NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Political Theory · Chapter 7
Chapter 7: Nationalism (Nationalism)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Political Theory Chapter 7: Nationalism (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on nations, self-determination, the factors behind nationalism and its limits, plus the in-text questions. All 12 questions are answered in full.
How is a nation different from other forms of collective belonging?
Solution
A nation is not a casual collection of people, and it differs from other groups in these ways:
It differs from the family, which is based on face-to-face relationships where each member has direct personal knowledge of the others.
It differs from tribes, clans and other kinship groups, in which ties of marriage and descent link members, so that even if we do not know all the members we can trace the links. In a nation we may never meet most fellow nationals and need not share ties of descent with them.
A nation is largely an "imagined" community, held together by the collective beliefs, aspirations and imaginations of its members. It rests on shared beliefs, a sense of continuing history, identification with a territory or homeland, shared political ideals, and a common political identity.
Unlike other groups, a nation also has a shared vision of the future and the aspiration to have an independent political existence, which distinguishes it from other groups.
What do you understand by the right to national self-determination? How has this idea resulted in both formation of and challenges to nation-states?
Solution
Nations seek the right to govern themselves and determine their future development. This is the right to national self-determination: a nation seeks recognition by the international community of its status as a distinct political entity or state. Such claims come most often from people who have lived together on a given land for a long time with a sense of common identity, and sometimes from a wish to form a state that protects, if not privileges, their culture.
Formation of nation-states. In nineteenth century Europe the idea of "one culture - one state" gained acceptance, and small kingdoms were united into larger nation-states such as Germany and Italy; new states were founded in Latin America. After World War I the idea was used to reorder boundaries, and the Treaty of Versailles established a number of small, newly independent states. National liberation movements in Asia and Africa also asserted the right when struggling against colonial rule, and nationalism helped to break up empires: Austro-Hungarian, Russian, and the British, French, Dutch and Portuguese empires.
Challenges. It was virtually impossible to satisfy all demands. Reorganising boundaries led to mass migration, millions were displaced or expelled from their homes, and many became victims of communal violence. Most new states still had minorities, often disadvantaged. In the colonies, migration, border wars and violence continued, and nation-states that won independence by struggle now acted against minorities claiming self-determination. Even stable states face separatist movements, such as the Quebecois in Canada, the Basques in Spain, the Kurds in Turkey and Iraq and the Tamils in Sri Lanka. The right has now been reinterpreted as the grant of certain democratic rights for a nationality within a state.
"We have seen that nationalism can unite people as well as divide them, liberate them as well as generate bitterness and conflict". Illustrate your answer with examples.
Solution
United people: in nineteenth century Europe nationalism united small kingdoms into larger nation-states; the present German and Italian states were formed through unification. Local dialects and loyalties were consolidated into state loyalties and common languages, and a similar process of consolidation took place in India. Arab nationalism hopes to unite Arab countries in a pan Arab union.
Divided people: nationalism contributed to the break-up of the Austro-Hungarian and Russian empires, and today separatist movements of the Quebecois in Canada, the Basques in Spain, the Kurds in Turkey and Iraq and the Tamils in Sri Lanka threaten to divide existing states.
Liberated people: the struggle for freedom from colonial rule by India and other former colonies were nationalist struggles that broke up the British, French, Dutch and Portuguese empires in Asia and Africa and brought independence, dignity and recognition.
Generated bitterness and conflict: redrawing of state boundaries on the "one culture - one state" idea after World War I caused mass migration, expulsion of millions from the land that had been their home for generations and communal violence; in Asia and Africa migrations, border wars and violence continue. Nationalism has inspired intense loyalties as well as deep hatreds and has been the cause of wars.
Neither descent, nor language, nor religion or ethnicity can claim to be a common factor in nationalisms all over the world. Comment.
Solution
The statement is correct. It is commonly believed that nations are constituted by a group sharing features such as descent, language, religion or ethnicity. But the chapter says there is no common set of characteristics present in all nations.
Language: many nations do not have a common language. Canada includes English-speaking and French-speaking peoples, and India has a large number of languages spoken in different regions and by different communities.
Religion: many nations have no common religion to unite them. In addition, all major religions are internally diverse, with sects that differ significantly, so an identity forged on common religion would create an authoritarian and oppressive society.
Race or descent: the same holds for other characteristics such as race or descent; members of a nation may never meet and need not share ties of descent.
What binds a nation is instead shared belief, a sense of continuing history, a territory, and, above all, shared political ideals such as democracy, secularism and liberalism. Imposing a single religious or linguistic identity would exclude some groups and limit equal treatment and liberty, so democratic nations should be imagined in political, not cultural, terms.
Illustrate with suitable examples the factors that lead to the emergence of nationalist feelings.
Solution
The chapter identifies the following elements, which give rise to the belief that people form a nation:
Shared beliefs: a nation exists when its members believe that they belong together, like members of a team who think of themselves as a collective group.
History: a sense of continuing historical identity drawn from collective memories, legends and records. Indian nationalists invoked India's ancient civilisation and cultural heritage; Nehru wrote in The Discovery of India of a "tremendous impress of oneness".
Territory: living together on a land gives a sense of a homeland, such as motherland, fatherland or holy land. The Jewish people, though dispersed, claimed Palestine as their "promised land", and the Indian nation identifies with the rivers, mountains and regions of the subcontinent.
Shared political ideals: a shared vision of the kind of state to build, based on values such as democracy, secularism and liberalism.
Common political identity and the wish for independent political existence, as seen in struggles against colonial rule and separatist demands. Cultural features such as language, religion, festivals and symbols may also bring people together.
How is a democracy more effective than authoritarian governments in dealing with conflicting nationalist aspirations?
Solution
The chapter argues that the solution to conflicting nationalist claims lies not in creating new states but in making existing states more democratic and equal, so that people of different cultural and ethnic identities live as partners and equal citizens. A democracy does this better for these reasons:
It defines national identity in political terms, as loyalty to shared values in the Constitution, not to a single religion, race or language, so that all groups can feel part of the nation.
It can recognise and protect minorities, through group rights such as constitutional protection for language, culture and religion, and sometimes representation in legislatures. The Indian Constitution has an elaborate set of provisions for this.
It treats citizens as equals and allows them to express many identities, so groups feel less need to demand a separate state. It can negotiate demands with generosity and skill.
A state that does not respect the rights and cultural identity of minorities finds it difficult to win their loyalty. Authoritarian suppression, such as the ban on the Basque language in public places and homes under the Spanish dictator Franco, leaves lasting suspicion: even after these measures were withdrawn, the leaders of the Basque movement remain suspicious of the government.
Democracy therefore accommodates differences by dialogue, rights and equal citizenship, where authoritarian rule tends to impose a single identity by force.
What do you think are the limitations of nationalism?
Solution
Sample answer, based on the chapter:
It can divide as well as unite, and generate hatred, conflict, bitterness and wars. It has inspired intense loyalties but also deep hatreds.
Demands for self-determination and separate states lead to the drawing and redrawing of boundaries, mass migrations, displacement and communal violence; it is impossible and undesirable to give every group its own state, since states could be too small to be viable and the problems of minorities would multiply.
It can become narrow, intolerant and homogenising. A single religious or linguistic identity excludes groups and limits liberty and equal treatment; Tagore criticised narrow expressions of nationalism and refused to let patriotism triumph over humanity.
Nation-states that won freedom by struggle may act against minorities within their own territory.
Identity claims can lead to divisions and violence, though each person has many identities (gender, caste, religion, language, region) and a democracy should encompass them all.
Margin: In this age of globalisation, the world is shrinking. We are living in a global village. Nations are irrelevant. That's not the case. Nationalism is still relevant. You can see this when Indian team goes out to play cricket. Or when you discover that Indians living abroad still watch Bollywood films.
Solution
Sample answer: Nationalism is still relevant. The chapter says it remains a powerful force even today, that a large part of the world is divided into nation-states, and that separatist and nationalist struggles continue even in an age of globalisation. Cheering for the national cricket team or Indians abroad keeping up their culture show feelings of belonging to a nation. At the same time, global links such as the internet and trade are real, and the two exist side by side.
Let's do it: Identify any patriotic song in your language. How is the nation described in this song? Identify and watch any patriotic films in your language. How has nationalism been portrayed and its complexities worked out in these films?
Solution
Guidance: Choose a patriotic song and note whether the nation is described as a motherland, a land of rivers and mountains, a history or a set of ideals. For the film, note how patriotism, sacrifice, the diversity of the country and conflicts of loyalty are shown. Compare with the chapter: homeland, shared history, shared beliefs and political ideals.
Margin: "Why don't you cheer for our team? Don't you have any nationalist spirit?" "I am as much a nationalist as anyone else. I cast my vote; I pay my taxes and I respect the laws of our country. I am also proud to belong to this country."
Solution
Sample answer: The reply fits the chapter, which says that obligations arising from recognition of the rights of fellow citizens are the strongest test of loyalty to the nation, so voting, paying taxes and obeying laws are real expressions of nationalism. Cheering for the team is one way of showing it, but it is not the only way, and no one should be called less nationalist for not cheering.
Demand for national self-determination in Basque: Do you think Basque nationalists are justified in demanding a separate nation? Is Basque a nation? What more would you like to know before you can answer this question? Can you think of similar examples from different parts of the world? Can you think of regions and groups in our country where such demands have been made?
Solution
Facts from the chapter: Basque is a hilly, prosperous region of Spain recognised as an autonomous region within the Spanish federation; its nationalists want a separate country. They say their culture and language (understood now by only one-third of the people there) differ from Spanish culture, the hilly terrain makes the region distinct, it never surrendered its autonomy since Roman days, and its justice, administration and finance had their own arrangements. The modern movement began at the end of the nineteenth century when Spanish rulers tried to abolish these arrangements, and the dictator Franco cut autonomy further and banned the Basque language in public places and homes. These measures are withdrawn, but the leaders remain suspicious; opponents say the separatists seek political gains from a resolved issue.
Sample answer: Basque has several features of a nation, such as its own language, history, territory and a belief that it belongs together, so it can be called a nation in that sense. But the chapter says the solution to such claims lies in more democratic and equal states, and granting autonomy and protection to minorities. Before judging, I would like to know how many Basque people want separation, how far the language and culture are now protected, the economic effects, and the views of other people living in the region.
Similar examples named in the chapter: the Quebecois in Canada, the Kurds in Turkey and Iraq, and the Tamils in Sri Lanka. In our country, the chapter says some groups also use the language of nationalism; you can name regions in India from newspapers where such demands have been made.
Let's do it: Cut out clippings from various newspapers and magazines related to the demands of various groups in India and abroad for the right to self-determination. Form an opinion about the following: What are the reasons behind these demands? What strategies have they employed? Are their claims justified? What do you think could be the possible solution?
Solution
Guidance: For each clipping note the group, the reasons (such as culture, language, neglect, history), the strategies (constitutional and peaceful means, or violence), and your judgement. The chapter suggests that the possible solution is to make states more democratic and equal and to give recognition and group protection, such as protection for language, culture and religion and representation, to the groups concerned.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered