NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 10
Chapter 10: The Philosophy of the Constitution (Philosophy of the Constitution)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 10: The Philosophy of the Constitution (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on the values behind the Constitution, secularism, federalism, criticisms and limitations, plus the in-text questions. All 13 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
The following are certain laws. Are they connected with any value? If yes, then what is the underlying value? Give reasons.
Both daughters and sons will have share in the family property.
There will be different slabs of sales tax on different consumer items.
Religious instructions will not be given in any government school.
There shall be no begar or forced labour.
Solution
The chapter says that many laws are closely connected to our deeply held values, as a law against discrimination is connected to the idea of equality.
Equality (gender justice). Giving daughters and sons an equal share treats men and women equally and removes discrimination within the family on the ground of sex.
Social justice (equity). Different slabs of tax mean that essential items are taxed less and luxury items more, so that the burden falls according to the capacity to pay and the needs of the people. It reflects the commitment to social justice and a fair distribution of burdens.
Secularism. Keeping religious instruction out of government schools means that the state does not favour any religion and treats all religions with equal respect, and protects the freedom of conscience of students.
Freedom and dignity (justice). Begar or forced labour takes away the basic dignity and freedom of a person. Prohibiting it protects individual freedom and social justice for the weaker sections.
Which of the options given below cannot be used to complete the following statement? Democratic countries need a constitution to
Check the power of the government.
Protect minorities from majority.
Bring independence from colonial rule.
Ensure that a long-term vision is not lost by momentary passions.
Bring social change in peaceful manner.
Solution
(iii) cannot be used.
A constitution restricts the exercise of power so that the state does not turn tyrannical (i); it protects the rights of minorities and weaker groups (ii); it gives a long-term vision and a framework, so that it is not lost in the passions of a moment (iv); and it provides peaceful, democratic means of social transformation (v). Independence from colonial rule (iii) is won by the freedom struggle and not by a constitution. The chapter says only that for a formerly colonised people, a constitution announces and embodies the first real exercise of political self-determination, which is different from bringing independence.
The following are different positions about reading and understanding Constituent Assembly debates. i. Which of these statements argues that Constituent Assembly debates are relevant even today? Which statement says that they are not relevant? ii. With which of these positions do you agree and why?
Common people are too busy in earning livelihood and meeting different pressures of life. They can't understand the legal language of these debates.
The conditions and challenges today are different from the time when the Constitution was made. To read the ideas of Constitution makers and use them for our new times is trying to bring past in the present
Our ways of understanding the world and the present challenges have not changed totally. Constituent Assembly debates can provide us reasons why certain practises are important. In a period when constitutional practises are being challenged, not knowing the reasons can destroy them.
Solution
(i) Statement (c) argues that the debates are relevant even today. Statement (b) says that they are not relevant, because conditions and challenges have changed. Statement (a) does not say the debates are irrelevant; it says that common people would find it hard to read and understand them.
(ii) Sample answer: I agree with (c). The chapter says that in India, unlike the United States whose constitution was written in the late 18th century, the world of the original framers is not very different from ours: "In terms of our values, ideals and conception, we have not separated ourselves from the world of the Constituent Assembly". It also says that we may have forgotten the reasons behind several of our practices, because we have taken them for granted. This is harmless when the going is good, but when the practices are challenged, neglect of the underlying principles can be harmful. The debates tell us why certain practices are important. As for (a), difficulty is a reason to simplify and teach the debates, not to ignore them.
Explain the difference between the Indian Constitution and western ideas in the light of
Understanding of secularism.
Articles 370 and 371.
Affirmative action.
Universal adult franchise.
Solution
Secularism. The western model means mutual exclusion of the state and religion: the state neither helps nor hinders religions and keeps an arm's length, treating religion as a private matter. The Indian Constitution departs from it in two ways. It recognises the rights of religious groups, such as the right to establish and maintain educational institutions, so freedom of religion belongs to individuals and communities. And the state has the power to intervene in religion, for example to end untouchability, or to give aid to educational institutions run by communities. Separation means principled distance and not mutual exclusion.
Articles 370 and 371. Western federalism, like the American, is symmetric. The Indian Constitution introduced asymmetric federalism: Article 370 gave a special status to Jammu and Kashmir (this status no longer exists since 2019), and Article 371 (including 371A for Nagaland) gives special provisions to the North-Eastern States, such as validity to pre-existing laws and protection of local identity through restrictions on immigration. Differential treatment of units is considered nothing bad.
Affirmative action. The Indian Constitution made the commitment to caste-based affirmative action by providing reservation of seats in legislatures and of public sector jobs for Scheduled Castes and Tribes, to link liberalism with social justice. In the U.S., affirmative action programmes began only after the 1964 Civil Rights Act, almost two decades after they were constitutionally entrenched in India.
Universal adult franchise. In stable Western democracies the right to vote had been extended to women and the working class only recently. India committed itself to universal franchise from the start, in spite of the belief that traditional hierarchies were too rigid to eliminate. The idea had been present in Indian nationalism since the Constitution of India Bill (1895) and the Motilal Nehru Report (1928).
Which of the following principles of secularism are adopted in the Constitution of India?
that state will have nothing to do with religion
that state will have close relation with religion
that state can discriminate among religions
that state will recognise rights of religious groups
that state will have limited powers to intervene in affairs of religions
Solution
(d) and (e) are adopted.
(a) Not adopted: this is the western idea of mutual exclusion. In India, separation does not mean mutual exclusion but principled distance.
(b) Not adopted: the state keeps a distance from all religions.
(c) Not adopted: the state has to be at a distance from all religions, so that it can promote liberty, equality and social justice, and it does not discriminate.
(d) Adopted: the Constitution grants rights to all religious communities, such as the right to establish and maintain educational institutions.
(e) Adopted: the state can intervene in religion, for example to end untouchability, or help, for example through aid to educational institutions of communities, depending on which promotes freedom and equality. The power is limited to promoting these values.
Match the following. a. Freedom to criticise treatment of widows b. Taking decisions in the constituent assembly on the basis of reason, not self interest c. Accepting importance of community in an individual's life d. Article 370 and 371 e. Unequal rights to women regarding family property and children i. Substantive achievement ii. Procedural achievement iii. Neglect of gender justice iv. Liberal individualism v. Attention to requirements of a particular region
Solution
Item
Match
Reason
a. Freedom to criticise treatment of widows
iv. Liberal individualism
The freedom of expression and of conscience of individuals, against community customs, is part of liberal individualism.
b. Taking decisions on the basis of reason, not self interest
ii. Procedural achievement
It reflects faith in political deliberation, a procedural achievement of the Constitution.
c. Accepting importance of community in an individual's life
i. Substantive achievement
Recognition of group rights and respect for diversity is one of the core (substantive) features of the Constitution.
d. Article 370 and 371
v. Attention to requirements of a particular region
Special provisions for particular States, such as Jammu and Kashmir and the North-East.
e. Unequal rights to women regarding family property and children
iii. Neglect of gender justice
One of the limitations: the Constitution glossed over gender justice within the family.
This discussion was taking place in a class. Read the various arguments and state which of these you agree with and why. Jayesh: I still think that our Constitution is only a borrowed document. Saba: Do you mean to say that there is nothing Indian in it? But is there such a thing as Indian and western in the case of values and ideas? Take equality between men and women. What is western about it? And even if it is, should we reject it only because it is western? Jayesh: What I mean is that after fighting for independence from the British, did we not adopt their system of parliamentary government? Neha: You forget that when we fought the British, we were not against the British as such, we were against the principle of colonialism. That has nothing to do with adopting a system of government that we wanted, wherever it came from.
Solution
Sample answer: I agree with Saba and Neha.
The chapter admits that the Constitution is modern and partly western, but says that it was never a blind borrowing. It was innovative borrowing, and in every borrowed aspect the framers put their own imprint.
Many Indians, from Rammohan Roy to the Dalits today, have made modern ways of thinking their own. As early as 1841 Dalits of northern India used the new legal system to bring suits against their landlords.
When western modernity met local cultural systems, an alternative, hybrid modernity emerged. In drafting the Constitution, efforts were made to amalgamate western and traditional Indian values, so it was selective adaptation and not borrowing.
The national movement was against colonialism, not against ideas from the West. Ideas such as equality between men and women are valuable wherever they came from. We should judge a system by whether it promotes our values.
Jayesh is right that some institutions, such as the parliamentary system, have a western origin, but that does not make the Constitution alien.
Why is it said that the making of the Indian Constitution was unrepresentative? Does that make the Constitution unrepresentative? Give reasons for your answer.
Solution
Why it is said so. The Constituent Assembly was not elected by universal adult franchise. It was formed when adult franchise had not yet been granted, by a restricted franchise, and most members came from the advanced sections of society. So many groups were not adequately represented, and in terms of "voice", that is, people being recognised in their own language and not the language of the masters, it was unrepresentative.
Does this make the Constitution unrepresentative? Not entirely.
Representation has two components, voice and opinion. In terms of opinion, a vast range of issues and opinions was raised in the debates. Members spoke not only about their individual social concerns but about the perceived interests and concerns of various social sections. The claim that almost every shade of opinion was represented may be a trifle exaggerated, but it has something to it.
The makers wanted to be as inclusive as possible, and they adopted universal adult franchise for the future.
The Dalits feel that the Constitution reflects many of their aspirations. The statues of Dr. Ambedkar with a copy of the Constitution in many small towns express this feeling.
One of the limitations of the Constitution of India is that it does not adequately attend to gender justice. What evidence can you give to substantiate this charge? If you were writing the Constitution today, what provisions would you recommend for remedying this limitation?
Solution
Evidence. The chapter says that the Constitution appears to have glossed over some important issues of gender justice, particularly within the family. As an example of the neglect of gender justice it lists unequal rights of women regarding family property and children (Exercise 6). It does not strongly attend to the private sphere of the family, where customs and personal laws often make women unequal, although the Constitution guarantees equality in public life.
Sample recommendations.
A provision that personal laws and customs of all communities must conform to the equality of men and women, with equal rights in property, inheritance, marriage and guardianship of children.
An explicit right against domestic violence and harassment, and against practices that treat women as unequal in the family.
Constitutional provision for one-third reservation of women in Parliament and Assemblies, as in local bodies.
Equal pay for equal work and protection at the workplace, as enforceable rights.
Do you agree with the statement that "it is not clear why in a poor developing country, certain basic socio-economic rights were relegated to the section on Directive Principles rather than made an integral feature of our Fundamental Rights"? Give reasons for your answer. What do you think are the possible reasons for putting socio-economic rights in the section on Directive Principles?
Solution
Sample answer: I agree to a large extent. In a poor developing country, rights such as the right to work, education, health and an adequate livelihood are basic needs, and the poor cannot enjoy their civil rights without them. Directive Principles are non-justiciable, so citizens cannot go to court to enforce them, which weakens the commitment to social justice of the Constitution itself.
Possible reasons for putting them under the Directive Principles (my suggestions, not stated in the chapter):
A newly independent and poor country did not have the resources to guarantee all these rights immediately, and rights that cannot be implemented could lose their meaning if courts were to enforce them.
The framers wanted such matters to be decided through the democratic process and by the policies of governments from time to time, with the Directive Principles as goals which governments should aim for.
The Constitution did link liberalism with social justice in other ways, such as reservations for Scheduled Castes and Tribes, and the Directive Principles still guide the laws of the state.
How did your school celebrate the Constitution Day on November 26th?
Solution
Guidance: This is a personal activity question with no fixed answer. Describe what your school did (for example reading the Preamble together in the assembly, speeches or quiz on the Constituent Assembly and Dr. Ambedkar, essay or poster competitions, or a talk on fundamental rights and duties). If your school did not celebrate it, suggest what could be done. A sample line: Our school held an assembly where all students read the Preamble aloud, and there was a quiz on the making of the Constitution. The Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949, as Chapter 9 records.
Check your progress: State which of the following rights are part of individual freedom: Freedom of expression; Freedom of religion; Cultural and educational rights of minorities; Equal access to public places
Solution
Freedom of expression: yes, individual freedom. The chapter names freedom of expression (the demand for a free press) and freedom from arbitrary arrest as parts of individual freedom.
Freedom of religion: yes. Freedom of conscience is an individual freedom of the liberal ideology, though in India freedom of religion also belongs to religious communities.
Cultural and educational rights of minorities: not individual freedom. They are community-based (group) rights, such as the right of religious communities to establish and run their educational institutions.
Equal access to public places: not mentioned in the chapter as an individual freedom; it is a part of the right to equality and social justice, which gives equal status to all individuals and ends caste-based discrimination.
Activity: Read again the quotes from the Debates of the Constituent Assembly (CAD) given in the following chapters. Do you think that the arguments in those quotations have relevance for our present times? Why? i. Quotes in Chapter two ii. Quote in Chapter seven
Solution
Guidance: Reread the quotations. The quotation in Chapter 7 is T.T. Krishnamachari's statement of 25 November 1949 that the drift in all constitutions has been towards the centre, because the State has become a welfare state and the ultimate responsibility for the economic well-being of the country has become the paramount responsibility of the centre. It is still relevant: the debates on the Centre's strong role, financial powers and the demands of the States for autonomy continue today. The two quotations in Chapter 2 are Somnath Lahiri's complaint (29 April 1947) that fundamental rights were drafted from the point of view of a police constable, each followed by a proviso that almost takes the right away, and Sardar Hukam Singh's statement (26 May 1949) that the majority must make the minorities feel secure and that the only safety for minorities lies in a secular State. Both concern the limits on rights and the protection of minorities, which are still live issues today. Follow the chapter's argument that the world of the framers is not very different from ours, and give reasons.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF