NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Political Theory · Chapter 2
Chapter 2: Freedom (Freedom)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Political Theory Chapter 2: Freedom (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on the ideal of freedom, constraints, the harm principle, negative and positive liberty and freedom of expression, plus the in-text questions. All 11 questions are answered in full.
What is meant by freedom? Is there a relationship between freedom for the individual and freedom for the nation?
Solution
Meaning of freedom. In the simple sense, freedom is the absence of constraints. It exists when external constraints on the individual are absent, so that the person is not subject to external controls or coercion and can take independent decisions and act in an autonomous way. But this is only one dimension. Freedom is also about expanding the ability of people to express themselves freely and develop their potential, creativity and capabilities. A free society is one that enables all its members to develop their potential with the minimum of social constraints. Freedom is valuable because it allows us to make choices and use our judgement. The Indian concept analogous to freedom is Swaraj (Swa = self, Raj = rule), which means both the rule of the self and rule over self.
Relationship between individual freedom and national freedom. Yes, they are closely connected.
The struggle for freedom represents the desire of people to be in control of their own lives and destinies. Not just individuals but societies also value their independence and wish to protect their culture and future.
Nelson Mandela's Long Walk to Freedom was a struggle to remove the obstacles to the freedom of all the people of South Africa, and Aung San Suu Kyi saw her freedom as connected with the freedom of her people.
Swaraj in the freedom struggle of India meant freedom as a constitutional and political demand and as a value at the social-collective level, as in Tilak's "Swaraj is my birth right and I shall have it". Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose spoke of all-round freedom, for the individual as well as for society.
The principles used to distinguish necessary from unnecessary constraints also apply to the relationship between individuals, groups and nations. An individual's freedom is not secure if the nation is dominated by outsiders, and a nation is not truly free if its individuals are oppressed.
What is the difference between the negative and positive conception of liberty?
Solution
Point
Negative liberty
Positive liberty
Meaning
Freedom as the absence of external constraints; an area of non-interference in which the individual can do, be or become whatever he or she wishes.
Freedom as the expansion of opportunities and conditions in which the individual can develop capabilities and express himself or herself.
Idea
"Freedom from".
"Freedom to".
Question answered
"Over what area am I the master?"
"Who governs me?", to which the ideal answer is "I govern myself".
Concern
Defends a minimum area that is sacred, which no external authority can interfere with. The bigger this area, the more the freedom, though it has to keep in mind the stability of society.
Looks at the relationship between individual and society and improves conditions (material, political and social) so that fewer constraints stand in the way of development. Freedom is possible only in society.
Requirements
No interference in this inviolable area.
Freedom from poverty and unemployment, adequate material resources, participation in decision making, and education.
Thinkers
Called the negative liberty tradition; the freedom of expression, defended by J.S. Mill, is considered part of this minimum area of non-interference.
Traced to Rousseau, Hegel, Marx, Gandhi, Aurobindo and others.
Generally both go together and support each other, but tyrants can sometimes justify their rule by invoking arguments of positive liberty.
What is meant by social constraints? Are constraints of any kind necessary for enjoying freedom?
Solution
Social constraints are limits on the freedom of individuals imposed by society, that is by the laws of government, rules, social authority or the structure of society. The chapter says that restrictions may come from domination and external controls, imposed by force or by a government through laws backed by force, as with colonial rulers or apartheid in South Africa. They can also arise from social inequality, such as the caste system, and from extreme economic inequality.
Are some constraints necessary? Yes.
No individual living in society can hope to enjoy a total absence of constraints. We cannot live in a world with no constraints, or society would descend into chaos. People differ in ideas and opinions, have conflicting ambitions and compete for scarce resources, so every society needs some mechanisms to control violence and settle disputes.
Some constraints free us from insecurity and provide the conditions for self-development.
In order to live freely, we need to respect the differences of views, opinions and beliefs. Where one group tries to impose its views by force or to bully others, law and political restraints are needed so that differences can be discussed without coercion.
The important question is which constraints are necessary and justifiable and which are not. The "harm principle" and "reasonable restrictions" help to decide this.
What is the role of the state in upholding freedom of its citizens?
Solution
From the chapter, the state has these roles:
Preventing harm to others. According to the harm principle of J.S. Mill, the state can constrain a person only from actions that cause serious harm to others, and should not interfere in self-regarding actions. In this way the state protects the freedom of each person from the harmful actions of others.
Controlling violence and settling disputes, and making sure that differences can be debated without one group coercively imposing its views on another, with legal support where needed.
Imposing only reasonable restrictions. The constraints must be defensible by reason and not excessive or out of proportion to the action restricted. The state must not develop a habit of imposing restrictions, since that is harmful to freedom. For example, banning books is an easy solution but harmful for the long-term freedom of society.
Creating positive conditions. A free society widens the area in which people can chart their destiny. The state should help to provide material resources, a chance to take part in decision making and education, so that people are not constrained by poverty and unemployment.
Being democratic. If the government is democratic, the members of the state retain some control over their rulers, and so democratic government is an important means of protecting the freedom of people.
The state itself can also be a source of constraint, as shown by colonial rule and apartheid, so its power has to be limited.
What is meant by freedom of expression? What in your view would be a reasonable restriction on this freedom? Give examples.
Solution
Meaning. Freedom of expression is the freedom to hold and express one's views and opinions, including freedom of thought and discussion, in speech, writing, books, plays, films and so on. It is considered to belong to the minimum area of non-interference, and the society must be willing to bear some inconvenience to protect it. Voltaire's statement sums it up: "I disapprove of what you say but I will defend to death your right to say it". J.S. Mill gave four reasons: (1) no idea is completely false, and a banned "false" idea may have an element of truth; (2) truth emerges only through the conflict of opposing views; (3) this conflict is of continuing value, because truth exposed to opposing views is trustworthy and does not become an unthinking cliche; (4) we cannot be sure what we consider true is actually true, since ideas once suppressed have later turned out to be true.
Reasonable restrictions (sample answer). In India the term used for justifiable constraints is "reasonable restrictions", which must be capable of being defended by reason and proportionate to the action.
A hate campaign that foments hatred against a group causes serious harm to the freedom of others, so some constraint is justified. But the chapter says the restriction should not be severe: not life imprisonment for conducting a hate campaign, but perhaps some restriction on movement or on the right to hold public meetings, especially if the campaign continues in spite of warnings by the state.
Speech which puts people in danger can be restricted.
Minor harm, such as the inconvenience of loud music in an apartment building, should invite only social disapproval, and not the force of law.
Banning books or films after the protests of some groups, as in the cases of The Satanic Verses and Ramayana Retold, is an easy short-term solution but harms the long-term prospects of freedom, since a habit of banning develops.
Do only great men and women fight for great principles like freedom? What does this principle mean to me?
Solution
Sample answer: No. Great persons such as Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi are well known, but ordinary people have also struggled against domination. The chapter says human history provides many examples of heroic struggles of communities against domination. Freedom means to me the ability to take my own decisions about my studies and my life, speak my mind without fear, and to have opportunities to develop my talents, while respecting others' freedom.
Let's do it: Can you think of someone in your village, town or district who has struggled for his/her own freedom or the freedom of others? Write a short note about that person and the particular aspect of freedom which he/she struggled to protect.
Solution
Guidance: Choose a person known to you, such as a social worker who fought against caste discrimination or for the education of girls, a person who stood up for the rights of villagers, or a freedom fighter of your town. In 4 or 5 lines say who the person is, what the person did, which freedom was at stake (for example freedom from fear, freedom of expression, equal treatment, or the opportunity to study) and what it cost the person. Like Mandela and Aung San Suu Kyi in the chapter, such persons struggle for the freedom of a whole group and not only for themselves.
Let's debate: Girls and boys should be free to decide whom they wish to marry. Parents should have no say in this matter.
Solution
Guidance for the debate: For: liberalism, as the chapter says, focuses on the individual, and the decision to marry someone should be taken by the individual rather than by the family, caste or community. Choice of one's partner belongs to the self-regarding area, where under the harm principle no outside authority should interfere. Freedom is valuable because it allows choices to be made and judgement to be used. Against: parents have a stake in the happiness of their children and can advise, and the chapter notes that children need to be placed in the care of parents until they build their capacity to choose wisely. A balanced position is that parents may advise and be consulted, but the final decision rests with the individuals concerned.
Why does he talk about `mankind'? What about women?
Solution
Mill uses "mankind" in the old sense of humanity. Taken in this way, the harm principle applies equally to women and men: the only purpose for which power can rightfully be exercised over any member of a civilised community, against his or her will, is to prevent harm to others. The question of the margin is a fair one, since the wording of the time often left women out, and the principle should be applied without distinction between men and women.
Let's think: The Issue of Dress Code. If choosing what to wear is an expression of one's freedom then how should we look at the following situations where there are restrictions on dress? In China during Mao's regime all the people had to wear `Mao suits' based on the argument that it was an expression of equality. A fatwa was issued against Sania Mirza for her style of dress that was considered, by one cleric, to be against the dress code prescribed for women. The rules of a test match in cricket require every cricketer to wear white dress. Students are required to wear school uniforms. Let us debate some questions. Is the restriction on what to wear justified in all cases or only in some? When does it constitute a constraint on freedom? Who has the authority to impose these constraints? Should religious leaders be given the authority to issue decrees on dress? Can the state decide what one should wear? Should the ICC set down rules of what to wear when playing cricket? Is the imposition excessive? Does it diminish the many ways, people have of expressing themselves? What are the consequences of accepting the impositions? Will the society become `equal' if everyone dresses the same way as in Maoist China? Or are women being denied the participation in sports if they cannot wear clothes that would help them to compete effectively? Will the game be affected if cricketers wear coloured clothes?
Solution
Sample answer: Restrictions on dress are not justified in all cases, only where there is a good reason and where people are not coerced.
Mao suits. A compulsory dress for all people, imposed by the state, is an excessive constraint. Equality is not achieved by making everyone dress alike, and it denies people their way of expressing themselves.
Fatwa on Sania Mirza. A religious leader has no authority to impose a dress code on a person. It is an unjustified constraint, since dress is a choice in the self-regarding area, and it also denies a woman the clothes that help her to compete effectively in sports. The harm principle says that the state or other authority may interfere only to prevent harm to others, and her dress harms no one.
Cricket whites. This is a rule of a game, which players accept willingly for the sake of pursuing their goals as sportspersons. The chapter says that if we willingly accept certain restrictions to pursue our goals and are not coerced, then our freedom is not curtailed. The rule is justified, and it does not significantly affect the game, though coloured clothes are used in other formats.
School uniforms. Uniforms are accepted by the school community for discipline and equality among students, and the restriction is reasonable and limited to the school. It is not an excessive imposition.
In general, a restriction is acceptable when it is reasonable, limited, has a clear purpose and is accepted by those concerned, and it is not acceptable when imposed by force by an authority on private matters.
Do we have the freedom to destroy our environment?
Solution
Sample answer: No. Under the harm principle, freedom covers self-regarding actions, but destroying the environment is an other-regarding action, since it causes harm to others, including other people and future generations. The chapter says that the state can constrain actions that cause serious harm to definite individuals. So freedom does not include the freedom to destroy the environment, and restrictions on it are justified.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
All NCERT exercises solved
Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF