NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Political Theory · Chapter 4
Chapter 4: Social Justice (Social Justice)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Political Theory Chapter 4: Social Justice (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on principles of justice, Rawls' veil of ignorance and the basic minimum, plus the in-text questions. All 9 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
What does it mean to give each person his/her due? How has the meaning of "giving each his due" changed over time?
Solution
Giving each person his or her due means that justice involves treating every individual as he or she deserves, with concern for the well-being of all. Socrates explained in The Republic that justice is not merely doing good to friends and harm to enemies or pursuing our own interests; just as a doctor is concerned with the well-being of patients, a just ruler is concerned with the well-being of the people, which includes giving each person his due.
The meaning of what is due has changed. In ancient Indian society justice was linked to dharma and keeping a just social order, a primary duty of kings; Confucius held that kings should punish wrong doers and reward the virtuous. Today what is due to a person is closely linked to what is due to him or her as a human being. According to Immanuel Kant, all human beings possess dignity, so what is due to each is the opportunity to develop talents and pursue chosen goals. Justice now requires giving due and equal consideration to all individuals.
Briefly discuss the three principles of justice outlined in the chapter? Explain each with examples.
Solution
Equal treatment for equals. All individuals share certain characteristics as human beings, so they deserve equal rights (civil rights such as life, liberty and property, political rights such as the vote, and social rights such as equal opportunities) and must not be discriminated against on grounds of class, caste, race or gender. Example: if two persons of different castes do the same work, such as breaking stones or delivering pizzas, they must get the same pay; a male teacher getting a higher salary than a female teacher for the same work would be unjust.
Proportionate justice. Equal treatment is not enough; rewards should be in proportion to the scale and quality of effort, skills required and dangers involved, once everyone starts from equal rights. Example: it would be unfair if all students got equal marks regardless of their answer papers. Miners, skilled craftsmen and policemen may not always be paid in line with the effort and danger of their work.
Recognition of special needs. Society should take account of people's special needs when distributing rewards and duties. Example: physical disabilities, age or lack of access to good education or health care are grounds for special help; in India the Constitution allowed reservations in jobs and quotas in educational institutions for the Scheduled Castes and Tribes.
Governments sometimes find it difficult to harmonise the three principles, and it is their function to balance them in order to promote a just society.
Does the principle of considering the special needs of people conflict with the principle of equal treatment for all?
Solution
No, not necessarily. The chapter says that the principle of taking account of special needs does not contradict the principle of equal treatment so much as extend it. The principle of treating equals equally can mean that people who are not equal in certain important respects may be treated differently.
Equal treatment in basic status and rights remains the base, but non-discrimination and proportionate reward may not be enough for people who are disadvantaged, for example by disability, age or lack of access to education and health care. If people with very different standards of living are treated alike in every respect, the result is likely to be an unequal society. Thus special help, given for genuine special needs, is meant to make equal treatment real. The difficulty is only in agreeing which inequalities deserve special help.
How does Rawls use the idea of a veil of ignorance to argue that fair and just distribution can be defended on rational grounds?
Solution
Rawls asks us to imagine that we have to decide how society should be organised without knowing which position we would ourselves occupy in it: what family we would be born in, upper or lower caste, rich or poor, privileged or disadvantaged. This situation of complete ignorance is the "veil of ignorance".
Each person still thinks in terms of his or her own interest, but since no one knows who he or she will be, each will look at the future society from the point of view of the worst-off, in case he or she is born among them.
Each will therefore choose rules that give reasonable opportunities to weaker sections and make resources such as education, health and shelter available to all.
Since one could also be born into a privileged position, each will also ensure that the rules do not weaken the better-off, so that society as a whole benefits.
Thus fairness comes out of rational self-interested thinking, not out of benevolence, generosity or self-sacrifice. Rawls argues that rational thinking, not morality, can lead us to judge impartially how to distribute the benefits and burdens of society, so a fair and just distribution can be defended on rational grounds.
What are generally considered to be the basic minimum requirements of people for living a healthy and productive life? What is the responsibility of governments in trying to ensure this minimum to all?
Solution
Methods of calculating basic needs have been devised by governments and international organisations such as the World Health Organisation. It is generally agreed that the basic minimum includes the basic amount of nourishment needed to remain healthy, housing, a supply of clean drinking water, education and a minimum wage.
Providing people with their basic needs is considered to be one of the responsibilities of a democratic government. A just society must provide the basic minimum conditions so that people can live healthy and secure lives, develop their talents and have equal opportunities to pursue their goals. However, this can be a heavy burden on governments, particularly in countries like India with a large number of poor people. There is also a debate on the method: whether free markets will best help the disadvantaged, or whether the government should itself provide a basic minimum to the poor, even through redistribution of resources.
Which of the following arguments could be used to justify state action to provide basic minimum conditions of life to all citizens?
Providing free services to the poor and needy can be justified as an act of charity.
Providing all citizens with a basic minimum standard of living is one way of ensuring equality of opportunity.
Some people are naturally lazy and we should be kind to them.
Ensuring basic facilities and a minimum standard of living to all is a recognition of our shared humanity and a human right.
Solution
(b) and (d) are the arguments that justify state action.
Not suitable. Charity is a favour given out of kindness, not something that people can claim as due; the chapter says justice concerns what is due to each person.
Suitable. People who lack basic nourishment, health care and education cannot compete on equal terms, so a minimum standard is necessary for equality of opportunity.
Not suitable. It treats the poor as lazy people deserving kindness, and does not rest on a principle of justice.
Suitable. It rests on the dignity of every human being and treats the minimum as a right, which is the modern understanding of what is due to a person.
Let's think: Examine the following situations and discuss whether they are just. In each case discuss the principle of justice that might be used in defence of your argument.
Suresh, a visually impaired student, gets three hours and thirty minutes to finish his mathematics paper, while the rest of the class gets only three hours.
Geeta walks with a limp. The teacher decided to give her also three hours and thirty minutes to finish her mathematics paper.
A teacher gives grace marks to the weaker students in class, to boost their morale.
A professor distributes different question papers to different students based on her evaluation of their capabilities.
There is a proposal to reserve 33 per cent of the seats in the Parliament for women.
Solution
Sample answer, using the three principles (equal treatment, proportionate reward, special needs).
Just. A visual impairment is a special need that makes writing the paper slower; extra time lets him compete on equal terms. Principle: recognition of special needs.
Not just. A limp does not affect the speed of writing a paper, so there is no special need. It gives her an advantage over others and violates equal treatment for equals.
Not just. Marks should reward the quality and effort of the answers (proportionate justice). Grace marks to raise morale give unearned reward and are unfair to the others; the weaker students need help in learning, not marks.
Not just, in general. It treats students who are equal in basic rights differently on the basis of the professor's evaluation, not on any special need, and so breaks equal treatment and makes comparison of marks unfair.
Open to debate, but defensible. Women have been under-represented and long deprived of equal opportunity, so reservation can be defended under the special-needs principle; critics argue that it conflicts with equal treatment.
Margin: Why is the statue of justice blindfolded? She is blindfolded because she needs to be impartial. Of course she needs to be impartial. But I wonder how then does she see the special needs of people?
Solution
Sample answer: The blindfold shows that justice must not favour anyone because of wealth, power, caste, religion or gender; this is the principle of equal treatment for equals. But justice is not only impartiality. The chapter says that social justice also requires taking into account special needs and proportionate reward. The law and the state must therefore first know about the different circumstances of people, such as disability or deprivation, through study of facts, and then frame rules and policies which are impartial in principle but take such needs into account, such as reservations or special facilities.
Let's do it: Various calculations of the minimum requirements of food, income, water and such facilities have been made by government agencies and U.N. agencies. Search in your school library, or on the internet, for any such calculations.
Solution
Guidance: Look for the poverty line and minimum calorie norms used by the government, and for the World Health Organisation and other U.N. standards on clean drinking water, nutrition and housing. Note down the figure, the agency and the year, and compare it with the chapter's list of the basic minimum: nourishment, housing, clean drinking water, education and a minimum wage.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF