Constitution as a Living Document Class 11 Question Answer | NCERT Political Science Chapter 9 Solutions Skip to content
Smart Notes for Every Exam · instant PDF download after payment +91 92520 37565
NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Political Science · NCERT Indian Constitution at Work and Political Theory Indian Constitution at Work · Chapter 9

Chapter 9: Constitution as a Living Document (Constitution: Living Document)

NCERT solutions for Class 11 Political Science Indian Constitution at Work Chapter 9: Constitution as a Living Document (2026-27). Answers to all exercises on amendment procedure, special majority, the basic structure theory and the 42nd amendment, plus the in-text questions. All 15 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.

NCERT textbook Chapter 9 (PDF)

Exam revision? Chapter 9 notes with key points, diagrams and practice questions: see the free sample · US$2.99 for all 18 chapters

Free NCERT solutions by Notes Bazar · www.notesbazar.in/ncert-solutions/class-11-polsci/constitution-as-a-living-document

Exercises

1
Choose the correct statement from the following.
A constitution needs to be amended from time to time because,
  1. Circumstances change and require suitable changes in the constitution.
  2. A document written at one point of time becomes outdated after some time.
  3. Every generation should have a constitution of its own liking.
  4. It must reflect the philosophy of the existing government.
Solution

(a) and (b) are correct.

  • (a) Correct: the chapter says that no constitution can provide for all eventualities, and that a constitution has to respond to the challenges that arise in the future as society changes.
  • (b) Correct: a document written at one point of time reflects the problems of that time, and with changes in society it may need revisions, changes and re-examination. A constitution is not a frozen and unalterable document.
  • (c) Not correct: the Constitution is placed above ordinary law and future generations are expected to respect it. It is not meant to be changed to suit the taste of each generation.
  • (d) Not correct: the Constitution is a framework for democratic governance, not an expression of the philosophy of the government of the day. Amendments need wide consensus precisely so that a ruling party cannot rewrite it for itself.

Correct: (a) and (b)

2
Write True / False against the following statements.
  1. The President cannot send back an amendment bill for reconsideration of Parliament.
  2. Elected representatives alone have the power to amend the Constitution.
  3. The Judiciary cannot initiate the process of constitutional amendment but can effectively change the Constitution by interpreting it differently.
  4. Parliament can amend any section of the Constitution.
Solution
  1. True. An amendment bill, like other bills, goes to the President for assent, but in this case the President has no power to send it back for reconsideration.
  2. True. Only elected representatives (Parliament, and for some articles half of the State legislatures) can take the final decisions on amendments. No outside agency like a constitution commission or a referendum is needed. This is parliamentary sovereignty.
  3. True. Amendments can be initiated only in Parliament, but the judiciary, through its interpretations, as in the basic structure theory, has practically amended the Constitution without a formal amendment.
  4. True, within one limit. After the Kesavananda Bharati ruling, Parliament can amend any and all parts of the Constitution, but no amendment can violate the basic structure of the Constitution.

a True, b True, c True, d True (subject to the basic structure)

3
Which of the following are involved in the amendment of the Indian Constitution? In what way are they involved?
  1. Voters
  2. President of India
  3. State Legislatures
  4. Parliament
  5. Governors
  6. Judiciary
Solution
  1. Voters: not directly involved. No referendum is required for ratification of an amendment. They take part only indirectly, through the representatives they elect.
  2. President: involved, but only formally. The amendment bill goes to the President for assent, but the President has no power to send it back for reconsideration.
  3. State Legislatures: involved in some cases. For amendments to articles about the distribution of powers between the States and the Centre, or about representation, the bill must also be passed by the legislatures of half the States, by a simple majority in each.
  4. Parliament: the main actor. All amendments are initiated only in Parliament. Each amendment bill must pass in both Houses separately by a special majority (at least half of the total strength of the House and two-thirds of the members present and voting). For many articles a simple law of Parliament is enough.
  5. Governors: not involved. The Constitution gives them no role in amendments.
  6. Judiciary: not involved in the process of amending, because it cannot initiate or pass an amendment. But through interpretation, and by deciding whether an amendment violates the basic structure, it has an important effect on what amendments are valid.

Involved: Parliament, President (assent), State legislatures (some amendments); not directly: voters, Governors, Judiciary

4
You have read in this chapter that the 42nd amendment was one of the most controversial amendments so far. Which of the following were the reasons for this controversy?
  1. It was made during national emergency, and the declaration of that emergency was itself controversial.
  2. It was made without the support of special majority.
  3. It was made without ratification by State legislatures.
  4. It contained provisions, which were controversial.
Solution

(a) and (d) are the reasons.

  • (a) The 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments were made against the background of the internal emergency declared from June 1975, and many MPs of the opposition parties were in jail when the 42nd amendment was passed. The opposition saw these amendments as attempts by the ruling party to subvert the Constitution.
  • (d) The 42nd amendment affected large parts of the Constitution (it changed the Preamble, the Seventh Schedule and 53 articles), tried to override the Supreme Court's ruling in the Kesavananda case, extended the duration of the Lok Sabha from five to six years, and put restrictions on the review powers of the judiciary.
  • (b) and (c) are not given in the chapter as reasons for the controversy. The chapter does not say that the amendment lacked a special majority or the ratification of the States.

Reasons: (a) and (d)

5
Which of the following is not a reasonable explanation of the conflict between the legislature and the judiciary over different amendments?
  1. Different interpretations of the Constitution are possible.
  2. In a democracy, debates and differences are natural.
  3. Constitution has given higher importance to certain rules and principles and also allowed for amendment by special majority.
  4. Legislature cannot be entrusted to protect the rights of the citizens.
  5. Judiciary can only decide the constitutionality of a particular law; cannot resolve political debates about its need.
Solution

(d) is not a reasonable explanation.

The chapter explains the conflict by the possibility of different interpretations of the Constitution, by the fact that democratic politics naturally has debates and differences, by the dual nature of the Constitution (some principles are more basic, yet amendment by special majority is allowed), and by the limited role of the judiciary in deciding the constitutionality of a law and not the political question of its need. It never says that the legislature cannot be trusted with the rights of citizens. The legislature is the body of the elected representatives of the people, and the amending power rests with it, so (d) is not an explanation of the conflict but a doubtful claim.

Not a reasonable explanation: (d)

6
Identify the correct statements about the theory of basic structure. Correct the incorrect statements.
  1. Constitution specifies the basic tenets.
  2. Legislature can amend all parts of the Constitution except the basic structure.
  3. Judiciary has defined which aspects of the Constitution can be termed as the basic structure and which cannot.
  4. This theory found its first expression in the Kesavananda Bharati case and has been discussed in subsequent judgments.
  5. This theory has increased the powers of the judiciary and has come to be accepted by different political parties and the government.
Solution
  1. Incorrect. Correct statement: The Constitution does not mention the basic structure at all, and does not say what is part of it. The theory is the invention of the judiciary, which came from interpretation.
  2. Correct. Parliament can amend any and all parts of the Constitution within the limitation that no amendment can violate the basic structure.
  3. Incorrect. Correct statement: The judiciary has not made a complete list of the basic structure. Since 1973 the Court has in many cases elaborated upon the theory and given instances of what constitutes the basic structure, and it is the final authority on whether an amendment violates it.
  4. Correct. The Supreme Court advanced the theory in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), and later cases such as Minerva Mills (1980) have repeated and developed it.
  5. Correct. The theory has placed the judiciary as the final authority on whether an amendment violates the basic structure, and over the past four decades it has been accepted by political parties, the government and Parliament, and all institutions.

Correct: (b), (d), (e). Incorrect: (a), (c)

7
From the information that many amendments were made during 2000-2003, which of the following conclusions would you draw?
  1. Judiciary did not interfere in the amendments made during this period.
  2. One political party had a strong majority during this period.
  3. There was strong pressure from the pubic in favour of certain amendments.
  4. There were no real differences among the parties during this time.
  5. The amendments were of a non-controversial nature and parties had an agreement on the subject of amendments.
Solution

(e) is the right conclusion.

The chapter says that the period 2001-2003, when ten amendments were made in three years, was marked by coalition politics, with different parties in power in different States and bitter rivalry between the BJP and its opponents. Yet so many amendments were passed. Since an amendment needs a special majority in both Houses, this could only happen because the amendments were non-controversial and there was agreement among the parties on them. The chapter says that many of the amendments of this period reflected an evolving consensus on certain issues.

  • (b) is wrong: it was a period of coalition politics, not a single-party majority (unlike 1974-76).
  • (d) is wrong: the parties were rivals, as the chapter says.
  • (a) and (c) cannot be concluded from the information given.

Conclusion: (e)

8
Explain the reason for requiring special majority for amending the Constitution.
Solution

An ordinary law needs only a simple majority of the members present and voting. An amendment needs a special majority: those voting for it must be at least half of the total strength of the House and also at least two-thirds of those present and voting, in each House separately. The reasons are:

  1. The Constitution is above ordinary law and has to be protected from frequent and unnecessary changes. The special majority makes it rigid enough to guard against easy tampering.
  2. A party with a thin majority can pass ordinary laws and the budget even if the opposition does not agree, but to amend the Constitution it must take at least some opposition parties into confidence. The amendment must be based on broad support among the political parties and parliamentarians.
  3. It ensures that amendments reflect a wide consensus and are not the wish of the ruling party alone. Dr. Ambedkar said that if those dissatisfied with the Constitution cannot obtain even a two-thirds majority, their dissatisfaction cannot be taken to be shared by the general public.

At the same time, the procedure is not impracticable, so the Constitution can be amended when real needs arise.

9
Many amendments to the Constitution of India have been made due to different interpretations upheld by the Judiciary and Parliament. Explain with examples.
Solution

The chapter explains that a number of amendments are the product of different interpretations of the Constitution by the judiciary and the government of the day. When they clashed, Parliament inserted an amendment underlining one interpretation as the authentic one. It is a normal part of democratic politics that various institutions interpret the Constitution, particularly the scope of their own powers, in different ways.

  1. Fundamental rights and Directive Principles, right to private property and the amending power. The judiciary and Parliament differed on the relationship between fundamental rights and directive principles, on the scope of the right to private property, and on the scope of Parliament's power to amend the Constitution. In the period 1970-75 Parliament repeatedly made amendments to overcome the adverse interpretations of the judiciary.
  2. The Kesavananda Bharati case (1973). The Supreme Court ruled that no amendment can violate the basic structure of the Constitution. Some attempts were made to ask the Court to reconsider the ruling, and when they failed, the 42nd amendment was made to assert parliamentary supremacy and to override the ruling. The Court repeated its stand in the Minerva Mills case (1980).
  3. Reservation. The Supreme Court held that reservations in jobs and educational institutions cannot exceed fifty per cent of the total seats, and introduced the idea of the creamy layer for OBCs, which are informal changes by interpretation.

The 43rd and 44th amendments of the later government cancelled most of the changes of the 38th, 39th and 42nd amendments and restored the constitutional balance.

10
If amending power is with the elected representatives, judiciary should NOT have the power to decide the validity of amendments. Do you agree? Give your reasons in 100 words.
Solution

Sample answer: I do not agree. Elected representatives are supreme in amending the Constitution, but only within the Constitution, since Parliament gets its powers from it. The Kesavananda Bharati ruling accepted that Parliament may amend any part, but not violate the basic structure, and made the judiciary the final authority on that. Without this check, a party with a large majority could change the very features that make India a democracy, as the controversy over the 42nd amendment showed. Democracy is as much about checks on the arbitrary use of power as about the well-being of the people. The judiciary only checks the limits and does not take over the amending power.

In-text questions

1
Check your progress: After reading the section above, a number of students in the class were confused. They made the following statements. What would you say about each of these statements?
  • The Constitution is like any other law. It simply tells us what are the rules and regulations governing the government.
  • The Constitution is the expression of the will of the people, so there must be a provision to change the Constitution after every ten or fifteen years.
  • The Constitution is a statement of the philosophy of the country. It can never be changed.
  • The Constitution is a sacred document. Therefore any talk of changing it is against democracy.
Solution
  1. Wrong. The makers placed the Constitution above ordinary law. It is the framework of democratic governance and also reflects the dreams and aspirations of the society, so it is more than an ordinary law, and it is amended by a different and more difficult procedure.
  2. Wrong. The Constitution should not be changed at fixed intervals. It must be protected from unnecessary and frequent changes, and be amended whenever the need arises. No fixed period is set by the makers.
  3. Wrong. It is not a frozen and unalterable document. It is made by human beings and may need revisions, changes and re-examination. The Indian Constitution is not unalterable, although its basic structure cannot be changed.
  4. Wrong. The Constitution is both a sacred document and an instrument that may require changes. Talk of changing it is not against democracy, since the Constitution itself provides the procedure of amendment and thus accepts the necessity of changes.
2
Check your progress: For making the following amendments to the Constitution of India, what conditions need to be fulfilled? Place a tick mark in the chart wherever applicable.
Subject of amendmentSpecial majorityRatification by States
Citizenship clause
Right to freedom of religion
Changes in the Union List
Changes in State boundaries
Provision regarding Election Commission
Solution
Subject of amendmentSpecial majorityRatification by States
Citizenship clauseno (simple majority, by law)no
Right to freedom of religiontickno
Changes in the Union Listticktick
Changes in State boundariesno (simple majority, by law)no
Provision regarding Election Commissiontickno
  • State boundaries: Articles 2 and 3 say Parliament may by law admit new States or increase the area of a State, so a simple law of Parliament is enough.
  • Citizenship: Article 11 of the Constitution empowers Parliament to make laws on citizenship, so it too can be regulated by an ordinary law (this point is not in the chapter).
  • Freedom of religion (a fundamental right) needs the special majority of Article 368 in both Houses, but does not affect the powers of the States.
  • Changes in the Union List alter the distribution of powers between the Centre and States, so they need both the special majority and the ratification by the legislatures of half the States.
  • The Election Commission provision requires the special majority only, as it is not about the distribution of powers or representation of the States.
3
In the Lok Sabha there are 545 members. Therefore, any amendment must be supported by a minimum of 273 members. Even if only 300 members are present at the time of voting, the amendment bill must get the support of 273 out of them. But imagine that 400 members of Lok Sabha have voted on an amendment bill. How many members should support the bill to get the bill passed?
Solution

Two conditions have to be met together.

  1. Supporters must be at least half of the total strength of the House: 273 (as given in the chapter for 545 members).
  2. Supporters must also be at least two-thirds of those voting: two-thirds of 400 = 266.67, so at least 267.

To satisfy both, the larger figure applies, so the bill needs at least 273 votes in favour.

At least 273 members

4
Check your progress: State whether the following statements are correct or not:
  • After the Basic Structure ruling, Parliament does not have power to amend the Constitution.
  • The Supreme Court has given a clear list of the basic features of our Constitution, which cannot be amended.
  • Judiciary has the power to decide whether an amendment violates basic structure or not.
  • The Kesavananda Bharati ruling has set clear limits on Parliament's power to amend the Constitution.
Solution
  1. Not correct. Parliament can amend any and all parts of the Constitution, within the limit that no amendment can violate the basic structure.
  2. Not correct. The Constitution does not list the basic structure and the Court has not given a complete list. Since 1973 it has given instances in various cases.
  3. Correct. The ruling places the judiciary as the final authority in deciding whether an amendment violates the basic structure and what constitutes it.
  4. Correct. It has set the limit that no amendment can violate the basic structure of the Constitution.
5
Activity: Find out the amendments about the right to education (RTE) and the Goods and Services Tax (GST). What do you think is the importance of these amendments?
Solution

Guidance: The right to education was made a Fundamental Right by the 86th Amendment (2002), which inserted Article 21A, making education free and compulsory for children aged six to fourteen. GST was introduced by the 101st Amendment (2016), which created one national tax on goods and services in place of many taxes of the Centre and the States. Importance: the first makes education a legal right of every child and puts a duty on the State; the second changes the sharing of tax powers between the Union and the States, and so it needed the consent of State legislatures too. (These two amendment details are not in the chapter.)

Cover of Complete Political Science Notes for Class 11 (CBSE 2026-27)
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Political Science notes
  • For CBSE Class 11 Political Science (028), 2026-27: Indian Constitution at Work (10 chapters) and Political Theory (8 chapters)
  • All NCERT exercises solved
  • Important exam questions in the CBSE pattern (MCQ, short, long and passage-based) fully answered
US$2.99US$3.9920% off · all 18 chapters · instant PDF
Read free sample

What is inside the Chapter 9 notes →

Found a mistake or need help with a question? Message us on WhatsApp. Free study tips and new solutions: join our WhatsApp Channel.

Prices shown in US dollars. Show prices in: ₹ INR · US$ USD