature, A.R. Desai identified its unique features:
It is a positive state: unlike the laissez-faire of classical liberal theory, it does not do the minimum to maintain law and order but is an interventionist state that uses its powers to design and implement social policies for the betterment of society.
It is a democratic state: formal democratic institutions, especially multi-party elections, are a defining feature, which is why liberal thinkers excluded socialist and communist states.
It involves a mixed economy, where private capitalist enterprises and state or publicly owned enterprises co-exist; the state sector concentrates on basic goods and social infrastructure and private industry dominates the consumer goods sector.
Why Desai is critical. He wrote from a Marxist perspective, in "The myth of the welfare state". He proposed test criteria: does the welfare state ensure freedom from poverty, social discrimination and security for all; remove inequalities of income by redistribution and preventing concentration of wealth; transform the economy so that the profit motive is subservient to the real needs of the community; ensure stable development free from booms and depressions; and provide employment for all?
Examining states usually called welfare states, such as Britain, the USA and much of Europe, he found their claims greatly exaggerated: they fail to provide minimum economic and social security to all citizens, cannot reduce economic inequality and often seem to encourage it, have not ensured stable development free from market fluctuations, and show excess economic capacity and high unemployment. He concluded that the notion of the welfare state is something of a myth.
What arguments were given for and against the village as a subject of sociological research by M.N. Srinivas and Louis Dumont?
Solution
Against (Louis Dumont and some social anthropologists). They thought that social institutions like caste were more important than the village, which was only a collection of people living in a particular place. Villages may live or die and people may move from one village to another, but their institutions like caste or religion follow them wherever they go. So it would be misleading to give much importance to the village as a category.
For (M.N. Srinivas). Srinivas believed the village was a relevant social entity:
Historical evidence showed villages had served as a unifying identity and village unity was quite significant in rural social life.
He criticised the British administrator-anthropologists for portraying the village as unchanging, self-sufficient "little republics". Using historical and sociological evidence he showed that villages had experienced considerable change and were never self-sufficient, being involved in economic, social and political relationships at the regional level.
The village as a site of research illustrated the importance of ethnographic methods and offered eye-witness accounts of rapid social change in the countryside.
What is the significance of village studies in the history of Indian sociology? What role did M.N. Srinivas play in promoting village studies?
Solution
Significance. The chapter says the village as a site of research offered many advantages:
It showed the importance of ethnographic research methods.
It offered eye-witness accounts of the rapid social change in the Indian countryside as the newly independent nation began planned development.
These vivid descriptions were greatly appreciated at the time, as urban Indians and policy makers could form impressions of what was going on in the heartland of India.
It gave sociology a new role in an independent nation: rather than being restricted to the study of "primitive" peoples, it could be made relevant to a modernising society.
Role of Srinivas. The village remained a life-long interest for him. Fieldwork for a year in a village near Mysore gave him first-hand knowledge and proved decisive for his career. He helped encourage and coordinate a major collective effort to produce detailed ethnographic accounts of village society in the 1950s and 1960s. Along with scholars like S.C. Dube and D.N. Majumdar, he was instrumental in making village studies the dominant field in Indian sociology of that time. He wrote ethnographic accounts and also conceptual discussions on the village as a unit of analysis, defending its relevance in the debate with Dumont.
Today we still seem to be involved in similar debates. Discuss the different sides to the question from a contemporary perspective. For example, many tribal movements assert their distinctive cultural and political identity -- in fact, the states of Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh were formed in response to such movements. There is also a major controversy around the disproportionate burden that tribal communities have been forced to bear for the sake of developmental projects like big dams, mines and factories. How many such conflicts do you know about? Find out what the issues are in these conflicts. What do you and your classmates feel should be done about these problems?
Solution
Guidance. Use the two sides of the 1930s-40s debate. The protectionist side today appears in demands to protect tribal culture, land and identity, and in the tribal movements that led to the states of Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh. The nationalist side stresses that tribes, like other backward sections, need development and integration, and that keeping them apart can leave them in a backward state.
The controversy on development projects such as big dams, mines and factories is that tribal communities bear a disproportionate burden. Collect specific local cases and note the issues (loss of land and livelihood, displacement, and who benefits). Your own view should weigh both protection of identity and rights and access to development.
Discuss what is meant by a `living tradition'. According to D.P. Mukerji, this is a tradition which maintains links with the past by retaining something from it, and at the same time incorporates new things. A living tradition thus includes some old elements but also some new ones. You can get a better and more concrete sense of what this means if you try to find out from different generations of people in your neighbourhood or family about what is changed and what is unchanged about specific practices. Here is a list of subjects you can try; you could also try other subjects of your own choice: games played by children of your age group (boys/girls); ways in which a popular festival is celebrated; typical dress/clothing worn by women and men. For each of these, you need to find out: What aspects have remained unchanged since as far back as you know or can find out? What aspects have changed? What was different and same about the practice/event (i) 10 years ago; (ii) 20 years ago; (iii) 40 years ago; (iv) 60 or more years ago? Discuss your findings with the whole class.
Solution
Guidance. A living tradition is one that keeps links with the past by retaining something from it and also takes in new things. For each subject (children's games, a popular festival, clothing), make a table of what has remained the same and what has changed over 10, 20, 40 and 60 or more years, using what your elders tell you. Where a practice has both old and new elements, it is a living tradition in D.P. Mukerji's sense.
A.R. Desai criticises the welfare state from a Marxist and socialist point of view -- that is he would like the state to do more for its citizens than is being done by western capitalist welfare states. There are also very strong opposing viewpoints today which say that the state should do less -- it should leave most things to the free market. Discuss these viewpoints in class. Be sure to give a fair hearing to both sides. Make a list of all the things that are done by the state or government in your neighbourhood, starting with your school. Ask people to find out if this list has grown longer or shorter in recent years -- is the state doing more things now than before, or less? What do you feel would happen if the state were to stop doing these things? Would you and your neighbourhood/school be worse off, better off, or remain unaffected? Would rich, middle class, and poor people have the same opinion, or be affected in the same way, if the state were to stop some of its activities? Make a list of state-provided services and facilities in your neighbourhood, and see how opinions might differ across class groups on whether these should continue or be stopped.
Solution
Guidance. The two sides: (1) Desai's view that the state should do more, since even the so-called welfare states fail to ensure security for all, reduce inequality or provide employment for all; (2) the free-market view, close to the "laissez-faire" idea explained in the glossary, that the state should do the minimum and leave most things to the market.
For the list, include state-provided services such as roads, water supply, electricity supply, street lights, schools, sanitation, police, hospitals and public transport, as the book suggests. Think about whether poorer people, who may depend more on public schools, hospitals and transport, would be affected differently from the rich, who can buy private alternatives (this is for you to test against what you find). Record the opinions you find and compare them by class.
Suppose you had friends from another planet or civilisation who were visiting the Earth for the first time and had never heard of something called a `village'. What are the five clues you would give them to identify a village if they ever came across one? Do this in small groups and then compare the five clues given by different groups. Which features appear most often? Do the most common features help you to make a sort of definition of a village? (To check whether your definition is a good one, ask yourself the question: Could there be a village where all or most features mentioned in your definition are absent?)
Solution
Sample answer. Using what the book says about villages in Chapter 2 (Social Change and Social Order in Rural and Urban Society) and in the discussion of Srinivas: (1) a small settlement with a low density of population spread over a larger area; (2) a significant part of the population in agriculture-linked occupations, with most produce and income from agriculture; (3) personalised relationships, where people mostly know one another by sight; (4) strong traditional institutions such as caste and religion; (5) a sense of village unity as a shared identity.
To test the definition, ask whether a village can exist without one of these features, for example a village where most people have non-farm jobs. This is the kind of question behind the debate between Dumont, who thought institutions like caste mattered more than the village, and Srinivas, who thought the village a relevant social entity.
In the 1950s, there was great interest among urban Indians in the village studies that sociologists began doing at that time. Do you feel urban people are interested in the village today? How often are villages mentioned in the T.V., in newspapers and films? If you live in a city, does your family still have contacts with relatives in the village? Did it have such contacts in your parents' generation or your grandparents' generation? Do you know of anybody from a city who has moved to a village? Do you know of people who would like to go back? If you do, what reasons do these people give for wanting to leave the city and live in the village? If you don't know of any such people, why do you think people don't want to live in a village? If you know of people living in a village who would like to live in a town or city, what reasons do they give for wanting to leave the village?
Solution
Guidance. This is an opinion and survey activity, so answer from your own observation. Useful points from the chapters: in the 1950s village studies gave urban Indians and policy makers impressions of the heartland of India during planned development. Today, note how often villages appear in the media and whether your family keeps contacts with relatives in villages across generations.
Reasons people give for moving from villages to cities usually relate to what the book describes: villages offer fewer alternative sources of employment, and the poor depend on the dominant sections; the city, in contrast, offers anonymity and amenities and institutions that only large numbers can support. Reasons for wanting to return could be more personalised relationships and a less crowded environment, though the city has problems of housing, transport and pollution.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Sociology notes
For CBSE Class 11 Sociology (039), 2026-27: Introducing Sociology (5 chapters) and Understanding Society (5 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short and long answer) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 10 chapters · instant PDF