NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Political Theory · Chapter 8
Chapter 8: Secularism (Secularism)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Political Theory Chapter 8: Secularism (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on inter and intra-religious domination, western and Indian secularism and principled distance, plus the in-text questions. All 16 questions are answered in full.
Which of the following do you feel are compatible with the idea of secularism? Give reasons.
Absence of domination of one religious group by another.
Recognition of a state religion.
Equal state support to all religions.
Mandatory prayers in schools.
Allowing separate educational institutions for any minority community.
Appointment of temple management bodies by the government.
Intervention of state to ensure entry of Dalits in temples.
Solution
Compatible. Secularism is first and foremost a doctrine that opposes inter-religious domination, and it aims at a society free of both inter-religious and intra-religious domination.
Not compatible. A secular state must have no formal, legal alliance with any religion and must not establish a religion. States with an official religion, like Pakistan with Sunni Islam or sixteenth century England with the Anglican Church, leave little scope for dissent or religious equality.
Compatible in the Indian sense if it means even-handed treatment, such as the state giving assistance to the educational institutions of all minorities; Nehru described secularism as equal protection by the State to all religions. It is not compatible if it means the state funding or promoting worship, since the state must keep a principled distance and have no religious rationale for its policies.
Not compatible. Mandatory prayers in a state school give a religious rationale to public policy and may force children of other faiths to take part, which would violate religious freedom and equality.
Compatible. Indian secularism protects the right of religious minorities to maintain their own culture and educational institutions, and the Constitution grants all religious minorities the right to establish and maintain educational institutions, which may receive state assistance.
Not compatible in general. The chapter says that the state must be separated from organised religion and its institutions, and that it must not be run by the heads of a religion; government appointment of the management bodies of one religion's temples would be state control over that religion's institutions and could favour or burden one religion. (The state may, however, intervene in a principled way to oppose oppression, as in the ban on untouchability.)
Compatible. Indian secularism opposes intra-religious domination as well, and allows state-supported religious reform: the Constitution bans untouchability, and the state may intervene to end the exclusion of dalits from temples.
Some of the key characteristics of western and Indian model of secularism have got mixed up. Separate them and make a new table.
Solution
Western secularism
Indian secularism
Strict non-interference of religion and state in each other's affairs
State supported religious reforms allowed
Equality between different sects of a religion is emphasised (focus on intra-religious domination)
Equality between different religious groups is a key concern
Less attention to community based rights
Attention to minority rights
Individual and his rights at the centre
Rights of both individual and religious community protected
Reasons: in the western (American) model separation means mutual exclusion, and liberty and equality are individualist, with little scope for community-based or minority rights; being largely religiously homogeneous, western societies focused on intra-religious domination. The Indian model arose in a context of deep religious diversity, gives equal focus to intra-religious and inter-religious domination, protects the religious freedom of both individuals and minority communities, and allows state-supported religious reform.
What do you understand by secularism? Can it be equated with religious tolerance?
Solution
Secularism is a normative doctrine which seeks to realise a secular society, one without inter-religious or intra-religious domination. Put positively, it promotes freedom within religions, and equality between as well as within religions. It opposes all institutionalised religious domination, but is not anti-religious. A secular state is neither theocratic nor has any formal legal alliance with a religion, and is committed to peace, religious freedom and equality.
It cannot be equated with religious tolerance. The culture of inter-religious tolerance existed in India even before, but tolerance is compatible with religious domination. It may allow some space to everyone but such freedom is usually limited, and it allows one to put up with people one finds repugnant. This is a virtue if a society is recovering from a civil war but not in times of peace when people struggle for equal dignity and respect. Secularism is much more than mere peaceful coexistence or toleration: it requires equal dignity and rights for all, within and between religions, even if the state has to intervene in some aspects of religions.
Do you agree with the following statements? Give reasons for supporting or opposing any of them.
Secularism does not allow us to have a religious identity.
Secularism is against inequality within a religious group or between different religious groups.
Secularism has a western-Christian origin. It is not suitable for India.
Solution
Disagree. Secularism is against institutionalised religious domination, which is not the same as being anti-religious. It promotes religious freedom and equality and so protects religious identity. It does undermine only those forms of identity that are dogmatic, violent, fanatical, exclusivist or hateful of other religions. Indian secularism allows an individual to profess the religion of his or her choice and minorities to maintain their culture. (Atatürk's Turkey is the contrasting case, where the fez was banned.)
Agree. Secularism opposes both inter-religious and intra-religious domination. Indian secularism opposes the oppression of dalits and women within Hinduism, discrimination against women within Indian Islam or Christianity, and the threat a majority may pose to minorities; it supports equality within and between religions.
Disagree. The chapter says secularism has both western and non-western origins. In the west the central idea was church-state separation, and in countries like India the idea of peaceful coexistence of religious communities has been important. The western model is not a product of the Christian world: western states became secular when they challenged the control of established religious authority over social and political life. Many things in India such as trousers, the internet and parliamentary democracy came from the west too. India evolved its own variant, which is different from western secularism.
Indian secularism focuses on more than the religion-state separation. Explain.
Solution
Indian secularism does not focus only on church-state separation. It differs from the western model in several ways:
It gives equal focus to intra-religious and inter-religious domination: it opposes the oppression of dalits and women within Hinduism, discrimination against women in Islam and Christianity, and threats to minorities from the majority.
It deals with the religious freedom of individuals and also of minority communities, who have the right to exist and to maintain their own culture and educational institutions.
It is compatible with state-supported religious reform, because the state must also oppose intra-religious domination. The Constitution bans untouchability, and the state has enacted laws abolishing child marriage and lifting the taboo on inter-caste marriage.
The state may disengage from religion in American style, or engage with it where needed: negatively, to oppose religious tyranny, as in the ban on untouchability, or positively, as when minorities' educational institutions receive assistance from the state.
The state is neither theocratic nor does it establish any religion, but it follows a policy of religious equality that allows both distance and engagement.
Principled distance is the concept followed by Indian secularism in place of separation as mutual exclusion. The state keeps a distance from religion but not for the sake of absolute non-interference; the distance is guided by principles, namely the values of peace, freedom and equality (within and between religions). Depending on these principles the state may refrain from interfering, or intervene.
For example, the state may keep out of religious affairs to prevent communal conflict, as in the American style. It may intervene negatively to oppose religious tyranny, as in banning untouchability or enacting laws against child marriage, dowry and sati. It may engage positively by granting religious minorities the right to run educational institutions that may receive state aid. Thus the state is neither coercive nor indifferent: non-interference is also one of its options, and interference does not automatically mean coercion.
What do these examples have in common? (the 1984 massacre of Sikhs, the exodus of Kashmiri pandits, the post-Godhra riots in Gujarat in 2002)
Solution
They all involve discrimination in one form or another. In each case members of one community were targeted and victimised because of their religious identity, so that the basic freedoms of a set of citizens were denied. They are instances of religious persecution that reflect inter-religious domination, which secularism first and foremost opposes.
Let's do it: List some of the ways in which you feel communal harmony could be promoted.
Solution
Sample answer: Education for mutual understanding; sharing of festivals and mutual help between neighbours; stories of people of one community helping another during riots; fair and impartial action by the state to punish those guilty of communal violence and to prevent religious conflict; separating religious and state institutions; and equal respect and rights for all communities. The chapter says education and individual goodness are useful but not enough, so the state's role is crucial.
Let's debate: Learning more about other religions is the first step towards learning to respect and accept other people and their beliefs. But that need not mean that we should not be able to stand up for what we feel are basic human values.
Solution
Sample answer: Knowing about other faiths reduces prejudice and suspicion and builds respect. But respect does not mean accepting every practice. The chapter says secular state does not have to treat every aspect of every religion with equal respect, and religiously sanctioned caste hierarchies or discrimination against women are not acceptable. So we can respect people and their beliefs and still oppose practices that violate basic values such as equality and dignity.
Kemal Ataturk's secularism: Can you imagine a secularism that does not give you the freedom to keep the name you are identified with, wear the dress you are used to, change the language you communicate in? In what ways do you think Ataturk's secularism is different from Indian secularism?
Solution
No, such a secularism seems to take away basic freedoms. In Turkey Atatürk, who came to power after the First World War, set out aggressively to modernise and secularise the country: he changed his name from Mustafa Kemal Pasha, banned the fez by the Hat Law, encouraged Western clothing, replaced the traditional calendar with the Gregorian one and adopted a modified Latin alphabet in 1928. He intended to end the institution of Khalifa in public life.
Difference from Indian secularism: Atatürk's version involved active intervention in and suppression of religion, whereas Indian secularism keeps a principled distance from organised religion, protects the religious freedom of individuals and minority communities and does not seek to suppress religion. Nehru, who did not practise any religion himself, did not take secularism to mean hostility to religion.
Let's debate: Religious identities and differences have no significance for the young.
Solution
Sample answer (against the statement): Religious identity and differences still matter to the young. Young people are born into families and communities with their own faith, festivals and culture, and the chapter says that secularism protects religious identity and the freedom to profess the religion of one's choice; it undermines only those forms of identity that are dogmatic, violent, fanatical or exclusivist. The young also face the same problems of discrimination, inter-religious and intra-religious domination as the old, which is why they need to understand and defend equality within and between religions. A supporter of the statement may say that young people mix freely across religions in school and college, and that this is a good sign; but this shows tolerance for differences, not that the differences have no significance.
Let's think: Is secularism compatible with the following? Subsidising a pilgrimage for a minority community. Performing religious rituals in government offices.
Solution
Sample answer. Performing religious rituals in government offices is not compatible: a secular state must not adopt or favour any religion, and public policy and institutions must have no exclusively religious rationale. Subsidising a pilgrimage for a minority community is open to debate: the state would be financing a religious activity, which is generally against the principle of keeping distance from religion; it could be defended only as an even-handed, principled measure to remove a real disadvantage, and only if all communities are treated alike. In general, the Indian state may engage with religion in support of equality, but the policy must be justified by the values of peace, freedom and equality and not by favour to one religion.
Let's do it: Watch films such as Bombay and Garam Hawa. What ideals of secularism do they depict? Read a short story 'Name' in Forsaking Paradise: Stories from Ladakh by Abdul Ghani Sheikh.
Solution
Guidance: While watching, note scenes of coexistence, discrimination or violence on account of religious identity, and how the characters respond. Link them to the chapter: opposition to inter-religious domination, equal dignity of all communities and the need for the state to protect basic freedoms. Write a short note of your own on each.
Margin: I thought treating everyone in exactly the same way is not always fair!
Solution
Yes. The chapter shows this by the examples of the train compartment, where voting is fair for ordinary preferences but not when a passenger has a vital need (an asthma patient and smoke), and of the auditorium with a staircase, where a ramp or lift is needed. Real equality sometimes requires different arrangements for people in different circumstances, which is why minority rights are not special privileges but means of equal respect and dignity.
Margin: How can a State treat all religions equally? Would granting equal number of holidays to each religion help? Or would banning any religious ceremony on public occasions be a way of doing this?
Solution
Sample answer: Neither is enough by itself. Counting holidays gives symbolic equality but may not remove domination or secure rights. Banning all religious ceremonies on public occasions would be a form of non-interference like that of the western model, but it is not required by Indian secularism, which follows principled distance. The chapter says that the phrase "equal respect for all religions" does not capture Indian secularism. A state treats religions equally by having no state religion, protecting the freedom and equality of individuals and minorities within and between religions, and not giving a religious reason for public policy; the holiday list (below) is one way of showing even-handed recognition.
Read out the list of gazetted holidays in India. Does it uphold the case of Secularism in India? Give your arguments.
Solution
The list for 2019 has 17 holidays. National: Republic Day (26 January), Independence Day (15 August) and Mahatma Gandhi's Birthday (2 October). Hindu: Maha Shivaratri, Holi, Janmashtami, Dussehra, Diwali. Muslim: Id-ul-Fitr, Id-ul-Zuha (Bakrid), Muharram, Milad-un-Nabi. Christian: Good Friday, Christmas Day. Jain: Mahavir Jayanti. Buddhist: Buddha Purnima. Sikh: Guru Nanak's Birthday.
Sample answer: The list supports the case for secularism in India to a large extent, since holidays are given for festivals of many religions and for national days, and no one religion is declared the state religion. It reflects the state's even-handed engagement with religious diversity rather than strict exclusion of religion. A critic may say that some religions have more holidays than others, but equal numbers are not the test; what matters is the freedom and equality of all.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered