NCERT Solutions · Class 11 Economics · NCERT Indian Economic Development and Statistics for Economics Indian Economic Development · Chapter 4
Chapter 4: Human Capital Formation in India (Human Capital Formation)
NCERT solutions for Class 11 Economics Indian Economic Development Chapter 4: Human Capital Formation in India (2026-27). Answers to all 20 exercises on sources of human capital, human development, education, health, women's education and government intervention, plus the in-text questions. All 32 questions are answered, with the key answer highlighted.
What are the two major sources of human capital in a country?
Solution
Investment in education and investment in health are the two major sources of human capital. (The other sources are on-the-job training, migration and information.) Spending on education raises people's future income and productivity, and health expenditure directly increases the supply of a healthy labour force.
What are the indicators of educational achievement in a country?
Solution
Educational achievements in a country are generally indicated in terms of the adult literacy level (people aged 15 and above), the primary education completion rate and the youth literacy rate (people aged 15 to 24). Table 4.2 of the chapter gives these for 1990, 2000, 2011 and 2017-18.
Adult literacy rate, primary completion rate and youth literacy rate.
Why do we observe regional differences in educational attainment in India?
Solution
Regional differences arise mainly because the amounts spent by states on education differ widely. In 2020-21 the per capita public expenditure on elementary education ranged from as high as Rs 96,968 in Sikkim to as low as Rs 10,710 in Bihar, which leads to differences in educational opportunities and attainments across states. Education expenditure is shared by the union, state and local governments, so states with fewer resources or less commitment spend less. The increase in expenditure has also not been uniform over time. Poverty also plays a part, as many people cannot afford to access basic education.
Bring out the differences between human capital and human development.
Solution
Human capital
Human development
Considers education and health as a means to increase labour productivity.
Based on the idea that education and health are integral to human well-being, as they give people the ability to read and write and to lead a long and healthy life, so that they can make other choices they value.
Treats human beings as a means to an end, the end being an increase in productivity.
Treats human beings as ends in themselves.
Any investment in education and health is unproductive if it does not raise output of goods and services.
Welfare should be increased through investments in education and health even if they do not raise labour productivity.
Basic education and health matter for their contribution to output.
Basic education and health are important in themselves; every individual has a right to be literate and lead a healthy life.
How is human development a broader term as compared to human capital?
Solution
Human capital looks at education and health only as inputs that raise labour productivity and output, so it values human beings for their contribution to production. Human development takes human beings as ends in themselves: it includes the ability to read and write and to lead a long, healthy life, and the freedom to make the choices one values, whether or not they raise productivity. Thus the human capital approach covers only the productivity side, while human development also covers the basic right to education and health care irrespective of their effect on output. Hence human development is the broader concept.
What factors contribute to human capital formation?
Solution
The sources of human capital formation are:
Investment in education: spending on education is like spending on capital goods by firms; it raises future income and productivity.
Investment in health: preventive medicine (vaccination), curative medicine, social medicine (health literacy), clean drinking water and sanitation increase the supply of a healthy labour force.
On-the-job training: firms train workers in the firm or off-campus, and the returns in higher productivity exceed the costs.
Migration: people move for higher salaries, and the higher earnings outweigh the costs of migration.
Information: spending to learn about labour market salaries, and the cost and quality of education and health services, helps decisions on investment in human capital.
How government organisations facilitate the functioning of schools and hospitals in India?
Solution
India is a federal country and expenditure on education and health is incurred simultaneously by the union, state and local governments (Municipal Corporations, Municipalities and Village Panchayats), as the Constitution lists their functions.
Education: the ministries of education at the union and state level, departments of education, and organisations such as the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), the University Grants Commission (UGC) and the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) facilitate institutions in the education sector.
Health: the ministries of health at the union and state level, departments of health, and organisations like the National Medical Commission and the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) facilitate institutions in the health sector.
The government also ensures that private providers adhere to the stipulated standards and charge the correct price.
Discuss the following as a source of human capital formation: (i) Health infrastructure (ii) Expenditure on migration.
Solution
(i) Health infrastructure. A sick labourer without access to medical facilities is compelled to abstain from work, causing a loss of productivity, whereas a healthy person gives uninterrupted labour supply for a longer time. Expenditure on preventive medicine (vaccination), curative medicine, social medicine (health literacy) and provision of clean drinking water and good sanitation directly increases the supply of healthy labour force and is thus a source of human capital formation.
(ii) Expenditure on migration. People migrate in search of jobs that fetch higher salaries than in their native places; unemployment is the reason for rural-urban migration, and technically qualified persons like engineers and doctors migrate to other countries for higher salaries. Migration involves the cost of transport, a higher cost of living and psychic costs of living in a strange socio-cultural set-up, but the enhanced earnings in the new place outweigh these costs. Hence expenditure on migration is also a source of human capital formation.
Establish the need for acquiring information relating to health and education expenditure for the effective utilisation of human resources.
Solution
People spend to acquire information about the labour market and other markets such as education and health: for example, the level of salaries associated with various types of jobs, whether educational institutions provide the right type of employable skills, and at what cost. This information is necessary to make decisions about investment in human capital and for the efficient utilisation of the human capital stock already acquired. Since individual consumers of health and education services do not have complete information on quality and costs, providers can exploit them; information therefore helps people to choose properly, avoids wasteful spending and shows where skills can be best used. So expenditure on acquiring information is itself a source of human capital formation.
How does investment in human capital contribute to growth?
Solution
Investment in education, health, training, migration and information raises the productivity of human beings. Human capital contributes substantially to increasing labour productivity, stimulates innovations and creates the ability to absorb new technologies. A healthy person provides uninterrupted labour for a longer time, and an educated person earns and contributes more to national income. As economic growth is the increase in real national income, this raises growth. The relationship runs in both directions: higher income allows more investment in human capital and a higher level of human capital raises income. The Seventh Five Year Plan also recognised that a large population, trained and educated on sound lines, can become an asset in accelerating economic growth.
'There is a downward trend in inequality world-wide with a rise in the average education levels'. Comment.
Solution
The claim is not stated in the chapter, so this comment uses its ideas. Education raises earning capacity, gives better social standing and choices, and allows more people to take part in economic life, which may narrow gaps (an inference; the chapter does not state this directly). Consistent with this, the book finds that there is a convergence in the measures of human capital (education and health) between developing and developed countries, as human capital in developing countries grew faster. However, there is no sign of convergence of per capita real income, so higher education levels have not by themselves removed inequality of income among nations. Also the evidence that human capital causes growth is nebulous because of measurement problems, and educated youth face unemployment. So education helps reduce inequality, but only if it is of good quality, spreads to all sections and is matched by jobs.
Examine the role of education in the economic development of a nation.
Solution
Education is one of the main sources of human capital. Its role in development:
It increases labour skill and productivity, so an educated worker generates more income and contributes more to growth.
It provides knowledge to understand changes in society and scientific advancements, and stimulates inventions and innovations.
An educated labour force facilitates the adaptation of new technologies; in a knowledge economy skilled labour in areas such as computer science, data science and sciences will be in greater demand (National Education Policy 2020).
It gives social standing, better choices and the ability to take part in democracy, and educated people bring social (external) benefits.
Educating women improves fertility and health outcomes and economic independence.
Economists therefore stress expanding educational opportunities as it accelerates development.
Explain how investment in education stimulates economic growth.
Solution
Spending on education by individuals is similar to spending on capital goods by companies: the objective is increasing future income over a period of time. Education raises the labour skill of a person, so he or she earns more, and since economic growth is an increase in real national income, the contribution of an educated person to growth is greater than that of an illiterate person. Education also provides knowledge that stimulates innovation, creates the ability to absorb new technologies and makes the labour force adapt quickly to technological change. Investment in education thus increases productivity, innovation and income, and hence growth. Higher income in turn permits more investment in education.
Bring out the need for on-the-job-training for a person.
Solution
On-the-job training is a source of human capital formation. Firms spend on training their workers, either in the firm itself under the supervision of a skilled worker or by sending them for off-campus training. The need for it is:
It increases the worker's skill and labour productivity, which gives higher output and higher earnings.
The training is given in the firm under the supervision of a skilled worker or off-campus, so the worker acquires the skills needed for the job.
The return from training, in the form of enhanced productivity, is more than the cost of it, to the firm and to the worker.
Firms usually insist that workers work for a specific period after training so that they can recover the benefit of the enhanced productivity.
Trace the relationship between human capital and economic growth.
Solution
Human capital raises growth: educated and healthy people have higher labour productivity, they innovate and absorb new technologies, and increase real national income.
Growth raises human capital: higher income enables higher spending on education and health. Thus the causality flows in either direction.
Empirical evidence that human capital causes growth is rather nebulous because of measurement problems: years of schooling, teacher-pupil ratio and enrolment may not reflect the quality of education, and life expectancy and mortality rates may not reflect the true health status.
Studies show a convergence in human capital measures between developing and developed countries, but no convergence of per capita real income; human capital grew faster in developing countries than per capita income.
Table 4.1 shows that these sectors have grown simultaneously: real per capita income rose from Rs 7,651 (1951) to Rs 94,054 (2018-22), literacy from 16.67 to 78 per cent, and the infant mortality rate fell from 146 to 28, so growth in each sector probably reinforced the others.
Discuss the need for promoting women's education in India.
Solution
The difference between male and female literacy rates is narrowing, which is a positive development in gender equity, but the need to promote education for women is still imminent because:
It improves the economic independence and social status of women.
Women's education makes a favourable impact on the fertility rate and on health care of women and children.
Female literacy is still much lower: in 2017-18 the adult literacy rate was 66 per cent for women against 82 per cent for men (Table 4.2), and in 1990 it was only 37.9 per cent for women.
We cannot be complacent, as there are miles to go in achieving cent per cent adult literacy.
Argue in favour of the need for different forms of government intervention in education and health sectors.
Solution
Education and health create both private and social benefits, and expenditure on them has a substantial long-term impact which cannot be easily reversed; for example, once a child is admitted to a school or health centre without the required services, substantial damage is done before the child is shifted.
Individual consumers do not have complete information about the quality and cost of services, so providers can acquire monopoly power and exploit; the government has to ensure that private providers adhere to the standards and charge the correct price (regulation).
A large section of the population lives below the poverty line and cannot afford basic education and health care, or super specialty health care and higher education; so the government should provide services free of cost for the deserving and socially oppressed classes (provision), as basic education and health care are a right.
Financing: the government spends through the union, state and local governments, institutions such as NCERT, UGC, AICTE, ICMR and the National Medical Commission, the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, and the 2 per cent education cess for elementary education.
What are the main problems of human capital formation in India?
Solution
Inadequate expenditure on education: a little over 4 per cent of GDP compared with the desired 6 per cent, with an uneven rise and fall of expenditure over time.
Regional differences: per capita public expenditure on elementary education was Rs 96,968 in Sikkim and Rs 10,710 in Bihar (2020-21).
Education for all is still a distant dream: the absolute number of illiterates is as high as India's population at independence, and the Directive Principle of free education up to age 14 has not been fully met.
Gender gap: adult literacy 82 per cent for men and 66 per cent for women in 2017-18.
The education pyramid is steep, with few reaching higher education; and unemployment among educated youth is high (in 2011-12, 19 per cent for rural male graduates and 16 per cent for urban, and nearly 30 per cent for rural female graduates), showing a lack of employable skills.
School dropouts, and child labour.
Quality concerns and lack of facilities, such as makeshift schools without classrooms and buildings; and exploitation by private providers who have monopoly power in education and health.
India has a rich stock of scientific and technical manpower, but conditions must be provided so that they are utilised in India.
In your view, is it essential for the government to regulate the fee structure in education and health care institutions? If so, why?
Solution
Sample answer: Yes. Education and health are services whose benefits go to society as a whole and whose effects, once received, cannot be reversed. Consumers do not have complete information on quality and cost, and the providers can acquire monopoly power and exploit them. A large part of the population cannot afford high fees, so many would be shut out of basic education and health care, which are rights of citizens. The book says that the government must ensure that private providers adhere to the standards and charge the correct price. Regulation of fees therefore protects access and equity, but it should be balanced so that quality is not harmed and institutions can meet costs.
Spending on education by parents is similar to spending on capital goods by companies: the objective is to increase future income. Education also gives better social standing, the ability to make better choices in life, and knowledge to understand changes in society.
Identify and collect the data from three families from different strata (very poor, middle class, affluent). Study the expenditure pattern of the families on education of male and female children.
Solution
Guidance: Prepare a simple table for each family listing yearly spending on school fees, books, tuition and other items for sons and daughters, and compare the share of income spent. Poor families usually spend less and may favour sons; affluent families spend more on all children. State your findings with data collected.
Look at Fig. 4.2 and discuss: (a) What are the advantages of having proper 'classroom'? (b) Do you think the children going to this school are receiving quality education? (c) Why these schools do not have buildings?
Solution
(a) A proper classroom gives protection from sun and rain, seating, a blackboard and teaching aids, and a quiet atmosphere with fewer disturbances, so learning is better and attendance is regular.
(b) Probably not. The figure shows a school run in makeshift premises in Delhi, with children sitting on the ground under tents with no proper classrooms, so quality of teaching and learning suffers.
(c) Such schools lack buildings because of inadequate government and private investment in education infrastructure, poverty of the people they serve, and temporary or unauthorised settlements (outside reasoning).
Do you think IT-based services in rural areas will lead to human development? Discuss. (Box 4.2: India as a Knowledge Economy)
Solution
Sample answer: The box says the value of IT depends greatly on the existing level of economic development. IT services such as e-mail and e-governance can give villagers information on markets and government services, but they lead to human development only if people have basic literacy, health, electricity and connectivity. Without these, IT will not benefit them, so basic education and health must come first.
If a construction worker, maid-servant, dhobi or a peon in school has absented herself/himself for long due to ill health, find out how it has affected her/his (i) job security (ii) wage/salary. What could be the possible reasons?
Solution
Guidance: Such workers are usually in the unorganised sector or on daily wages with no paid sick leave. A long absence often means loss of wages for the absent days, and it may lead to loss of the job because the employer replaces the worker, so both job security and income suffer. The reasons are that they have no contracts or health insurance, they are easily replaceable, and wages are paid only for work done. This also shows how poor health reduces productivity and income, which is why health expenditure is a source of human capital.
Identify the objectives and functions of NCERT, UGC, AICTE and ICMR.
Solution
Outside facts, standard: NCERT (National Council of Educational Research and Training) does research in school education, develops the curriculum and textbooks, and advises the government. UGC (University Grants Commission) coordinates and maintains standards of university education and gives grants to universities and colleges. AICTE (All India Council for Technical Education) plans and coordinates the development of technical education and approves technical institutions. ICMR (Indian Council of Medical Research) formulates, coordinates and promotes biomedical research. All of them facilitate institutions in the education and health sectors.
Prepare case studies of dropouts at different levels of schooling, say (i) Primary dropouts (ii) Class VIII dropouts (iii) Class X dropouts. Find out the causes and discuss in the class.
Solution
Guidance: Interview a few dropouts at each level and note the cause. Common causes from the chapter and general experience: poverty and the need to earn (child labour), the poor quality and lack of facilities in schools, the cost of education, and household work, especially for girls. Compare the causes at each level.
'School dropouts are giving way to child labour'. Discuss how this is a loss to human capital.
Solution
Children who leave school early and join work lose the chance to build skills and knowledge, so their productivity and lifetime earnings remain low. Fig. 4.6 shows child labour as a loss to human capital. Because investment in education is a main source of human capital, a country that pushes children into work instead of school has a lower stock of human capital and slower growth; the children also lose health and the right to education, and remain in poverty, which continues the cycle.
When compared to less educated, a large proportion of educated persons are unemployed. Why?
Solution
The chapter notes that the rate of unemployment is highest among educated youth: in 2011-12, 19 per cent for rural male graduates and above, 16 per cent for urban male graduates, and nearly 30 per cent for rural female graduates, against only 3-6 per cent for primary-level educated youth. The chapter implies that higher education institutions do not give enough employable skills, and the economy is not creating enough jobs for graduates. The less educated take whatever work is available and so show a lower unemployment rate. The government should increase allocation for higher education and improve its standards so that students get employable skills.
Interpret the data given in Table 4.2 (Educational Attainment in India).
Solution
Values (1990, 2000, 2011, 2017-18):
Indicator
1990
2000
2011
2017-18
Adult literacy, male
61.9
68.4
79
82
Adult literacy, female
37.9
45.4
59
66
Primary completion, male
78
85
92
93
Primary completion, female
61
69
94
96
Youth literacy, male
76.6
79.7
90
93
Youth literacy, female
54.2
64.8
82
90
Interpretation: All indicators improved over the years. The gender gap narrowed: in adult literacy it fell from 61.9 - 37.9 = 24.0 percentage points in 1990 to 82 - 66 = 16 points in 2017-18; in youth literacy from 76.6 - 54.2 = 22.4 points to 93 - 90 = 3 points. Female primary completion (61 per cent in 1990) overtook male completion by 2011 (94 against 92) and was 96 against 93 in 2017-18. Still, adult female literacy at 66 per cent is lower than male literacy at 82 per cent, so a gap remains.
Is India going to be a knowledge based economy in the near future? Discuss in the classroom.
Solution
Sample answer: The Indian software industry has an impressive record, India has a rich stock of scientific and technical manpower, and National Education Policy 2020 expects demand for skilled labour in data science, computer science and sciences to rise as India aims to be among the three largest economies. But the problems of low spending on education (a little over 4 per cent of GDP against 6 per cent), dropouts, gender and regional gaps, and unemployment of graduates must be solved, and the skilled manpower must be utilised in India. So it is possible if human capital formation improves in quality and reach.
As an educated person, what will be your contribution to the cause of education? (Example 'Each one - teach one').
Solution
Sample answer: I can teach a child or an adult in my neighbourhood to read and write, help children who cannot afford tuition, donate books, encourage parents to send daughters to school and keep children away from child labour, and spread awareness of the Right to Education.
Done with the answers?Now revise the whole chapter: Class 11 Economics notes
For NCERT Statistics for Economics (Class 11) and Introductory Microeconomics (2026-27 editions) - all 13 chapters of the CBSE Class 11 syllabus
Typed concept notes with labelled diagrams, tables and formulas
Every NCERT exercise solved in full: statistics numericals (mean, median, mode, correlation, index numbers) and microeconomics numericals and graphs